Simple. The BM sellout battle. Both COF and DM are identified as the ultimate Black Metal Sellouts. Which one do you prefer? And why? I personally prefer Dimmu. I don't like Danni Filth's voice.

I´m not a big fan of any of those two bands, but in my opinion I think that cradle has sold out more.

i prefer dimmu cuz at least their first 2 were quite good.

cradle brought me into the metal scene tought when i was younger. But they really released only shit since midian.

Cradle of Filth has never been black metal.

Anyways, I prefer Dimmu Borgir. I like all of their albums except For All Tid and their re-make of Stormblast.

For all tid is their best release

The dude sucks at singing at it is distracting to the music.

Written by Dangerboner on 08.07.2006 at 05:19

Cradle of Filth has never been black metal.

The first few albums were (gothic) black metal. Later they became too gothic, that's why they get the extreme gothic metal label nowadays.

Anyway, my vote goes to Dimmu Borgir. Everything till Spiritual Black Dimensions is enjoyable symphonic black metal, only the last few albums are just bad. Dimmu Borgir have the talent, it is just that they prefer to sell more instead of creating classics. It is their own choice, but it is the reason why I don't like them anymore.

Cradle of Filth never really did it for me. The old material is a good introduction to the (at that time, new) gothic black metal music, but it just didn't catch my attention. Dani Filth's voice is fun for a few weeks, but after a while it becomes a source of irritation. Also, Cradle of Filth released more bad albums than Dimmu Borgir.

Written by Dangerboner on 08.07.2006 at 05:19

Cradle of Filth has never been black metal.

Anyways, I prefer Dimmu Borgir. I like all of their albums except For All Tid and their re-make of Stormblast.

Your the man
you always seem tro say whatever is on my mind
and thanks to the person who started this thread
I was going to create it as soon as they give me the premission to start one
cheers

I prefer Dimmu Borgir, I like most of their stuff ... although I have to question why the heck they went back and re-recoreded 'Stormblast'. All they did was make it sound weaker and not put a heap of effort into it (imo).

And Cradle Of Filth, well i dont like Dani's vocals and it would be bloody hard to get into a band if you cant stand the vocals.

Bouth, I even dont know, so dont wote, CoF its I dunno, its not even BM, same liek Dimmu Borgir, but some music and songs are great and listenibl

Dimmu Borgir. They had two decent albums at the start of their career, while COF has never made anything that appealed to me.

Dimmu Borgir till death, I prefer their soldout style than their pure black metal... that symphonics elemments > all

Written by AntaeusM on 08.07.2006 at 13:41


Dimmu Borgir have the talent, it is just that they prefer to sell more instead of creating classics. It is their own choice, but it is the reason why I don't like them anymore.

This is the most important thing. Besides, I don't feel sorry for this. The put out 3 amazing albums, and that's it. IMO they never could release something like THOSE again, and as long as they don't even try, it's a good thing.

Written by Stigmatized on 08.07.2006 at 16:12

Dimmu Borgir. They had two decent albums at the start of their career

Just decent? Come on, man!

I don't think Cradle of Filth can be accurately labelled a black metal sellout band. Sure, their first couple of albums had BM influences, but the gothic themes were IMO as strong as the black even back then. Sure, they became more commercial, but they're a great stepping-stone for people looking to get into extreme metal. I find it a shame however, that once people are done with CoF and have moved onto bigger things, they then join the rest of the crowd that loves to bash them. Midian is a masterpiece of an album, by any standards, yet it does not get the recognition it deserves due to peoples' willingness to blindly follow what they hear from their peers. Even the post-midian stuff is musically strong. I could rant for hours, but I know it aint gonna change anyones mind - so I won't.

As for Dimmu - Sellout or not (and this is also up for debate, but lets not linger on it), they make some fucking spectacular music nowdays. Sure, I prefer the 'proper' black metal bands to them infinitely, but I don't find cause in that to call Dimmu Borgir shit. Personally, I respect what they've done in the past, and I equally respect what they've done recently. As musical works - they deserve that at least. In comparison with CoF, their lyrics are less inspired I think, and that is important for me - so they lose out.


In short - CoF gets my vote-points, and threadstarter gets idiot-points.

Dimmu, of course. They made Progenies of the Great Apocalypse.

Written by Damned-In-Black on 08.07.2006 at 20:52

I don't think Cradle of Filth can be accurately labelled a black metal sellout band. Sure, their first couple of albums had BM influences, but the gothic themes were IMO as strong as the black even back then. Sure, they became more commercial, but they're a great stepping-stone for people looking to get into extreme metal. I find it a shame however, that once people are done with CoF and have moved onto bigger things, they then join the rest of the crowd that loves to bash them. Midian is a masterpiece of an album, by any standards, yet it does not get the recognition it deserves due to peoples' willingness to blindly follow what they hear from their peers. Even the post-midian stuff is musically strong. I could rant for hours, but I know it aint gonna change anyones mind - so I won't.

As for Dimmu - Sellout or not (and this is also up for debate, but lets not linger on it), they make some fucking spectacular music nowdays. Sure, I prefer the 'proper' black metal bands to them infinitely, but I don't find cause in that to call Dimmu Borgir shit. Personally, I respect what they've done in the past, and I equally respect what they've done recently. As musical works - they deserve that at least. In comparison with CoF, their lyrics are less inspired I think, and that is important for me - so they lose out.


In short - CoF gets my vote-points, and threadstarter gets idiot-points.

Thank you for this post. All of it makes perfect sense, and I agree with everything you've said. While I do not listen to either of these bands nearly as much as I used to, I still enjoy and respect them, and spin their albums every so often.

