Jiri
Posts: 710 |
Loading...
|
Nemo Atkins
Posts: 257
|
Written by Jiri on 16.08.2013 at 17:10
Poor Floor...
We don't know how this might work out. For all we know, she'll be announced as the new vocalist (both sides certainly sound like they would like to work together, from what I've read) and the next album will be...I don't want to say "better" than the Annette material, since I quite enjoy it myself and didn't actually mind her in Nightwish (granted, I've never seen them live), but maybe more in line with the Tarja material (which I don't know much of, but what I have heard is certainly very enjoyable).
Personally, I'm on the fence whether it would be good to have Floor in Nightwish, since her current band would not really be able to do much while she is with Nightwish (not that I'm complaining about that: I wasn't fond of ReVamp's first album) and some people would complain that it means After Forever is almost guaranteed to never reform, but we would get a vocalist who can perform music from both eras of Nightwish without necessarily being an impersonator of either Tarja or Annette and it would encourage people to check out both ReVamp and After Forever (if they haven't already) to see what Floor is capable of with material that was written for her voice.
I guess we'll just have to wait and see how this turns out...
Loading...
|
PocketMetal
Posts: 750
|
The female vocals were the only down-side in the recent albums , and tbh I wasn't a fan of Tarja either ... so an album with Floor can easily become my favorite from NW.
Loading...
|
Enissa
Posts: 816 |
Floor in Nightwish would be a fresh start for the band, and a very good choice in all aspects, but Tuomas needs to reconsider his musical direction, as the Disney-tique/fairytale/soundtrack themed composition in the recent album might not work with Floor.
Which I doubt he will if he is already trying to compose a soundtrack album again :\
Loading...
|
Jiri
Posts: 710 |
Quote: We don't know how this might work out. For all we know, she'll be announced as the new vocalist (both sides certainly sound like they would like to work together, from what I've read) and the next album will be...I don't want to say "better" than the Annette material, since I quite enjoy it myself and didn't actually mind her in Nightwish (granted, I've never seen them live), but maybe more in line with the Tarja material (which I don't know much of, but what I have heard is certainly very enjoyable).
Personally, I'm on the fence whether it would be good to have Floor in Nightwish, since her current band would not really be able to do much while she is with Nightwish (not that I'm complaining about that: I wasn't fond of ReVamp's first album) and some people would complain that it means After Forever is almost guaranteed to never reform, but we would get a vocalist who can perform music from both eras of Nightwish without necessarily being an impersonator of either Tarja or Annette and it would encourage people to check out both ReVamp and After Forever (if they haven't already) to see what Floor is capable of with material that was written for her voice.
I guess we'll just have to wait and see how this turns out...
You're right, we don't know. However, they have been dragging their feet on announcing her as the new vocalist. It won't happen. Even if it does, Tuomas isn't writing the new album with her vocals in mind. He is just writing music for any vocalist. If he was sure Floor was his vocalist, he probably would have started the writing process for her vocals. Who knows, maybe he is. Maybe he is holding suspense. But it is kind of getting ridiculous now. Floor has been touring with the band for almost a year now. Would he really wait four more months to announce that the vocalist is the woman who has already been singing with the band for such a long time? I am doubtful. If she is to be their new singer, t'would have been disclosed by now. Poor Floor...
Loading...
|
Nemo Atkins
Posts: 257
|
Quote:
Written by Jiri on 16.08.2013 at 18:46
We don't know how this might work out. For all we know, she'll be announced as the new vocalist (both sides certainly sound like they would like to work together, from what I've read) and the next album will be...I don't want to say "better" than the Annette material, since I quite enjoy it myself and didn't actually mind her in Nightwish (granted, I've never seen them live), but maybe more in line with the Tarja material (which I don't know much of, but what I have heard is certainly very enjoyable).
Personally, I'm on the fence whether it would be good to have Floor in Nightwish, since her current band would not really be able to do much while she is with Nightwish (not that I'm complaining about that: I wasn't fond of ReVamp's first album) and some people would complain that it means After Forever is almost guaranteed to never reform, but we would get a vocalist who can perform music from both eras of Nightwish without necessarily being an impersonator of either Tarja or Annette and it would encourage people to check out both ReVamp and After Forever (if they haven't already) to see what Floor is capable of with material that was written for her voice.
