Metal Storm logo
Symphony X - Underworld review



Reviewer:
8.1

500 users:
8.29
Band: Symphony X
Album: Underworld
Style: Symphonic power metal, Progressive metal
Release date: July 2015


01. Overture
02. Nevermore
03. Underworld
04. Without You
05. Kiss Of Fire
06. Charon
07. To Hell And Back
08. In My Darkest Hour
09. Run With The Devil
10. Swan Song
11. Legend

After 4 years of waiting since the release of Iconoclast, Symphony X return with Underworld, an album that may divide fans of the band depending on the expectations placed on this 9th studio effort. Here we have an album of safe yet solid progressive metal tracks with few risks taken in terms of song structure, and another step away from any neoclassical elements present on earlier albums.

Underworld is a heavy progressive album with an abundance of power metal elements thrown in. "Underworld" clearly demonstrates this and really deserved to be the album opener instead of the mid-tempo and somewhat uninspired "Nevermore". Russell Allen stands out on the former with a powerful soaring chorus mixed with more aggressive vocals towards the end of the track. Despite this mistake in the order of the tracks, Underworld does enough to keep the 65 minutes interesting. Ballads like "Without You" and "Swansong" are placed between heavy tracks and just when things might get a bit samey the band throw an epic like "To Hell And Back" in the mix.

Michael Romeo continues to impress as a quality guitarist with technical yet somehow tasteful guitar solos and the ability to hold back during choruses, allowing Russell Allen to shine instead. It's just a shame that several tracks are carried with uninteresting riffs that seem beneath him. I was pleasantly surprised with the heaviness of "Kiss Of Fire," a track utilising some brief blasts on the drums and a fantastic vocal performance. It is clear from the performance of Russell Allen that he has been influenced by his work in other projects like Adrenaline Mob and Trans-Siberian Orchestra.

Despite describing the album as safe, there are some stand out moments where Symphony X extend beyond concise 5 or 6 minute tracks. "To Hell And Back" has an amazing intro that carries as a theme throughout the entire track. It's a fantastic song and has every band member on top form. Fortunately, this 9 minute track isn't the only one that shows the prowess of each band member. I was very impressed with the keyboards which seemed to always be there in the background and would suddenly appear at the forefront with a solo to stop the guitar dominating each song.

What is clear from Underworld is that Symphony X is capable of writing fine-tuned progressive metal. The album flows pretty well and has enough hooks and emotional moments to stop it simply being a technical demonstration. It is a solid effort with "Run With The Devil" being the only track that could perhaps be described as filler and the lyrics sometimes being a bit inferior to the music. Songs are catchy, riffs are for the most part memorable and do not overstay their welcome. All of this is made possible through excellent production and songwriting from a band that knows how to produce real quality musically even when playing it safe. Underworld may become divisive, but it is a solid effort that deserves your attention.


Rating breakdown
Performance: 9
Songwriting: 9
Originality: 6
Production: 10

Written by Belegûr | 13.07.2015



Guest review by
Boris_Pembroke
Rating:
8.9
Fantastic production and instrumental prowess make up for some cheesy song titles & lyrics.

Read more ››
published 27.09.2015 | Comments (4)

Guest review by
qlacs
Rating:
N/A
In medias res - I guess I'm just missing some neoclassical bits and the monumental compositions that grab me and drag me along from start to finish.

Read more ››
published 21.02.2018 | Comments (1)


Comments page 2 / 2

Comments: 38   Visited by: 575 users
02.09.2015 - 14:38
Luneth
Account deleted
When I think of 8.9 for a Symphony X album, I'm thinking Divine Wings of Tragedy, The Odyssey, and Paradise Lost. This album is waaaay below those epics. It was bland and uninspired. The moment a prog group stop pushing boundaries is the moment they fail, hence the lack of prog on the album (and even where it could be heard felt hugely recycled from previous work). Perhaps I expect too much from them, the album is OK. I just wanted more :/
Loading...
03.09.2015 - 00:29
Rating: 8
Belegûr
Arise In Might!
Written by Guest on 02.09.2015 at 14:38

When I think of 8.9 for a Symphony X album, I'm thinking Divine Wings of Tragedy, The Odyssey, and Paradise Lost. This album is waaaay below those epics. It was bland and uninspired. The moment a prog group stop pushing boundaries is the moment they fail, hence the lack of prog on the album (and even where it could be heard felt hugely recycled from previous work). Perhaps I expect too much from them, the album is OK. I just wanted more :/


You gave Iconoclast a 9 though...are you saying that album is better than the epics you mentioned?
Loading...
03.09.2015 - 09:17
Rating: 8
Daniell
_爱情_
Written by Guest on 02.09.2015 at 14:38

When I think of 8.9 for a Symphony X album, I'm thinking Divine Wings of Tragedy, The Odyssey, and Paradise Lost. This album is waaaay below those epics.


OR, people have different ways of approaching ratings. So it's no use comparing your ratings to someone else's.
Loading...
06.09.2015 - 20:37
Luneth
Account deleted
Written by Belegûr on 03.09.2015 at 00:29

Written by Guest on 02.09.2015 at 14:38

When I think of 8.9 for a Symphony X album, I'm thinking Divine Wings of Tragedy, The Odyssey, and Paradise Lost. This album is waaaay below those epics. It was bland and uninspired. The moment a prog group stop pushing boundaries is the moment they fail, hence the lack of prog on the album (and even where it could be heard felt hugely recycled from previous work). Perhaps I expect too much from them, the album is OK. I just wanted more :/


You gave Iconoclast a 9 though...are you saying that album is better than the epics you mentioned?


Iconoclast is a low 8 at best (I used to rate albums too quickly) Obviously it is not better than aforementioned albums.
Loading...
07.09.2015 - 19:50
x-avier

Written by phanto on 14.07.2015 at 02:13

This band has declined for every release since V, which was when they peaked.

they used to bring a great malmsteen-esque baroque and neoclassical-influenced prog metal. dynamic albums with long songs that could be both heavy, fast, and mellow and beautiful -- all in one track.

now they're just another heavy metal band with heavy-heavy-heavy-ballad-heavy-ballad-heavy album structures.

albeit they're still amazing musicians, the songwriting has certainly taken a plummet.



I just cant agree more with you. They were my fav prog band since they could combine everything and sound original. Now is only a heavy power metal band. RIP since paradise lost.

I've heard swang song is really nice. Thats the direction I think most of the people that liked old school SX where looking for
Loading...
19.10.2015 - 05:33
Rating: 8
MetalManic

I dunno, Nevermore is pretty sweet. The guitar work is breathless and energizing.
Loading...
17.05.2016 - 00:17
SoUnDs LiKe PoP

Written by SoUnDs LiKe PoP on 13.07.2015 at 18:09

These guys are one of those bands that I really want to like and even TRY to like... and yet everything I hear from them just falls short in catching my interest.


Well I actually listened to this album in full finally, and I actually quite enjoyed it. My favorite tracks are Underworld, Without You, and Swansong.

Perhaps I'll have to check out some of their other stuff now.
----
I lift weights and listen to metal
Loading...
26.08.2016 - 23:19
Rating: 9
BlankFile

A good and consistent album, with considerable heaviness. It has lots of amazing moments.

But i miss some of the elements that made this band, one of the biggest references in the genre. That Neoclassical feelling they´ve lost some years ago.
Loading...

Hits total: 13388 | This month: 7