Written by Doc G. on 25.01.2010 at 18:48

Written by macraigma on 25.01.2010 at 18:45

You guys are funny, why can't you just post your favs and be done! lol

Because I've got 3 hours to kill and nothing better to do. Besides, the forum would get boring if there wasn't any arguments now wouldn't it?

I guess you're right. I mean I do like reading SOME of the arguments that go on around here. They can be entertaining.

Written by Guest on 25.01.2010 at 18:55

Written by Doc G. on 25.01.2010 at 18:44

No, it wasn't off topic, it was merely absurd. How the fuck do you know Slayer was more important than Anthrax and Megadeth? I would argue otherwise.

you tell me which is more important and influenced other bands. Metallica then Slayer then Anthrax then Megadeth its what I think. when you explained about your own list I will explain mine too.

I really would have no basis of evidence...just as I think you really don't have any evidence. You seem to be spewing out facts with virtually nothing to back it up. I'm not claiming anything, but I've seen just as many younger bands influenced by Anthrax and Megadeth as I have Slayer.

Written by Doc G. on 25.01.2010 at 18:57

Written by Guest on 25.01.2010 at 18:55

Written by Doc G. on 25.01.2010 at 18:44

No, it wasn't off topic, it was merely absurd. How the fuck do you know Slayer was more important than Anthrax and Megadeth? I would argue otherwise.

you tell me which is more important and influenced other bands. Metallica then Slayer then Anthrax then Megadeth its what I think. when you explained about your own list I will explain mine too.

I really would have no basis of evidence...just as I think you really don't have any evidence. You seem to be spewing out facts with virtually nothing to back it up. I'm not claiming anything, but I've seen just as many younger bands influenced by Anthrax and Megadeth as I have Slayer.

evidence, I have good evidence and thats why you are shocked always. how many of musicians are fans of Megadeth ? or Metallica or Slayer or Anthrax? how many Tributes they released to Megadeth, Slayer, Metallica and Anthrax. go and find.

plus I didnt see any Evidence in your words.

Goddammit, I've been polite for so long, but that was just fucking retarded. I give up, you fail to see any fucking point I'm trying to make, twist words, back up your nonsense with more nonsense and then try and turn it around into something totally different, there's really no point in trying to argue with you.

Written by Doc G. on 25.01.2010 at 19:12

Goddammit, I've been polite for so long, but that was just fucking retarded. I give up, you fail to see any fucking point I'm trying to make, twist words, back up your nonsense with more nonsense and then try and turn it around into something totally different, there's really no point in trying to argue with you.

no one has forced you to answer me with your pointless words. Im the loser, calm down.

Written by Guest on 25.01.2010 at 19:30

Im the loser, calm down.

thanks for the sig.

Written by BitterCOld on 25.01.2010 at 19:35

Written by Guest on 25.01.2010 at 19:30

Im the loser, calm down.

thanks for the sig.

LOL!

Written by Doc G. on 25.01.2010 at 19:12

Goddammit, I've been polite for so long, but that was just fucking retarded. I give up, you fail to see any fucking point I'm trying to make, twist words, back up your nonsense with more nonsense and then try and turn it around into something totally different, there's really no point in trying to argue with you.

That's exactly what I thought in one of the arguments with TBG. And I gave up too and decided not to answer the pointless, unrelated, and irrelevant post.

@Doc, I read your post again and I realized that I hadnt read your post so good, Im sorry I got you wrong.

1. Metallica
2. Slayer
3. Anthrax

H8 Megadeth!

Written by Slayer on 28.01.2010 at 21:11



H8 Megadeth!

Im lil retired what means H8 some hightway number Hanger 18

Written by Bad English on 01.02.2010 at 22:31

Written by Slayer on 28.01.2010 at 21:11



H8 Megadeth!

Im lil retired what means H8 some hightway number Hanger 18

means "hate" i guess ...

Written by Bad English on 01.02.2010 at 22:31

Written by Slayer on 28.01.2010 at 21:11



H8 Megadeth!

Im lil retired what means H8 some hightway number Hanger 18

never liked Megadeth.

Why is Anthrax even on this list?

Written by bloodwrage on 11.02.2010 at 23:41

Why is Anthrax even on this list?

Probably because Spreading The Disease and Among The Living are solid old-school thrash metal albums, they contributed to the American thrash metal movement and remain an influence in today's thrash metal scene (even with the genre change like Metallica), and if I'm not mistaken (though I'm sure Marcel will find this post and correct it if I am) Anthrax held their own in the sales department in comparison to the other bands listed. There really is no reason they should be overlooked, although the Exodus snub is unfortunate.

My vote: Metallica, purely for their work in the '80s.

Written by bloodwrage on 11.02.2010 at 23:41

Why is Anthrax even on this list?

