Unhealer Eclecticist
Posts: 2311  |
31.05.2013 - 05:00Rating: 8
I gave it one shot and I was left with that bittersweet feeling of "I don't like it but I want to listen to it again". And I usually end up liking those albums, so let's see what happens next...
Loading...
|
Ap46
Posts: 64  |
Tristania, then Sirenia. Let's see who has done the job correctly and who has not
Loading...
|
Rasa
Posts: 93  |
31.05.2013 - 05:09Rating: 9
As I have hoped, it did not disappoint. Surely heaver than Rubicon and more "in your face". In a way it sounds for me like a continuation of Ashes rather than two albums past that period. Arteries, Cypher, Himmelfall - these are the highlights for me so far.
Loading...
|
theembryo
Posts: 161  |
31.05.2013 - 05:17Rating: 9
Mariangela not singing in title track....? Anyway, this and "Lavender", and yes, "Cypher" are absolute first-time listen quality for me here. Well done, and bravo for the review as well from Susan
Loading...
|
annodomini
Posts: 784  |
I am totally shocked! This is such a surprise! Tristania always was a qualified songwriters, but this time they toped themselves! Vocal lines are just spectacular, the variation between vocals are surprising, and the melodys... It's amazing to see how they managed to create a very original album in this genre. I mean all songs sounds fresh and quiet unique, with lots of influences from other styles, specially blues, what is significant in Mary's vocals. The only filler for me is "Night on earth". All other songs equaly amazing.
My favorites so far - Requeim, Diagnosis and Number.
And the lyrics are poetic again!
----
the riddle wants to be...
Loading...
|
X-Ray Rod Skandino StaffPosts: 18488  |
Welp shit, your review got me interested. I never checked out Tristania before. I don't like many gothic metal bands and usually I preffer the older sound but still, definitely interested because of the review.
----
Written by BloodTears on 19.08.2011 at 18:29 Like you could kiss my ass
Written by Milena on 20.06.2012 at 10:49 Rod, let me love you.
Loading...
|
BloodTears ANA-thema ElitePosts: 11835  |
31.05.2013 - 13:41Rating: 8
Written by X-Ray Rod on 31.05.2013 at 12:44
Welp shit, your review got me interested. I never checked out Tristania before. I don't like many gothic metal bands and usually I preffer the older sound but still, definitely interested because of the review. 
If you don't like Tristania, you can't marry me  Also, maybe you'll like it, I don't know.
Susan, that first sentence ahah so true! Of course I'll be checking this out when I can grab it. I am actually more optimistic now.
Loading...
|
Draugen
Posts: 502  |
31.05.2013 - 14:26Rating: 7
That's it, now I'm definatively going to give this album a chance. Hopefully I will end up being positively surprised.
Loading...
|
Vilovita Rusalka
Posts: 12  |
31.05.2013 - 15:08Rating: 3
Disappointment once again... But that's just my opinion and preference.
----
www.facebook.com/EternalAphelionPhotography
Loading...
|
annodomini
Posts: 784  |
I believe the problem of thos who are disappointed is that they still are hoping to hear old Tristania. These guys are the best creative crew Tristania ever had, even better then Veland-era. They just play a different style. It's pitty that fans of Tristania rate this by 2 or 3, because I always thought that people who like music like Tristania are open-minded, but it seems, they can't get out of the box and appreaciate different approaches.
----
the riddle wants to be...
Loading...
|
Ap46
Posts: 64  |
Ok, i listened to it and i think it's a good album. It has some twists and turns that keep you interested for the most part. But, i think it goes down in the middle and then up again at the end, so i find myself skipping 2 or 3 songs that do nothing for me. It's good though.
Loading...
|
CyberSymphony Ollie
Posts: 673  |
31.05.2013 - 18:50Rating: 7
Another great review from Susan  , definitely makes me want to play the album now. A couple of tracks are uploaded on YouTube and sounding not too bad. I can hear a definite improvement from the last album.
Loading...
|
Epictemptation7
Posts: 15  |
Wow this is great, Gothic Metal is healing now
Loading...
|
AnGina-- Dark Phoenix
Posts: 3555  |
I'm not even sure if it makes sense to write these words, because it seems some of you just don't want to understand it, but I'll give it s shot anyway. I can't speak for everyone, but I'm pretty sure some share my point of view - it's not that we/I don't like DW because we're hoping to get ''old'' Tristania back, we just don't like it. Period. Do you guys like all albums by your faves? I certainly don't. There are albums from bands that I like, that are shitty. There are albums from bands I dislike (meaning I like the majortiy of their work), that I fancy. We're not teens anymore, it's not obligatory to like just about anything our ''fave'' band releases.
DW is Tristania's 7th full lenght album. Of these 7, mr. Veland was only a part of 2. Meaning, anyone still hoping of anything going to the origins, is pointless and even stupid. So no, it's not about old Tristania, not about Veland, it's about simply not liking the album because of its very own fetaures.
Open-mindedness? I can't understand this one either, goes as well as the first point - not liking an album or a band doesn't mean, one is close-minded. I myself listen to a variety of genres outside metal and I embrace just about anything that I, for some reason, fancy. I don't have guilty pleasure, merely pleasures. Again, not liking an album is not a matter of open-mindedness, it's matter of taste and preferences.
