Doc G. Full Grown Hoser
Posts: 9718 From: Canada |
29.08.2009 - 13:13Rating: 5
Doc G.Full Grown HoserPosts: 9718 From: Canada
Br00tal. I didn't find it horrible, though I did find it quite disappointing. I heard a demo a few months back and got excited, it sounded interesting yet lack-lustre at the same time, so I hoped it was just the unmastered quality that was holding it back...nothing seemed to change.
While I wouldn't entirely agree with the severity of the rating, I really can't argue with the content of your review at all, nice review.
"...and presumably sat around playing Mario Kart with them all day..."
That part cracked me up quite a bit.
----
"I got a lot of really good ideas, problem is, most of them suck."
- George Carlin
Loading...
|
Marcel Hubregtse Grumpy Old Fuck
Posts: 40071 From: The Netherlands |
Btw the Roman history theme has been done by Maurizio a long time ago already, way before it was invogue to do such stuff. He already did that on Kataklysm's 2001 album Epic: The Poetry of War.
This ex-deo album is a bad album indeed but a 3.5 is a bit too harsh imo I would say it's on a par in crapiness with Korpiklaani's latest so a 5 would be fair.
----
Member of the true crusade against European Flower Metal
Yesterday is dead and gone, tomorrow is out of sight
Dawn Crosby (r.i.p.)
05.04.1963 - 15.12.1996
Loading...
|
HardSide
Posts: 381 From: USA
|
29.08.2009 - 14:52Rating: 7
Agree with Marcel. Review is pretty harsh, worser albums have gotten better ratings, The album does have a slow pace on some songs, but the vocals, atmosphere of the album is what make the album, the lyrics don't make up the music, if that was the case every thrash album here should have a lower rating with them just repeating the same words over and over.
Definately a 7-8 rating is deserved, this is the lowest rating I've seen for this album yet. You focus more on the members than the music itself. I suggest for others to try it out.
Loading...
|
MétalNoir Fils du Lys
Posts: 847 From: Canada |
29.08.2009 - 19:06Rating: 7
I certainly shall try to make a suitable and fair review for this great album, since I rate it 9 and I don't think it's overmade, I really love Romulus, even though it's slower than most highly commercial stuff, and I really think it is a genial idea all in all. This review is unnescesarily harsh and I will do my best to destroy it with mine.
----
Notre destinée n'est pas encore tracée....
Loading...
|
Elio Red Nightmare
Posts: 4920 From: Italy |
ElioRed NightmarePosts: 4920 From: Italy
Written by MétalNoir on 29.08.2009 at 19:06
I certainly shall try to make a suitable and fair review for this great album, since I rate it 9 and I don't think it's overmade, I really love Romulus, even though it's slower than most highly commercial stuff, and I really think it is a genial idea all in all. This review is unnescesarily harsh and I will do my best to destroy it with mine.
Who can say yours will be fair?
----
IntoPlighT said: "Slipknot is 15 years old how the fuck is that Nu metal?"
BEST. QUOTE. EVER.
Loading...
|
Bas Retired Staff
Posts: 5591 From: Switzerland |
BasRetired StaffPosts: 5591 From: Switzerland
Just started listening to "Cruor Nostis Abbas" on myspace, your review having made me pretty curious as to what it's like. I really liked the beginning (from about 00:40 untill the vocals started) and was thinking "hey, this actually isn't bad at all!". Shortly after though it suddenly all went down the drain and became one of the most boring songs I have heard since a long long time.
If the whole album is like Cruor Nostis Abbas (or perhaps it's even one of the better songs if it's on myspace?) your rating is well-deserved. Funny review too, I enjoyed reading it.
----
BAS - Beautifully Accented Sexiness
Loading...
|
K✞ulu Seeker of Truth
Posts: 2570 From: Czech Republic |
29.08.2009 - 22:21Rating: 8
K✞uluSeeker of TruthPosts: 2570 From: Czech Republic
Didn't find this album boring. Not at all. Never listened to Kataklysm either though.
