Rating:
7.2
Thine - The Dead City Blueprint
28 April 2014


01. Brave Young Assassin
02. Flame To The Oak
03. Out Of Your Mind And Into A Void
04. The Precipice
05. The Dead City Blueprint
06. A Great Unknown
07. The Rift
08. The Beacon
09. Scars From Limbo
10. Adrift Through The Arcane Isles Of Recovery


Disclaimer: This isn't metal. If you are a metal and only metal kinda person, best be off with you.

Hailing from Peaceville, home to early/mid 90's corpsepainted Norwegians howling their hatred of Zarquon and disgust for society because their mum and dad didn't buy them a pony for their 6th birthday, we have Thine, who sound exactly nothing like most of the PV roster you might be familiar with on this site.

Thine play atmospheric (dark) rock/prog. Or so other authors have decided. Apparently modern rock is as tag-nerdy as Metal. Which is to say its moody music that is far more complicated than simply bashing out barre chords.

Songs have a bit of that post-* approach to them, in that many build up from quieter verses to some more energetic choruses, like the opener "Brave Young Assassin". But this isn't a post-* so said formula is far from the end-all, be-all of song construction.

"The Precipice" does a great job of maintaining upbeat energy throughout, while others, such as "Scars From Limbo" remain lethargic.

All are laced with some great-sounding harmonies… I love the guitar tone, helps make the whole thing sing.

I'm a bit undecided on the vocals. For the most part they are good, particularly during some of the more emphatic choruses. Some of the quieter, more tender moments didn't totally connect with me.

As far as the whole "dark" thing goes, remember this is a "rock" rather than "metal", so perhaps modern Anathema is a better comparison than, say, oh, most of my metal collection. It's not superhappyfuntime, but it sure isn't soulcrushing black void. (Incidentally they recently opened for Anathema, and have done so twice before, so there you have it.)

Perhaps this is why I'm kind of flip-flopping on my overall appreciation of the album.

It's a beautiful day today, Sun is shining, little buzz from my cerveza lunch, with this playing as I type. It's good.

Earlier this week, when stuck in a largely unadorned cement apartment, on a cold and rainy day, sans WiFi and connection to the outside world, feeling a tad alone, it resonated really well and I enjoyed it much more.

So I guess that is definitely a good indicator. Most of my favorite music isn't just something I pop on whenever, I have to be in a frame of mind/mood to appreciate it.

If you like to occasionally stray out of the metal world and like rock that is neither pop saccharine nor power chord-heavy beer swilling anthems, this might be worth a spin.

Performance: 8
Songwriting: 7
Originality: 7
Production: 7


 



Written on 30.07.2014 by
Xnoybis
BitterCOld has been officially reviewing albums for MetalStorm since 2009.
More reviews by Xnoybis ››



Comments

‹‹ Back to the Reviews
Comments: 7  
Users visited: 98  
Search this topic:  


tea[m]ster - 30.07.2014 at 03:25  
Nice to see you reviewing again. This sounds like my brand of cerveza - will check it. Thanks.
Apothecary - 30.07.2014 at 04:05  
Well, this definitely sounds interesting, your tastes nearly always are. I love (dark) atmospheric music of generally all kinds, so while this may not be that "soul crushing void" I'm probably looking for as well, I'll def be checking out.
blackmamba - 30.07.2014 at 06:29  
A review of a mediocre non metal album? why did you bother? If it were a great non metal album I'd understand but is not metal and it's not even good what's the point?
M C Vice - 30.07.2014 at 09:34  
Imagine what a fine upstanding member of society Varg would have been if he's just gotten that pony he always wanted.
Xnoybis - 30.07.2014 at 15:41  
Written by blackmamba on 30.07.2014 at 06:29

A review of a mediocre non metal album? why did you bother? If it were a great non metal album I'd understand but is not metal and it's not even good what's the point?


For starters, because Peaceville sent it to me. They send me lots of great stuff, but new releases are rare. So I review. While this is a metal site we do have various discussions of non-metal musical acts. This might very well be of interest to them.

As for "mediocre", 7+ denotes a good album. It's better than many metal albums I have reviewed (and some I haven't bothered to review). That score is only "mediocre" to the peeps who flag everything 9 or 10. The very people whose opinions are care nothing about.
blackmamba - 30.07.2014 at 22:38  
Written by Xnoybis on 30.07.2014 at 15:41

Written by blackmamba on 30.07.2014 at 06:29

A review of a mediocre non metal album? why did you bother? If it were a great non metal album I'd understand but is not metal and it's not even good what's the point?


For starters, because Peaceville sent it to me. They send me lots of great stuff, but new releases are rare. So I review. While this is a metal site we do have various discussions of non-metal musical acts. This might very well be of interest to them.

As for "mediocre", 7+ denotes a good album. It's better than many metal albums I have reviewed (and some I haven't bothered to review). That score is only "mediocre" to the peeps who flag everything 9 or 10. The very people whose opinions are care nothing about.



Fair enough.

Cheers!:thumbup:
LiquidSmoke - 31.07.2014 at 01:25  
I don't think anything is as tag-nerdy as metal

And I'll give this a spin; sounds like it could be good.

Advertise on Metal Storm


Login or register to post here.



Similar topics

Forum Topic Similarity Started
Reviews The Death Of Her Money - You Are Loved 4.5 25.05.2011 by Fat & Sassy!
Reviews Botanist - I: The Suicide Tree / II: A Rose From The Dead 4 23.11.2011 by Mr. Doctor
Reviews Primordial - To The Nameless Dead 4 10.11.2008 by Deadsoulman
Reviews The Old Dead Tree - The Nameless Disease 4 09.12.2007 by
Reviews Bloodbound - Book Of The Dead 4 01.06.2007 by Susan



Hits total: 1377 | This month: 55