I love, love, love this album. It was my introduction to Agalloch and I remember the day I first grabbed it vividly. It was raining and as I listened to it I could hear the heavy rain on top of it. It created an atmosphere I still remember to this day whenever I listen to it. It gives me chills.

One of the few albums I can say is a 'classic' of metal and music in whole.

Written by [user id=147752] on 03.03.2014 at 17:00

I love, love, love this album. It was my introduction to Agalloch and I remember the day I first grabbed it vividly. It was raining and as I listened to it I could hear the heavy rain on top of it. It created an atmosphere I still remember to this day whenever I listen to it. It gives me chills.

One of the few albums I can say is a 'classic' of metal and music in whole.

Pretty much the same case for me, of course it was a hazy evening in Dubai and I was listening to it while I was studying calculus on the bus and I was on my way to the institute.

Written by [user id=4365] on 23.03.2012 at 21:15

Neither do I ;]

It pains me to say this, but you just lost a part of your credibility.

Written by Erik M. on 29.03.2014 at 22:19


It pains me to say this, but you just lost a part of your credibility.

My 5 score is incredibly harsh. While I don't find them that exciting I can tell it's quality stuff. This album is overdue for a re-listen anyway.

Written by [user id=4365] on 29.03.2014 at 22:30

My 5 score is incredibly harsh. While I don't find them that exciting I can tell it's quality stuff. This album is overdue for a re-listen anyway.

A 5 is indeed a harsh score for an album like this. Good to hear you're giving it a second (?) chance.

Written by [user id=4365] on 29.03.2014 at 22:30

My 5 score is incredibly harsh. While I don't find them that exciting I can tell it's quality stuff. This album is overdue for a re-listen anyway.

Ah I'm very glad to hear you say that.
This album really holds a special place in my heart. From the first time I heard it, and with every single subsequent listen, I've felt an emotional attachment which only about four other albums can evoke.

Written by Alex F on 30.03.2014 at 17:49

Ah I'm very glad to hear you say that.
This album really holds a special place in my heart. From the first time I heard it, and with every single subsequent listen, I've felt an emotional attachment which only about four other albums can evoke.

I don't think I could ever get that kind of connection from it. I think that kind of thing only happens at certain stages of music listening, and I'm probably far too old and jaded and have all those albums under my belt already

I love it... and I'm glad it took me so long to check out becayse after doing that I realised it's real impact on quite a few bands. I really like how sometimes it feels like it's only 50% metal and 50% neo-folk. The balance is fantastic and their use fo acoustic guitars is perfect.

Written by X-Ray Rod on 01.04.2014 at 21:12

their use fo acoustic guitars is perfect.

Totally agreed, the best usage of acoustic guitars in metal I've heard.

Written by [user id=4365] on 30.03.2014 at 17:54

I don't think I could ever get that kind of connection from it. I think that kind of thing only happens at certain stages of music listening, and I'm probably far too old and jaded and have all those albums under my belt already

I to am old and jaded, and found this record well into my musical journey...but for me, it was instant captivation and awe!

All I can say is that this album (with its predecessor) is and will be a part of me forever.

Written by Maco on 15.05.2014 at 06:37

All I can say is that this album (with its predecessor) is and will be a part of me forever.

Agree.

Written by [user id=147752] on 03.03.2014 at 17:00

I love, love, love this album. It was my introduction to Agalloch and I remember the day I first grabbed it vividly. It was raining and as I listened to it I could hear the heavy rain on top of it. It created an atmosphere I still remember to this day whenever I listen to it. It gives me chills.

One of the few albums I can say is a 'classic' of metal and music in whole.

That's just beautiful I see this and other albums the same way. It has an unique atmosphere, you need to experience it, like a good Death/Doom album.

Written by [user id=136611] on 31.01.2014 at 06:43

No Agalloch album has failed me yet!

EP's and later ones are weaker IMO

Why must be everything with shrieking vocals labeled as Black Metal? With this,there's almost more clean vocals than harsh...

Written by [user id=4365] on 29.03.2014 at 22:30

My 5 score is incredibly harsh. While I don't find them that exciting I can tell it's quality stuff. This album is overdue for a re-listen anyway.

And did you revisit it?

Written by Erik M. on 20.01.2015 at 23:11


And did you revisit it?

Noooope ^_^

Written by [user id=4365] on 20.01.2015 at 23:13

Noooope ^_^

Listening to this album was the weirdest thing in my life.I went through about half of it and was like:"Why is this considered such a good album? It's boring and repetitive",but then after a few more songs I realized my mood was changing according to the song's mood.I couldn't believe it!This isn't and album you listen to,this is an album you feel and live through and I love it for that.