----
Savor what you feel and what you see
Things that may not seem important now
But may be tomorrow
R.I.P. Chuck Schuldiner
Satan was a Backstreet Boy
Loading...
|
VPeter
Posts: 1450 From: The Netherlands |
VPeterPosts: 1450 From: The Netherlands
Great review and the grade is justified. Because this is nothing more then Kataklysm only played very slow and drawn out and tries so desperately to be epic but the only way it's epic, is epic fail.
Loading...
|
Daggon Underpaid M.D.
Posts: 1689 From: Mexico |
30.08.2009 - 08:31Rating: 4
DaggonUnderpaid M.D.Posts: 1689 From: Mexico
Well, I listened to the song Romulus when they released a video for the song (which BTW was pure crap), then I listened to some more songs, those were so boring that I almost got comatose. The rating may be a bit harsh but, c'mon, this guys and their guests are not beginners... Yes, maybe they got drunk one night and thought this was a cool idea.
Mario Kart hehehe.
----
"Les vers savent qu'ils n'ont pas d'ailes, c'est pour cela qu'ils se cachent sous terre"
Loading...
|
silenius
Posts: 527 From: Sweden |
30.08.2009 - 13:15Rating: 3
Great review, fair rating, gonna put on ''serenity in fire´´ to remind me that these guys actually can do music..
Loading...
|
enumaelis
Posts: 266 From: Spain |
30.08.2009 - 18:40Rating: 2
I agree with the review!
----
http://enumaelis.blogspot.com/
Loading...
|
Sunioj
Posts: 3894 From: Finland |
SuniojPosts: 3894 From: Finland
Agree with review. Terrible, terrible album.
Loading...
|
Njord njord
Posts: 1129 From: Portugal |
NjordnjordPosts: 1129 From: Portugal
Written by Silent Creeper on 30.08.2009 at 19:03
In my opinion fair rating would be somewhere between 5 and 6,5... Heard lot of much worse stuff which were rated higher...
I agree. This album is nothing really new, but is not so bad to deserve a 3.5
Loading...
|
Hellme666
Posts: 26 From: Canada
|
The album ain't the best shit to have seen the market in 2009, that is true. I, for myself, like the first 2-3 songs a lot, Romulus (the song) is epic and will kick some ass live.
Though, it really sounds like Kataklysm too much, just slowed down, and it saddens me that they didn't do something better. Maurizio is a great frontman/singer/songwriter, he did some amazing stuff with Kataklysm, so I had high hopes for Ex Deo...sadly, hopes are not always alright. Like I said, the first 2-3 songs are okay, but after that, it starts to sound the same stuff over and over, and it gets boring as fuck -_-
Still, I'm awaiting their first North American tour with Ensiferum this fall
----
Metal's Life, It Makes Me Live, And It's Gonna Make You Die If You Don't Like It!
Loading...
|
bloodwrage Pagan Angel
Posts: 444 From: USA
|
05.09.2009 - 09:46Rating: 6
Written by Hellme666 on 04.09.2009 at 08:44
The album ain't the best shit to have seen the market in 2009, that is true. I, for myself, like the first 2-3 songs a lot, Romulus (the song) is epic and will kick some ass live.
Though, it really sounds like Kataklysm too much, just slowed down, and it saddens me that they didn't do something better. Maurizio is a great frontman/singer/songwriter, he did some amazing stuff with Kataklysm, so I had high hopes for Ex Deo...sadly, hopes are not always alright. Like I said, the first 2-3 songs are okay, but after that, it starts to sound the same stuff over and over, and it gets boring as fuck -_-
Still, I'm awaiting their first North American tour with Ensiferum this fall
Yeah, this album isn't that good, but I hope they're at least entertaining live.
Loading...
|
Hellme666
Posts: 26 From: Canada
|
Written by bloodwrage on 05.09.2009 at 09:46
Written by Hellme666 on 04.09.2009 at 08:44
The album ain't the best shit to have seen the market in 2009, that is true. I, for myself, like the first 2-3 songs a lot, Romulus (the song) is epic and will kick some ass live.
