Favorite Shining Album

NO SHINING POLL!?

I've listened to few albums by Shining, and from what I heard I think I enjoyed II the most, specially songs like, Annu Ett Steg N?rmare Total Utfrysning, Dod, and Svart, so I voted for II.

V will win this hands down, even though III is the superior record ;]

What's the big deal about V anyway? it's just an average album if you ask me.

"V - Halmstad" is one of my favourite albums ever. It has everything a Shining album needs. The lyrics are great, the music is catchy as hell, yet depressive and Kvarforth's vocals are better and more emotional than before. Let's not forget that "Låt oss ta allt från varandra" is one of the best songs ever and has the best lyrics ever written in my opinion.

People will probably throw razorblades at me, but I think the second best album by Shining is actually "VI - Klagopsalmer".

Written by Warman on 28.12.2011 at 18:20

People will probably throw razorblades at me, but I think the second best album by Shining is actually "VI - Klagopsalmer".

DODGE, BITCH!

III wins by a microscopic hair. V is catchier, I dig Kvarfoth's vocals more and it's just more varied and interesting overall, but III is just a piece of chocking, oppressive sickness in it's purest form.

It's very close between IV and V for me... I voted V in the end though. I've only been into this band for maybe half a year, so I don't know their discography inside out, but III and VI are also very good...

Never gave a fuck at this band, as I hate depressive Black Metal.

Written by [user id=28526] on 28.12.2011 at 18:10
What's the big deal about V anyway?

They went more prog and the songwritting overall got more complex without losing their original touch, which can't be said about the albums that came after that are just going downhill, no passion now.

I have to give the albums a new listen but right now it feels like III, IV or V are the best ones to me.

Written by RavenKing on 28.12.2011 at 21:25

Never gave a fuck at this band, as I hate depressive Black Metal.

So do I but III has something special about it. You could give it a go and see what you think. I can count how many DSBM bands I like on one hand and still have digits left over.

Written by [user id=4365] on 28.12.2011 at 22:31
I can count how many DSBM bands I like on one hand and still have digits left over.

Which ones? Xasthur maybe?

Written by X-Ray Rod on 28.12.2011 at 23:14


Which ones? Xasthur maybe?

It's funny, I don't even consider Xasthur DSBM, even though I suppose they are. In my mind it's more ambient black metal. But yeah I like Xasthur.

Written by [user id=4365] on 28.12.2011 at 23:17

It's funny, I don't even consider Xasthur DSBM, even though I suppose they are. In my mind it's more ambient black metal. But yeah I like Xasthur.

Yeah, it's kind of in between but tbh I don't know what DSBM really is musically...

Written by X-Ray Rod on 28.12.2011 at 23:19


Yeah, it's kind of in between but tbh I don't know what DSBM really is musically...

*shrugs* Though I usually know it because I don't like it. Xasthur is far murkier and grittier than 99% of overly emphatic DSBM bands.

Written by [user id=4365] on 28.12.2011 at 23:20

*shrugs* Though I usually know it because I don't like it. Xasthur is far murkier and grittier than 99% of overly emphatic DSBM bands.

The thing that gets me is that I just know when a bm band is dsbm but I can't explain why musically.

Only one vote for IV?! I have to change it.

Written by Paz on 29.12.2011 at 21:53
Only one vote for IV?! I have to change it.

It got my vote too.

Easily III

III easily for me as well. I think II and III get less recognition because less people have heard them.

The Eriee Cold

I just made this account to show vii some love.

Hard to choose, I love the first five albums. But the one that I listen the most is IV.