Because it's a list about the 80s releases of The Big Four Of Thrash.

Written by bloodwrage on 11.02.2010 at 23:41

Why is Anthrax even on this list?

anthrax was big and cool enough for THIS back in the day.

Aw, Why the fuck isn't megadouche last?

80's were the best time for these bands but IMO Metallica albums were awesome in this decade.

Metallica for sure they had the best albums in the 80's

Metallica is the obvious choice but beyond that I would say megadeth for their early influence on progressive metal WHY IS SLAYER on this list cough overrated, and reign in blood is the most overrated metal album in history along with metallica's black album

Written by JohnWayneGacy666 on 02.04.2010 at 12:12

WHY IS SLAYER on this list

Like I told someone asking why Anthrax is on this list... duh, this list is about The Big Four Of Thrash.
Btw you are one funny clown calling Slayer overrated when you have them in your favourite bands list.

Written by BitterCOld on 25.01.2010 at 19:35

Written by Guest on 25.01.2010 at 19:30

Im the loser, calm down.

thanks for the sig.

pffft.. haha

Metallica's first four albums are state of the art thrash albums. Ergo, it's easily Metallica.

For me, the choice is quite easy. Slayer's old material (especially stuff until "Hell Awaits") crushes everything the 3 other bands released.

Never cared for Anthrax.
Never liked Metallica.
Not a big Megadeth fan either.

But Kreator's 80s stuff beats everything else, when it comes to Thrash.

Written by Doc G. on 25.01.2010 at 18:57

Written by Guest on 25.01.2010 at 18:55

Written by Doc G. on 25.01.2010 at 18:44

No, it wasn't off topic, it was merely absurd. How the fuck do you know Slayer was more important than Anthrax and Megadeth? I would argue otherwise.

you tell me which is more important and influenced other bands. Metallica then Slayer then Anthrax then Megadeth its what I think. when you explained about your own list I will explain mine too.

I really would have no basis of evidence...just as I think you really don't have any evidence. You seem to be spewing out facts with virtually nothing to back it up. I'm not claiming anything, but I've seen just as many younger bands influenced by Anthrax and Megadeth as I have Slayer.

In Fact I agree with that last statement...
I've been influenced alot by Megadeth and as weird as it may sound alot more by Anthrax...
I found them slightly different from the other thrash metal bands of this time and they brought something new to the genre
For that they influenced my opinion and musical taste aswell as my perception of Thrash metal

Since my favorite Megadeth stuff is in the ninety's, I'm going with Anthrax. Among the Living is probably my fav thrash album. And Spreading the Disease was pretty decent.

No surprise Metallica's up top.

So... fucking... overrated....

Written by Guest on 12.10.2010 at 03:23

Since my favorite Megadeth stuff is in the ninety's, I'm going with Anthrax. Among the Living is probably my fav thrash album. And Spreading the Disease was pretty decent.

No surprise Metallica's up top.

So... fucking... overrated....

not for their firsty three from the 80s. It seems like loads of revisionism is going on concerning 80s Metallica . None of the other 3 bands would have gone thrash were it not for Metallica.

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 12.10.2010 at 03:45

Written by Guest on 12.10.2010 at 03:23

Since my favorite Megadeth stuff is in the ninety's, I'm going with Anthrax. Among the Living is probably my fav thrash album. And Spreading the Disease was pretty decent.

No surprise Metallica's up top.

So... fucking... overrated....

not for their firsty three from the 80s. It seems like loads of revisionism is going on concerning 80s Metallica . None of the other 3 bands would have gone thrash were it not for Metallica.

Allow me to disagree with the last sentence. Slayer released "Show No Mercy" in 1983, the same year Metallica released "Kill' Em All".
Also, you neglect the fact that Metallica stole much of Mustaine's riffs on their first albums, so Megadeth would have been Thrash anyway.

You overestimate Metallica's role in the early days of Thrash. Yes, their old albums were good (and keep in mind I even consider AJFA as a good album, unlike you) but they're nevertheless overrated.

And revisionism is a necessity. I mean, looking at things now, with all we know that we ignored years ago, can give a more realistic analysis of the situation. For those of us, like you and me, who were there back then and can remember how it was, looking at things now with age and experience can help to understand many things. Time allows us to see things more as they really were, not influenced by the emotion of the moment.

Slayer were a cover band at first and started playing thrash due to the metallica Power Metal and No Life Till Lether demos, they have even said so themselves loads of times. Even Exodus and Overkill stepped it up due to those two demosl megadeth of course only started cause Dave got kicked out of the band. As for stuff so called being stolen from Dave that's actually only some stuff and not a whole lot. Remember, Dave wasn't even the first recording guitarist for Metallica, that was Lloyd Grant on Metal Massacre I