Iron Maiden vs Metallica

Index | Search | New topics | Updated topics | New posts

Posts: 512 Visited by: 780 users

Original post

Posted by Vanhellis, 04.05.2007 - 02:29

Metallica and Iron Maiden are world wide recognized as 2 of the more important, influential, famous and outstanding bands in the history of Music, more specific Metal, so which of these 2 godlike bands you like the most?
Personally I prefer Iron Maiden because they were the ones that started the whole movement, though Metallica gave it the strenght to amaze the whole world, but you know Maiden is Maiden and they have really become legends.

Poll

Which of these 2 influential almost godlike bands you like most?

Iron Maiden

507

Metallica

251

Total votes: 758

IllNiñoSweden Posts: 331	Permalink 15.11.2007 - 16:41 IllNiñoSweden Posts: 331 Iron Maiden is better than Metalica. Loading...
bucky01403 Account deleted	Permalink 16.11.2007 - 01:23 bucky01403 Account deleted Maiden of course, if not just because of the sheer amount of quality albums. As opposed to Metallica's three and a half good to great albums. Loading...
Kharn Account deleted	Permalink 16.11.2007 - 10:43 Kharn Account deleted I Was never an iron maiden fan, they are a good band but i don't like thier style. Have listened to metallica since i was young and they got me into heavier stuff. Loading...
DrunkenFuck Thrasher! Posts: 455	Permalink 25.11.2007 - 19:54 DrunkenFuck Thrasher! Posts: 455 Written by [user id=26418] on 07.11.2007 at 00:08 When I listened to the first Metallica records was hen I became a Metal Maniac. Even when I first listened to Black Album. But when I had in my hands the Load and later records I went disspointed...and when I listened to St. Anger I wanted to trhow it trough the window, it really sucks... But Maiden goes heavier and heavier, better and better, even in the called "worst Maiden albums" there are songs that make you bang your head like no other...:wall: Well I just bought "No Prayer For The Dying", and I got to be honest, it was so disapointing. I was really surprised of how bad it actually was. I meen, to give Maiden some credit that one song "Run Silent Run Deep" was fairly good, but the rest was just awfull. I won't be hearing that album very much, that's all I can say. I hope that Prayer is the Maiden St. Anger album, coz if not... Well that's sad. ---- THRASH!!! Loading...
Sticksrock Account deleted	Permalink 25.11.2007 - 22:49 Sticksrock Account deleted I would choose any Maiden song over any Metallica song. For me Maiden have been the most consistent band. A lot of other bands decide to do something really different to their usual stuff but Maiden have stayed pretty much the same with a few obvious exceptions. I dont get why Metallica decided to change so much after making 3-4 great albums Loading...
Smurfophagist Posts: 1069	Permalink 25.11.2007 - 23:15 Smurfophagist Posts: 1069 Well that is a very hard choice...I don't really know... They both had their good days and their bad days. I would choose Master of Puppets over No Prayer For The Dying any day, but the same goes for Matter Of Life And Death over St. Anger. This is very hard for me to decide. Even though my girlfriend hates Metallica and Maiden is her favorite band ---- Having a signature is an absolute must. Loading...
panchowl Posts: 414	Permalink 26.11.2007 - 06:06 panchowl Posts: 414 This poll is so easy for me, Iron Maiden of course! The best band on earth! Metallica, what can I say? the Black Album was their last respectable album! (from they beginning to this realese I love all of their albums!) but I mean: 1996 ("Load" album) to present... 11 years of only pile of shit!!! This can't compare with the 27 glorious years of Iron Maiden! Sorry if I offend somebody, not my intention Loading...
GT Coffee!! Staff Posts: 5101	Permalink 26.11.2007 - 21:28 GT Coffee!! Staff Posts: 5101 Written by panchowl on 26.11.2007 at 06:06 [...] Sorry if I offend somebody, not my intention Sure it was ---- Dreams are made so we don't get bored when we sleep Loading...
In Chaos Posts: 69	Permalink 27.11.2007 - 12:22 In Chaos Posts: 69 Iron Maiden is so much better than Metallica. don't get me wrong, Metallica is bad ass, but nothing compared to Iron Maiden. Loading...
Smurfophagist Posts: 1069	Permalink 27.11.2007 - 18:45 Smurfophagist Posts: 1069 Written by panchowl on 26.11.2007 at 06:06 This can't compare with the 27 glorious years of Iron Maiden! Well, i don't know, Death On The Road and Matter Of Life And Death kinda sucked ass. No offense this is just my modest opinion ---- Having a signature is an absolute must. Loading...
panchowl Posts: 414	Permalink 28.11.2007 - 00:14 panchowl Posts: 414 That's perfect brothers! All of we think different and have different points of view in Metal! And of course, I respect all opinions! Loading...
Dreamwar_86 To Arms! Posts: 480	Permalink 28.11.2007 - 06:14 Dreamwar_86 To Arms! Posts: 480 damn this is too diffucult i just love 2 bands mmm i vote Iron Maiden because they havent released such bad albums like Metallica´s Load Reload and St. Anger ---- Stay Metal !!! Loading...
Timsen Account deleted	Permalink 28.11.2007 - 23:05 Timsen Account deleted Written by In Chaos on 27.11.2007 at 12:22 Iron Maiden is so much better than Metallica. don't get me wrong, Metallica is bad ass, but nothing compared to Iron Maiden. Absolutely correct. By the way I did not await that Metallica may have more votes then Maiden... ;-) Iron Maiden is much more multi-faceted and melodic. Loading...
