Summoning - Stronghold review



Reviewer:
10

480 users:
8.97
Band: Summoning
Album: Stronghold
Release date: May 1999


01. Rhûn
02. Long Lost To Where No Pathway Goes
03. The Glory Disappears
04. Like Some Snow-White Marble Eyes
05. Where Hope And Daylight Die
06. The Rotting Horse On The Deadly Ground
07. The Shadow Lies Frozen On The Hills
08. The Loud Music Of The Sky
09. A Distant Flame Before The Sun


Bloody-Red sunset ...

Stronghold, with its bloody cover taken from an ancient painting - its epic and warm weather does not look like the previous Summoning's cool and atmospheric work, with massive spaces and assemblies just like the start of the album. You feel like an eagle rider, flying over the mountains and plains in the reach of Rohan and the Pelennor Fields, flying alongside the armies of elves and dwarves on the march, or taking up an ancient force like the rising of the sun against your eyes. The books that form the foundation of Summoning are very powerful in the space of the minimal, quiet album, revealing new and greater effects of the deep, epic music on us. Combined with very skillful craftsmanship, a kind of specialist black metal, the music has high production values for black metal, and because of this I would call it "black metallic music," to distinguish from the habitually low-quality productions of most black metal.

This album has come to bring new effects out of ancient history. You can make your own space and live in the sound of history, as if you were a wandering soul whose bady had been blown apart. This has inspired me to point out that these elven halls, alongside Middle Earth as a whole, are perhaps the embodiment of our own world, a description of the days that have been forgotten and buried under the bonds of the soil - the days when there was no energy except what we worked for, no factories, nothing but the nature of God, the candle, and the soil…

The music emitted from the keyboards, melodies with their own accent, along with the sweeping, dreaded, distant black metal riffs, make you feel the majestic halls of kings with strange architecture, full of desolate, cool, dark structures. It's a classic black-and-white distribution, the culmination of which is the last track on the album, "A Distant Flame Before The Sun." That track, which is also not produced like much black metal, is like the fires of hell and a sunset of blood. Your ears, when you get a little bit of the album's atmosphere, turn red just like this hell as you find out more and more about this album.

One of my friends has said that if Richard Wagner were alive he would become a member of Deep Purple, but I say that he would undoubtedly be a member of Summoning, because he always sought to create magnificent works and spaces of this kind. Here he would be among colleagues who in their work have references to more classic works, and take the same pride in its perfection; that borrowing is clearly visible in "Where Hope And Daylight Die," a track that shows the glory of classical music, combining a mysterious musical accompaniment with the description of a wounded warrior.

Finally, Stronghold is…

Crimson, but not conquered…
Dilapidated, but steady…
Old, but young…
Hidden, but showing…
In the bloody-red sunset…
Strong castle… strong fortress…
Stronghold…


Rating breakdown
Performance: 10
Songwriting: 10
Originality: 10
Production: 8

Written by R.Baldur | 03.09.2017


 


Guest review disclaimer:
This is a guest review, which means it does not necessarily represent the point of view of the MS Staff.


Comments

Comments: 18   Visited by: 89 users
03.09.2017 - 22:53
Dinruth
As much as I love Stronghold (seriously love it), it's still too simplistic for Wagner, I guess
Loading...
05.09.2017 - 04:40
R.Baldur
The Massenger
Written by Dinruth on 03.09.2017 at 22:53

As much as I love Stronghold (seriously love it), it's still too simplistic for Wagner, I guess


Yes, and I think the atmospher for this album is different from all of Summoning's albums, This is very special ...
----
Long Live Metal
Loading...
05.09.2017 - 11:15
nikarg
Old Nick
Nice review for a very good album. It definitely needed one
----
on and on south of heaven

Loading...
05.09.2017 - 20:45
s_t_s
Written by Dinruth on 03.09.2017 at 22:53

As much as I love Stronghold (seriously love it), it's still too simplistic for Wagner, I guess


A very nice and atmospheric album but I would not rate it 10, seriously ?! Summoning is a nice band but not the everyday day kind of metal band.
Loading...
05.09.2017 - 23:21
Metren
The What The?
Written by s_t_s on 05.09.2017 at 20:45

A very nice and atmospheric album but I would not rate it 10, seriously ?! Summoning is a nice band but not the veryday day kind of metal band.


I don't think the problem with Summoning is them not being an average run-of-the-mill band, I think the problem with Summoning is their pretty fucking weak songwriting, even their chord progressions are just so predictable and get on my nerves.
----
Dreadrealm's Bandcamp with free downloads: https://dreadrealm.bandcamp.com/ (200 Free Downloads Every Month is Bandcamp's limit)
Loading...
07.09.2017 - 01:37
R.Baldur
The Massenger
Written by nikarg on 05.09.2017 at 11:15

Nice review for a very good album. It definitely needed one


Yeah ... With this album we are in another world this album will live up to the old days
----
Long Live Metal
Loading...
07.09.2017 - 01:46
R.Baldur
The Massenger
Written by s_t_s on 05.09.2017 at 20:45

Written by Dinruth on 03.09.2017 at 22:53

As much as I love Stronghold (seriously love it), it's still too simplistic for Wagner, I guess


A very nice and atmospheric album but I would not rate it 10, seriously ?! Summoning is a nice band but not the everyday day kind of metal band.