I guess we'll just have to wait and see how this turns out...
You're right, we don't know. However, they have been dragging their feet on announcing her as the new vocalist. It won't happen. Even if it does, Tuomas isn't writing the new album with her vocals in mind. He is just writing music for any vocalist. If he was sure Floor was his vocalist, he probably would have started the writing process for her vocals. Who knows, maybe he is. Maybe he is holding suspense. But it is kind of getting ridiculous now. Floor has been touring with the band for almost a year now. Would he really wait four more months to announce that the vocalist is the woman who has already been singing with the band for such a long time? I am doubtful. If she is to be their new singer, t'would have been disclosed by now. Poor Floor...
Fair point. On the other hand, she was originally called up just to fill in for the tour, which did have a lot of announced shows before it started. Some singers do later go on to join the band they did touring vocals for (Tommy Karevik sung a few songs for Kamelot before he joined them, although I suppose that was more a gigantic audition process which included a tour...), so who knows?
All I'm hoping for at the minute is that, if Tuomas doesn't ask Floor to join Nightwish, he also doesn't get someone who sounds like Anette. Again, I don't dislike Anette's vocals with Nightwish, but I rather doubt fans of Anette and Tarja would be happy with an Anette sound alike. Then again, I doubt they would be happy with a Tarja sound alike, so I kind of get the feeling they need someone who doesn't sound like either vocalist, but can sing material from both vocalists confidently...I wonder what Amanda Somerville is doing these days?
(OK, kidding about Amanda Somerville...)
Loading...
|
AngelofDeth Cyborg Raptor
Posts: 1183 |
Wow he is extremely lax about the situation, I always thought it was his arrogance but this kind of stuff can be extremely stressful and taxing so maybe this is a better way to handle it after all.
Anyway I can only hope that they choose Floor for the new material and I would be super stoked if they also did re-recordings of Dark Passion and Imaginaerum with Floor as well! lol maybe one day...
----
pewpew.. gotcha
Loading...
|
Feng
Posts: 108 |
"Yeah, a bit more like a band album, because we have kinda searched this orchestral, really varied spectrum to its maximum now, that how I feel."
I highly doubt this means a direct return to pre Once material, but I'm now quite excited about the prospect of something that might sound a bit more old school!
Loading...
|
jesterhead57
Posts: 24 |
New vocalist... now I'm actually looking forward to this.
Loading...
|
CyberSymphony Ollie
Posts: 673 |
I never even thought that Floor will stay as the permanent vocalist as she's with her Revamp project (thought she was brilliant with Nightwish). Quite intrigued about a new vocalist, hopefully we'll get a decent metal singer this time.
Loading...
|
ImperialTroll Account deleted |
ImperialTroll Account deleted
I will find this band interesting again if they bring a good female vocalist, like Onielar from Darkened Nocturn Slaughtercult, but I doubt that will ever happen
Loading...
|
X5452 Account deleted |
X5452 Account deleted
Nightwish damn well knows that Floor is perfect as a vocalist, it's all about whether she has time to be doing it full time, which is why they are waiting to announce it.
Loading...
|
M C Vice ex-polydactyl
Posts: 3408 |
Written by Nemo Atkins on 16.08.2013 at 19:14
Written by Jiri on 16.08.2013 at 18:46
...I wonder what Amanda Somerville is doing these days?
(OK, kidding about Amanda Somerville...)
I don't think she'd be a bad choice, actually. What about Linnea Vikstrom? She didn't get to do much with Therion.
----
"I'm here to nunchuck and not wear helmets. And I'm all out of helmets."
"I'll fight you on one condition. That you lower your nipples."
" 'Tis a lie! Thy backside is whole and ungobbled, thou ungrateful whelp!"
Loading...
|
mikeprado30
Posts: 1284 |
If they only... if they only think about ELISA C. MARTIN She would rock there and she REALLY would give a fresh air to the NW music...