Metalbound7 Posts: 229	Permalink 08.12.2007 - 01:47 Metalbound7 Posts: 229 the two bands that get me into metal!! Metallica "was" a great band but i have to choose Maiden whitout doubt. man, is iron Maiden, they are Gods! Loading...
mankvill Posts: 429	Permalink 08.12.2007 - 02:13 mankvill Posts: 429 Iron Maiden by far. It's not even really a fair fight, in my opinion. Loading...
Moeror Posts: 51	Permalink 08.12.2007 - 02:40 Moeror Posts: 51 Even though their style differ, Iron Maiden wins hands down!!! ---- On the plain lies an angel, dead Loading...
xVovax Posts: 12	Permalink 12.12.2007 - 18:23 xVovax Posts: 12 i think that Iron Maiden is better,but metallica is not bad. Loading...
Lucas Mr. Noise Elite Posts: 13427	Permalink 12.12.2007 - 18:34 Lucas Mr. Noise Elite Posts: 13427 Ride The Lightning. The only really good album I know of the two bands. ---- SLUDGE. DOOM. DEATH. Wait, what? "The reason I'm running for president is because I can't be Bruce Springsteen." - Barack Obama Loading...
Warman Erotic Stains Posts: 7695	Permalink 12.12.2007 - 19:09 Warman Erotic Stains Posts: 7695 Haha, I actually love like 95 % of the studio albums from both these bands. But then again, those two where my very first Metal bands. ---- Loading...
Lord TJ Posts: 1522	Permalink 12.12.2007 - 20:29 Lord TJ Posts: 1522 I think its safe to say that Iron Maiden kicked Metallica's ass in this site. But yea, Im seeing a lot of posts of people just stating what they voted. WHY DID YOU VOTE FOR WHO YOU VOTED FOR?!?!?!?!?! ---- Visit the "Black Metal Page" on facebook, my page delivers everything black metal - Memes - Music - Humor - Interviews - Discussion. https://www.facebook.com/TheBMPage Loading...
Warman Erotic Stains Posts: 7695	Permalink 12.12.2007 - 20:41 Warman Erotic Stains Posts: 7695 Written by Lord TJ on 12.12.2007 at 20:29 I think its safe to say that Iron Maiden kicked Metallica's ass in this site. But yea, Im seeing a lot of posts of people just stating what they voted. WHY DID YOU VOTE FOR WHO YOU VOTED FOR?!?!?!?!?! I agree man, it's so annoying! Still it's nothing compared to the "Top 10 albums/songs"-topics! ---- Loading...
Demonmayonnaise Posts: 362	Permalink 12.12.2007 - 21:00 Demonmayonnaise Posts: 362 Iron Maiden won my vote easily. Metallica was good, i give them that. But its fucking Iron Maiden... Need I say more? Loading...
Philaenas Account deleted	Permalink 13.12.2007 - 16:44 Philaenas Account deleted My vote went to Iron Maiden. I just love their style a whole lot more! And they give a killer live performance (never seen Metallica live though...). Somehow Metallica doesn't do it for me. Loading...
MetallicA Posts: 909	Permalink 13.12.2007 - 23:13 MetallicA Posts: 909 haha yeah you guys know what I picked... ---- God's disciples want you to die! In the blazing inferno Slewed on Satan's pitchfork Burning for eternity Death I see it coming your way by my hand... or by your fate with no remorse. Loading...
Oskmrgo83 Oskmrgo83 Posts: 226	Permalink 13.12.2007 - 23:43 Oskmrgo83 Oskmrgo83 Posts: 226 Written by MetallicA on 13.12.2007 at 23:13 haha yeah you guys know what I picked... Yeah! I support your vote. My favorite band... is with Iron Maiden in a extreme battle. Metallica is my favorite one... and Iron Maiden is my wife's favorite one. So, Metallica rules!!!! So, I just know that I was in the Metallica concert in 99 (Bogotá). Now, I'll go to the Iron Maiden show with my wife. But, just try to remember one main idea... Metallica rules the world!!!!!!! ---- Now it's time to... rock!!!!! Loading...
Ascalon Posts: 212	Permalink 18.12.2007 - 18:30 Ascalon Posts: 212 Maiden it's just an amazing, huge, and awesome band ... a classic of classics, byt maybe Metallica for me has more power in their musical proposal and more ideas in ther lyrics, it's difficult to choose definetely but if I have to make a decission I would vote for Metallica... sorry Maiden : ( ---- "Follow your steps and you'll find, the unknown ways are on your mind" (Angra) Loading...
JunN_Vai Posts: 53	Permalink 24.12.2007 - 04:44 JunN_Vai Posts: 53 Maiden n Metallicva huh....their both are great. I like them. And to you guys who hate Metallica at all, just remember that they have many hard time, and as we know hard time can make people better and better (experience is a good teacher). Beside that, Metallica promised to all headbangers, they will make Master of Puppets sound like album in 2008. Just wait and see... And once again, I like both....... Loading...
phantasmagoria72 Account deleted	Permalink 24.12.2007 - 07:25 phantasmagoria72 Account deleted if bruce would sing in maiden like he sings on his solo shit i be a little more swayed metallica gets my vote for most listenable for the last 30 yrs Loading...
phantasmagoria72 Account deleted	Permalink 24.12.2007 - 07:28 phantasmagoria72 Account deleted Written by [user id=27817] on 24.12.2007 at 07:25 if bruce would sing in maiden like he sings on his solo shit i be a little more swayed metallica gets my vote for most listenable for the last 30 yrs Loading...
Alex Smith Posts: 167	Permalink 30.12.2007 - 02:54 Alex Smith Posts: 167 I am a huge fan of Iron Maiden. And I'm bored of Metallica (perhaps, because I was playing drums a lot of their songs in the past). Anyway, Iron Maiden's music more melodic, than Metallica's... Loading...