AATG got me into Agalloch, and it is truly one of the greatest metal albums that exists, but this album is somehow even better. A Desolation Song is somewhat dispensable, and the album might arguably be slightly stronger with its absence in terms of 'perfection', but the rest of the album is so truly extraordinary that there's not much else to say about the album except - 'glorious'. A marvel of musical composition, fusion of neofolk, acoustic guitars and atmosphere with blast beats and BM shrieks in a way that shall likely never be matched. They've released marvellous music since (particularly on the otherwordly AATG), but this album secured Agalloch's place in history with its release. In The Shadow..., Odal and The Hawthorne Passage just by themselves practically defy belief, and including Wooden Doors, Ghost In Your Arms and The Great Cold Death, plus the rest, just oh my

Written by musclassia on 12.07.2015 at 02:08

AATG got me into Agalloch, and it is truly one of the greatest metal albums that exists, but this album is somehow even better. A Desolation Song is somewhat dispensable, and the album might arguably be slightly stronger with its absence in terms of 'perfection', but the rest of the album is so truly extraordinary that there's not much else to say about the album except - 'glorious'. A marvel of musical composition, fusion of neofolk, acoustic guitars and atmosphere with blast beats and BM shrieks in a way that shall likely never be matched. They've released marvellous music since (particularly on the otherwordly AATG), but this album secured Agalloch's place in history with its release. In The Shadow..., Odal and The Hawthorne Passage just by themselves practically defy belief, and including Wooden Doors, Ghost In Your Arms and The Great Cold Death, plus the rest, just oh my

I completely disagree that A Desolation Song is dispensable, it has a very important part in the album. It's supposed to sound notably different from the rest of the album, it's the acoustic closer of the album as a whole. Really without A Desolation Song the album is just a bunch of similar sounding songs rather than a complete album. Beautiful songs, but similar sounding none the less.

Written by Ganondox on 12.07.2015 at 05:24


I completely disagree that A Desolation Song is dispensable, it has a very important part in the album. It's supposed to sound notably different from the rest of the album, it's the acoustic closer of the album as a whole. Really without A Desolation Song the album is just a bunch of similar sounding songs rather than a complete album. Beautiful songs, but similar sounding none the less.

Ha, that was a nice little drunken rambling there last night. Hmm, I mean it is different and I suppose it does act as a nice counterpoint to the rest of the album, I just always found it to be a kinda weird song and one that I was never fully keen on. Occasionally I've finished listening to the album with ...And The Great Cold Death and it sounds like a really nice cohesive package. Desolation Song adds a different dimension, but a somewhat imperfect one for me that almost takes away as much as it adds.

Written by NorthernDickhead on 26.12.2014 at 19:17

Why must be everything with shrieking vocals labeled as Black Metal? With this,there's almost more clean vocals than harsh...

I think you'll find that most people don't actually consider this a black metal album. The band even stated that at the time they were more into post-rock like Godspeed You! Black Emperor rather than metal

Written by musclassia on 12.07.2015 at 02:08

AATG got me into Agalloch,

same here it was mate Lupas who had this lbum artwork a goat and hors, it was awesome, at first I thought some shity metalcore band , I tried then I knew its a great one, I thought its Norwegian, then I found out its an USA band from Oragon... maybe one of bets discoveries in my life thanks to this site

Written by Bad English on 20.03.2016 at 00:34

Written by musclassia on 12.07.2015 at 02:08

AATG got me into Agalloch,

same here it was mate Lupas who had this lbum artwork a goat and hors, it was awesome, at first I thought some shity metalcore band , I tried then I knew its a great one, I thought its Norwegian, then I found out its an USA band from Oragon... maybe one of bets discoveries in my life thanks to this site

How the bleep is the artwork of aatg a goat and horse?

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 20.03.2016 at 03:09

Written by Bad English on 20.03.2016 at 00:34

Written by musclassia on 12.07.2015 at 02:08

AATG got me into Agalloch,

same here it was mate Lupas who had this lbum artwork a goat and hors, it was awesome, at first I thought some shity metalcore band , I tried then I knew its a great one, I thought its Norwegian, then I found out its an USA band from Oragon... maybe one of bets discoveries in my life thanks to this site

How the bleep is the artwork of aatg a goat and horse?

hat artwork what MS has, isn't it goat ? and horns. BTW when Lupas introduced me whit it I thought its so unmetal , good I listened it I was stupid at age 22

Written by Bad English on 20.03.2016 at 03:12

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 20.03.2016 at 03:09

Written by Bad English on 20.03.2016 at 00:34

Written by musclassia on 12.07.2015 at 02:08

AATG got me into Agalloch,

same here it was mate Lupas who had this lbum artwork a goat and hors, it was awesome, at first I thought some shity metalcore band , I tried then I knew its a great one, I thought its Norwegian, then I found out its an USA band from Oragon... maybe one of bets discoveries in my life thanks to this site

How the bleep is the artwork of aatg a goat and horse?

hat artwork what MS has, isn't it goat ? and horns. BTW when Lupas introduced me whit it I thought its so unmetal , good I listened it I was stupid at age 22

ummmmmm are u still Bad English at 22?

Written by Alex F on 10.10.2015 at 07:32

Written by NorthernDickhead on 26.12.2014 at 19:17

Why must be everything with shrieking vocals labeled as Black Metal? With this,there's almost more clean vocals than harsh...

I think you'll find that most people don't actually consider this a black metal album. The band even stated that at the time they were more into post-rock like Godspeed You! Black Emperor rather than metal

This is where Ms genre system fails again. This band isn't really black metal. Many bands in here get that tag to easily.

I'm finally, very very slowly learning to appreciate this album and this band. Can't wait for the right moment to listen to this in the winter by the fireplace with a glass of mulled wine in my hand.

10000000000000000000000000000000000000/10