Though, it really sounds like Kataklysm too much, just slowed down, and it saddens me that they didn't do something better. Maurizio is a great frontman/singer/songwriter, he did some amazing stuff with Kataklysm, so I had high hopes for Ex Deo...sadly, hopes are not always alright. Like I said, the first 2-3 songs are okay, but after that, it starts to sound the same stuff over and over, and it gets boring as fuck -_-
Still, I'm awaiting their first North American tour with Ensiferum this fall
Yeah, this album isn't that good, but I hope they're at least entertaining live.
Knowing Maurizio, it should be something pretty badass to see live. They better be, cuze if they suck live, they will not do another album nor tour and the live of Ex Deo will end right there.
----
Metal's Life, It Makes Me Live, And It's Gonna Make You Die If You Don't Like It!
Loading...
|
warrior_of_ice
Posts: 169 From: Canada |
Why the harsh criticisms of Romulus? This album truly foreshadows the grandeur of the Roman Empire and conveys to the listener what it meant to be a son of Rome. Personally, this piece of art inspired me believe that history and metal must be coupled in order to educate fans of metal. I strongly encourage artists to promote historical facts and events with accuracy, taste and creativity in order to maintain the memories of the past. I support Maurizio Iacono's work and kindly ask listeners to keep an open mind when listening to this album.
Loading...
|
Doc G. Full Grown Hoser
Posts: 9718 From: Canada |
16.09.2009 - 23:43Rating: 5
Doc G.Full Grown HoserPosts: 9718 From: Canada
Written by warrior_of_ice on 16.09.2009 at 21:04
Why the harsh criticisms of Romulus? This album truly foreshadows the grandeur of the Roman Empire and conveys to the listener what it meant to be a son of Rome. Personally, this piece of art inspired me believe that history and metal must be coupled in order to educate fans of metal. I strongly encourage artists to promote historical facts and events with accuracy, taste and creativity in order to maintain the memories of the past. I support Maurizio Iacono's work and kindly ask listeners to keep an open mind when listening to this album.
Open mind? Open mind to what exactly? It's an overdone concept done poorly.
----
"I got a lot of really good ideas, problem is, most of them suck."
- George Carlin
Loading...
|
warrior_of_ice
Posts: 169 From: Canada |
Overdone concept done poorly? that's subjective. not saying this album will go down in metalstorm history as 2009's greatest album, however i can't quite grasp what you see wrong with this album.
Loading...
|
Derwood
Posts: 511 From: Canada |
24.09.2009 - 08:14Rating: 8
I was pretty dismissive of this album with my first listen, but for some reason I keep going back to it and it keeps growing on me. I find its one I prefer to take in one listen as it works best as a complete album. There is a real connection between the feel of the music and the subject matter that only comes through when it is taken as a whole work that simply doesn't come across in the individual songs. The atmosphere needs time to percolate.
----
You can't fight evil with a macaroni duck!
Loading...
|
Ellrohir Heaven Knight
Posts: 8662 From: Czech Republic |
EllrohirHeaven KnightPosts: 8662 From: Czech Republic
Such a low rating surprises me after what i heard good about Ex Deo from friends...
----
My rest seems now calm and deep
Finally I got my dead man sleep
Loading...
|
Tatras
Posts: 169 From: Poland |
25.11.2009 - 20:16Rating: 1
Heh my rating is much lower than 3,5... this album is horrible :/ So boring
Loading...
|
Edmund Fogg
Posts: 1752 From: Canada |
29.03.2010 - 21:11Rating: 6
Hmmm...Well,I guess musical taste differs from a person to another.I for one loved this album when it came out.The vocals are4 superb and the slowed down paste works great to create a Doomish atmosphere.
----
You cannot sedate all the things you hate - MM
The Observer is the source of reality - Bloom
God damn it!! What did Diddy didn't do? - Satan
Loading...
|
Doc G. Full Grown Hoser
Posts: 9718 From: Canada |
01.04.2010 - 11:23Rating: 5
Doc G.Full Grown HoserPosts: 9718 From: Canada
Written by Edmund Fogg on 29.03.2010 at 21:11
Hmmm...Well,I guess musical taste differs from a person to another.I for one loved this album when it came out.The vocals are4 superb and the slowed down paste works great to create a Doomish atmosphere.