But nowadays she is with Hamka working in their next album, and Spanish musicians are not so valued in the Euro Metal world.
----
BARDS WE ARE, BARDS WE WILL BE!
Loading...
|
Nemo Atkins
Posts: 257
|
Written by M C Vice on 17.08.2013 at 04:36
Written by Nemo Atkins on 16.08.2013 at 19:14
Written by Jiri on 16.08.2013 at 18:46
...I wonder what Amanda Somerville is doing these days?
(OK, kidding about Amanda Somerville...)
I don't think she'd be a bad choice, actually. What about Linnea Vikstrom? She didn't get to do much with Therion.
Not heard about Linnea (I've never listened to Therion), so I can't say anything about her. Although that does give me something to listen to if I get enough free time...
I'm not so sure Amanda Somerville would really fit in Nightwish. Yeah, she has the range to pull it off, but I think the Tarja fanatics would want to hear someone who can sing in an operatic style when they hear material she sang on (assuming they'll accept anyone other than Tarja on vocals in Nightwish...). Maybe she'd be a good choice for the Anette material, but the Tarja material? I'd need to hear her sing on that first before I could say with any certainty how that would work out, but, based on my current knowledge of her voice (which is pretty much confined to Avantasia, so that's next to nothing), I'm skeptical.
End of the day, I honestly think Floor would be the best choice, since she can do the singing styles required to pull off the material of both eras. If that doesn't happen, I can only pity whoever else is picked for the vocalist job if they aren't able to do the same...
(As a minor off topic comment, I'm slightly reminded of what happened in Iced Earth: the person who had to replace Barlow the second time also had the challenge of material done with Tim Owens. At least they found Stu Block for that one!)
Loading...
|
M C Vice ex-polydactyl
Posts: 3408 |
Written by Nemo Atkins on 17.08.2013 at 11:15
Written by M C Vice on 17.08.2013 at 04:36
Written by Nemo Atkins on 16.08.2013 at 19:14
Written by Jiri on 16.08.2013 at 18:46
Not heard about Linnea (I've never listened to Therion), so I can't say anything about her. Although that does give me something to listen to if I get enough free time...
She sang on Kings Of Edom and Hellequin, both off Sitra Ahra. She's still under 20 (I think) so Holopainen can still bend her to his (evil) will.
----
"I'm here to nunchuck and not wear helmets. And I'm all out of helmets."
"I'll fight you on one condition. That you lower your nipples."
" 'Tis a lie! Thy backside is whole and ungobbled, thou ungrateful whelp!"
Loading...
|
Bad English Tage Westerlund
Posts: 62020 |
I hope Tarot will realise something good
----
I stand whit Ukraine and Israel. They have right to defend own citizens.
Stormtroopers of Death - "Speak English or Die"
I better die, because I never will learn speek english, so I choose dieing
Loading...
|
The Melting Snow
Posts: 674 |
And i'm still hoping somehow they could get Tarja back. NW will never be my cup of tea without her again. -_-
Loading...
|
BrianStorm
Posts: 17
|
Written by Bad English on 17.08.2013 at 14:45
I hope Tarot will realise something good
They need to get rid of Tommi Salmela first. At the very least, return him to roadie status.
Loading...
|
The Warrior Account deleted |
The Warrior Account deleted
Just don't pick Floor
Pick another girl that is unknown please
we want a unique vocalist for the band
Loading...
|
Azarath Free as a.. Fish
Posts: 965 |
Written by [user id=135387] on 18.08.2013 at 17:22
Just don't pick Floor
Pick another girl that is unknown please
we want a unique vocalist for the band
If it doesn't work out with Floor, someone completely unknown is probably the way to go.
However, Floor is unique.
Loading...
|
KainRich
Posts: 12
|
I'd prefer a Marco vocals only Nightwish album. No need to bring in a new singer just because it's expected.
Loading...
|
Ellrohir Heaven Knight
Posts: 8669 |
About time
----
My rest seems now calm and deep
Finally I got my dead man sleep
Loading...
|
HellriderRising
Posts: 82 |
Loading...
|