I think metal music is now found in many genres,we can saying Sammuning is not the original heavy metal band like 80's, but we can not say Sammuning in totally isn't a metal music, Because the group's musical variety is still in the black metal style, which is one of the finest heavy metal genre.The type of summoning's sound is very original in music ...
----
Long Live Metal
Loading...
11.09.2017 - 01:58
Bad English
Masterchief
One of greatest reviews on last 10 year
----
Life is to short for LOVE, there is many great things to do online !!!

Stormtroopers of Death - ''Speak English or Die''

I better die, because I never will learn speek english, so I choose dieing
Loading...
11.09.2017 - 13:53
Daniell
_爱情_
You got a little carried away with that Wagner reference...
----
Now loving:
Hour of Penance - Cast the First Stone
Hate - Indestructible Pillar
Cradle of Filth - Heartbreak and Seance
Dark Tranquillity - Nothing To No One
Immolation - Swarm of Terror
Loading...
11.09.2017 - 15:58
R.Baldur
The Massenger
Written by Bad English on 11.09.2017 at 01:58

One of greatest reviews on last 10 year


Thank you my friend with a tribute and Respect to ScremmingStellUs
----
Long Live Metal
Loading...
11.09.2017 - 16:00
R.Baldur
The Massenger
Written by Daniell on 11.09.2017 at 13:53

You got a little carried away with that Wagner reference...


I think all wagner's works It was looking to create great spaces in music. Summoning's too. I don't want to put these two against together or comparison. I Just say Their efforts to adapt to classical music like Wagner are very respected for me.

I like all Stronghold track's and I very like this two tracks in stronghold : "The Rotting Horse on the Deadly Ground" and "The Loud Music of the Sky" :beer2:
----
Long Live Metal
Loading...
12.09.2017 - 03:23
Nicko's Nose
Written by s_t_s on 05.09.2017 at 20:45

Written by Dinruth on 03.09.2017 at 22:53

As much as I love Stronghold (seriously love it), it's still too simplistic for Wagner, I guess


A very nice and atmospheric album but I would not rate it 10, seriously ?! Summoning is a nice band but not the everyday day kind of metal band.

So them not being a generic everyday kind of metal band is not a good thing? O......k.......
Loading...
12.09.2017 - 23:21
s_t_s
Written by Nicko's Nose on 12.09.2017 at 03:23

Written by s_t_s on 05.09.2017 at 20:45

Written by Dinruth on 03.09.2017 at 22:53

As much as I love Stronghold (seriously love it), it's still too simplistic for Wagner, I guess


A very nice and atmospheric album but I would not rate it 10, seriously ?! Summoning is a nice band but not the everyday day kind of metal band.

So them not being a generic everyday kind of metal band is not a good thing? O......k.......


Where did I write "generic" ??
Loading...
13.09.2017 - 00:13
Nicko's Nose
Written by s_t_s on 12.09.2017 at 23:21

Written by Nicko's Nose on 12.09.2017 at 03:23

Written by s_t_s on 05.09.2017 at 20:45

Written by Dinruth on 03.09.2017 at 22:53

As much as I love Stronghold (seriously love it), it's still too simplistic for Wagner, I guess


A very nice and atmospheric album but I would not rate it 10, seriously ?! Summoning is a nice band but not the everyday day kind of metal band.

So them not being a generic everyday kind of metal band is not a good thing? O......k.......


Where did I write "generic" ??

Isn't that what "everyday" pretty much means? Generic, typical, whatever...
Loading...
14.09.2017 - 16:24
s_t_s
Imo generic means that we are talking about soulless and boring music while "not your everyday" kind of metal means that it is actually not typical (here I agree with you). Summoning is not a typical band and their albums are not like songs you could sing or learn by heart But I guess you and I mean the same in the end, just not using the same words To complete what I wrote I can spend months without listening to them and suddenly I feel like doing it but to speak the truth going thru almost an hour of such music isn't always so easy to digest. Not sure I'm being clear in the end
Loading...
15.09.2017 - 11:09
R.Baldur
The Massenger
Written by s_t_s on 14.09.2017 at 16:24

Imo generic means that we are talking about soulless and boring music while "not your everyday" kind of metal means that it is actually not typical (here I agree with you). Summoning is not a typical band and their albums are not like songs you could sing or learn by heart But I guess you and I mean the same in the end, just not using the same words To complete what I wrote I can spend months without listening to them and suddenly I feel like doing it but to speak the truth going thru almost an hour of such music isn't always so easy to digest. Not sure I'm being clear in the end


I agree with you. Difference in taste is normal thing. I enjoy from summoning's music, at all no problem. Colors are different
----
Long Live Metal
Loading...
17.09.2017 - 11:43
MetalButt
Best Summoning albums imo and one of the best black metal album for sure. Although i agree with the ratings the reviewer has given(except songwriting as almost everything is taken from tolkien) the review itself fails to do full justice to this epic album(maybe its just my opinion, sorry). But the album is not generic and neither is the band. i cant recall more than a handful of bands which are even 10% similar to what Protector and Silenius create even till date. The pioneers in the epic/atmospheric black metal category.
Would definitely rate it in my top 4 of all time.
Favourite Tracks - loud music of the sky, long lost to where no pathway goes, where hope and daylight dies(sung by protectors girlfriend - pretty epic)

And this is all that i can show, and this is all that you may know. . .
Loading...
18.09.2017 - 13:31
R.Baldur
The Massenger
Yes
----
Long Live Metal
Loading...

Hits total: 2138 | This month: 2138