Papangu	Föhn
Solstitium	Arð

	Adorior Bleed On My Teeth
	Unto Others Never, Neverland
	Dreamless Veil Every Limb Of The Flood
	The Jesus Lizard Rack
	Cyborg Octopus Bottom Feeder
	Siderean Spilling The Astral Chalice
	Nightwish Yesterwynde
	Groza Nadir
	Pyracanda Losing Faith
	Speedrush Division Mortality

	Wait A Minute! This Isn't Metal! August 2024
	Clandestine Cuts Vol. 14 Issue #8 Awesome New Demos and EPs
	Rockstadt Extreme Fest 2024
	ArcTanGent 2024
	Bloodstock 2024
	Abattoir's Concert Hunt The Summer Adventures (2024)
	Wait A Minute! This Isn't Metal! July 2024
	ArtMania Festival 2024

1.	Wintersun Time II
2.	Nightwish Yesterwynde
3.	Wolfheart Draconian Darkness
4.	Officium Triste Hortus Venenum
5.	Unto Others Never, Neverland
6.	Leprous Melodies Of Atonement
7.	Flotsam And Jetsam I Am The Weapon
8.	Dark Tranquillity Endtime Signals
9.	Kanonenfieber Die Urkatastrophe
10.	Spectral Wound Songs Of Blood And Mire

1.	Megadeth Rust In Peace
2.	Judas Priest Painkiller
3.	Death Symbolic
4.	Metallica Master Of Puppets
5.	Opeth Blackwater Park
6.	Metallica Ride The Lightning
7.	Black Sabbath Paranoid
8.	Iron Maiden Powerslave
9.	Death The Sound Of Perseverance
10.	Agalloch The Mantle