Doomish atmosphere? Man...That just seems so weird. It lacks any grooves or atmosphere that you can find in doom, but it's too slow to be any sort of threatening type extreme metal release. It's like it ripped a hole in the mediocrity continuum, and nestled in snuggly.
----
"I got a lot of really good ideas, problem is, most of them suck."
- George Carlin
Loading...
|
Edmund Fogg
Posts: 1752 From: Canada |
20.05.2010 - 01:34Rating: 6
Written by Doc G. on 01.04.2010 at 11:23
Written by Edmund Fogg on 29.03.2010 at 21:11
Doomish atmosphere? Man...That just seems so weird. It lacks any grooves or atmosphere that you can find in doom, but it's too slow to be any sort of threatening type extreme metal release. It's like it ripped a hole in the mediocrity continuum, and nestled in snuggly.
Lol.After giving it another spin today I realized I was wrong when I bought the album.It doesn't hold any Doom caracteristics and it is not a release I enjoy now as much as I did.Their is stis some catchy riffs but it truly is nothing more than background music.
----
You cannot sedate all the things you hate - MM
The Observer is the source of reality - Bloom
God damn it!! What did Diddy didn't do? - Satan
Loading...
|
Insineratehymn Account deleted |
Insineratehymn Account deleted
I agree. When I listened to this album, I thought it was really, really boring.
Loading...
|
Windrider Raureif
Posts: 684 From: Germany |
27.06.2010 - 22:42Rating: 8
Can't agree to this so-called Staff-Review, if you get behind the stories the lyrics tell you will find out that this album is a product of a good research, which deals with interesting and epic details of the Roman Empire.
You can say the music is not as good as Kataklysm (This album got me to Kataklysm and I like both bands now), but actually it has great highlights and underlines the topics in a way you would expect in a Roman-themed band.
Love this album, it is worth listening every time and sometimes gives you the feeling of a time machine!
Loading...
|
Baz Anderson
Posts: 13237 From: UK |
If I wanted a story, I'd read a book.
Loading...
|
Doc G. Full Grown Hoser
Posts: 9718 From: Canada |
28.06.2010 - 09:13Rating: 5
Doc G.Full Grown HoserPosts: 9718 From: Canada
Written by Windrider on 27.06.2010 at 22:42
Can't agree to this so-called Staff-Review, if you get behind the stories the lyrics tell you will find out that this album is a product of a good research, which deals with interesting and epic details of the Roman Empire.
You can say the music is not as good as Kataklysm (This album got me to Kataklysm and I like both bands now), but actually it has great highlights and underlines the topics in a way you would expect in a Roman-themed band.
Love this album, it is worth listening every time and sometimes gives you the feeling of a time machine!
MetalStorm is a music website. Lyrical content isn't the main focus of our reviews.
----
"I got a lot of really good ideas, problem is, most of them suck."
- George Carlin
Loading...
|
Windrider Raureif
Posts: 684 From: Germany |
28.06.2010 - 17:12Rating: 8
Written by Doc G. on 28.06.2010 at 09:13
Written by Windrider on 27.06.2010 at 22:42
Can't agree to this so-called Staff-Review, if you get behind the stories the lyrics tell you will find out that this album is a product of a good research, which deals with interesting and epic details of the Roman Empire.
You can say the music is not as good as Kataklysm (This album got me to Kataklysm and I like both bands now), but actually it has great highlights and underlines the topics in a way you would expect in a Roman-themed band.
Love this album, it is worth listening every time and sometimes gives you the feeling of a time machine!
MetalStorm is a music website. Lyrical content isn't the main focus of our reviews.
Right, the music isn't superb I know, but for me the lyrics count too, at least in this album (due to huge interest in the roman empire), so it's ok anyway, I have my own reasons rating albums and I'm fine with other's opinions.
Loading...
|