As I have said, repeating myself constantly across these forums, I don't think a band's image or popularity, political or religious or life or financial views or anything else have anything to do with the quality of their music. Upon listening, I pass judgement. And I have found that Cradle of Filth and Dimmu Borgir are decent bands who have released memorable albums.

gay thread

try-hard thread occupants.

lets move on

Written by Damnated on 08.07.2006 at 19:39

Written by AntaeusM on 08.07.2006 at 13:41


Dimmu Borgir have the talent, it is just that they prefer to sell more instead of creating classics. It is their own choice, but it is the reason why I don't like them anymore.

This is the most important thing. Besides, I don't feel sorry for this. The put out 3 amazing albums, and that's it. IMO they never could release something like THOSE again, and as long as they don't even try, it's a good thing.

Written by Stigmatized on 08.07.2006 at 16:12

Dimmu Borgir. They had two decent albums at the start of their career

Just decent? Come on, man!

Ok fine, they were actually pretty good for black metal.

Dimmu for me. They have the 'Fear And Wonder' instrumental, which I love. COF have sucky vocals. Dani Filth should quit his day job.

Written by LethargyMan on 08.07.2006 at 22:11

Dimmu, of course. They made Progenies of the Great Apocalypse.

Progenies of the great apocalypse is a gay song.

Written by [user id=14603] on 09.07.2006 at 11:56

Progenies of the great apocalypse is a gay song.

Well... yeah... But it's just so damned catchy. Also I'm a sucker for symphonies.

Written by Damned-In-Black on 08.07.2006 at 20:52

I don't think Cradle of Filth can be accurately labelled a black metal sellout band. Sure, their first couple of albums had BM influences, but the gothic themes were IMO as strong as the black even back then. Sure, they became more commercial, but they're a great stepping-stone for people looking to get into extreme metal. I find it a shame however, that once people are done with CoF and have moved onto bigger things, they then join the rest of the crowd that loves to bash them. Midian is a masterpiece of an album, by any standards, yet it does not get the recognition it deserves due to peoples' willingness to blindly follow what they hear from their peers. Even the post-midian stuff is musically strong. I could rant for hours, but I know it aint gonna change anyones mind - so I won't.

As for Dimmu - Sellout or not (and this is also up for debate, but lets not linger on it), they make some fucking spectacular music nowdays. Sure, I prefer the 'proper' black metal bands to them infinitely, but I don't find cause in that to call Dimmu Borgir shit. Personally, I respect what they've done in the past, and I equally respect what they've done recently. As musical works - they deserve that at least. In comparison with CoF, their lyrics are less inspired I think, and that is important for me - so they lose out.


In short - CoF gets my vote-points, and threadstarter gets idiot-points.

I also thank you for the post. But i tell you, it's like shouting in the desert. Noone that already hates the bands and has labelled them as sellouts will change their minds. Posts like yours are just a good read for people like me (f.e) that don't say they suck just to be part of the crowd.
I voted for CoF even though i have found some material by Dimmu to be a very good listen. CoF just...seems more to my likeing and i am in the minority in the thing that i don't dislike Dani's vocals. It contributes to the feeling of the music and makes them more unique.

Written by Vunts on 09.07.2006 at 14:01

I tell you, it's like shouting in the desert. Noone that already hates the bands and has labelled them as sellouts will change their minds.

The unfortunate truth. Better to get ones' views out there than keep quiet about it on account of most others disagreeing, however.

hum...difficult poll...i dont know if i will vote...i love all of the cradle stuff ive heard and i havent hear only two albuns i think(cruelty and the beast and principle of evil made flesh)...as for dimmu...i heard Puritania Euphoric Misanthropia, Death Cult Armageddon and Enthrone Darkness Triumphant, i have the remastering of Stormblast but i havent heard much of it...hum...its very hard =|

Dimmu for sure, whose music i actually like.
I really dont like it when people compare the two

I had said it before and repeat it now... Cradle Of Filth are one of the best Metal bands EVER.. couldn't care less if they succeed economically, I'm actually even glad that they do because they're among the most original and groundbreaking acts ever... enough said.

Written by [user id=14742] on 11.07.2006 at 00:58

Dimmu for sure, whose music i actually like.
I really dont like it when people compare the two

Neither does Shaggy. He seems to have a dislike towards CoF.

Written by [user id=14755] on 11.07.2006 at 01:31

Written by [user id=14742] on 11.07.2006 at 00:58

Dimmu for sure, whose music i actually like.
I really dont like it when people compare the two

Neither does Shaggy. He seems to have a dislike towards CoF.

Which reminds me
shagrath is waaaaaaay hotter than dani, thats enough to give dimmu my vote

Written by [user id=5080] on 11.07.2006 at 00:59

I had said it before and repeat it now... Cradle Of Filth are one of the best Metal bands EVER.. couldn't care less if they succeed economically, I'm actually even glad that they do because they're among the most original and groundbreaking acts ever... enough said.

A truly original opinion. I don't like COF, but I gotta respect you for that.

you didnt really have to title this poll like that did you. oh well
well i have a thing with Cradle Of Filth - i LOVE their early albums, up until 'Midian' and then i think they start going downhill
'Damnation And A Day' is actually a really really good album if people just gave it a chance and overlooked the record label and perfect production
but 'Nymphetamine' - although it has some good points isnt really my sort of thing any more. i dread hearing the new album..

Dimmu Borgir is nearly the opposite for me, the albums in the middle i get on with most
i dont listen to Dimmu Borgir as much i dont think but the music they are making now i definatly prefer over Cradle Of Filth
but i have voted for Cradle Of Filth because of the legacy and their brilliant albums that will always be there