I'm glad Tristania still has many admireres, I congratulate them on their long path, on their new album and all the positive reviews they are getting. But don't use the same old story over and over again to bash anyone, who doesn't agree that the album is superb. I won't lie, I was so dissapointed with Ashes when it came out and never liked anything post WOG as much as the previous ones. But nonetheless, over the years I found new depths in Ashes/Illumination/Rubicon, there are still some songs on the albums I adore deeply. Maybe it will be the same with DW, but overall, it's just not an album for me at the moment.
I enjoyed reading the review though, even thoug I disagree with Susan's points of view. But nonetheless, it's well written  and it gives me a view from the other side; what appeals some on DW and makes this album so likeable and I simply can't argue with that at any point, because it's merely a matter of opinion.
----
You think darkness is your ally? You merely adopted the dark. I was born in it. Molded by it. I didn't see the light until I was a man. But it was nothing to me but blinding.
Loading...
|
Cassian
Posts: 160  |
02.06.2013 - 16:19Rating: 10
Only listened to the album once, and my first impression is Mariangela's singing has got much more persuasive. It's not an accessible album though. The only song that has got my attention is "Requiem". Still need some more spins
Loading...
|
Gothnica
Posts: 1
|
Please Darkest White can't be best than Ashes,and Illumination,
Loading...
|
Susan Smeghead ElitePosts: 6941  |
07.06.2013 - 05:35Rating: 9
SusanSmegheadElitePosts: 6941 
Written by Gothnica on 04.06.2013 at 21:09
Please Darkest White can't be best than Ashes,and Illumination,
Really tough call since all 3 are so different. That's what I love so much about Tristania: sure, there are "periods" of a few similar albums but each is so unique it's almost impossible to compare one to the next. Seven treats for the ear this band has given us.
----
"A life all mine
Is what I choose
At the end of my days"
--The Gathering "A Life All Mine" from Souvenirs
Loading...
|
Spell
Posts: 15
|
Vibeke was Tristania, Tristania started going downhill after world of glass imo and totally fucked up when they picked this new chick instead of seeking a proper replacement to Vibeke. now they sound like just another chick band.
Loading...
|
DoomRules
Posts: 38  |
28.06.2013 - 20:38Rating: 9
We have to overcome that the old Tristania never will return, however this record clearly shows a
development as a band, we must recognize that they are very good musicians.
----
There's no light at the end of the tunnel...
Loading...
|
Ethan1994
Posts: 52  |
05.07.2013 - 19:42Rating: 10
Written by AnGina-- on 02.06.2013 at 14:11
I'm not even sure if it makes sense to write these words, because it seems some of you just don't want to understand it, but I'll give it s shot anyway. I can't speak for everyone, but I'm pretty sure some share my point of view - it's not that we/I don't like DW because we're hoping to get ''old'' Tristania back, we just don't like it. Period. Do you guys like all albums by your faves? I certainly don't. There are albums from bands that I like, that are shitty. There are albums from bands I dislike (meaning I like the majortiy of their work), that I fancy. We're not teens anymore, it's not obligatory to like just about anything our ''fave'' band releases.
DW is Tristania's 7th full lenght album. Of these 7, mr. Veland was only a part of 2. Meaning, anyone still hoping of anything going to the origins, is pointless and even stupid. So no, it's not about old Tristania, not about Veland, it's about simply not liking the album because of its very own fetaures.
Open-mindedness? I can't understand this one either, goes as well as the first point - not liking an album or a band doesn't mean, one is close-minded. I myself listen to a variety of genres outside metal and I embrace just about anything that I, for some reason, fancy. I don't have guilty pleasure, merely pleasures. Again, not liking an album is not a matter of open-mindedness, it's matter of taste and preferences.
I'm glad Tristania still has many admireres, I congratulate them on their long path, on their new album and all the positive reviews they are getting. But don't use the same old story over and over again to bash anyone, who doesn't agree that the album is superb. I won't lie, I was so dissapointed with Ashes when it came out and never liked anything post WOG as much as the previous ones. But nonetheless, over the years I found new depths in Ashes/Illumination/Rubicon, there are still some songs on the albums I adore deeply. Maybe it will be the same with DW, but overall, it's just not an album for me at the moment.
I enjoyed reading the review though, even thoug I disagree with Susan's points of view. But nonetheless, it's well written and it gives me a view from the other side; what appeals some on DW and makes this album so likeable and I simply can't argue with that at any point, because it's merely a matter of opinion.
That's fine.  If it's not your thing, then it's not your thing. I think most of us just get pissed off when people say that it sucks just because Vibeke isn't on it. When they just pin down the entire album's quality on one member's absence.
Loading...
|
Daggon Underpaid M.D.
Posts: 1689  |
29.08.2013 - 04:02Rating: 5
DaggonUnderpaid M.D.Posts: 1689 
I used to enjoy female fronted metal bands a lot in the past, but I don't know, maybe it's me, maybe I can't enjoy this type of music anymore, or maybe the music that most female fronted metal bands play is bad, artificial, focused on the image of their singer instead of focusing on music quality, I don't know, I hope some band will prove me wrong in the future, but in the meantime, I just can't say that I find this album boring.
----
"Les vers savent qu'ils n'ont pas d'ailes, c'est pour cela qu'ils se cachent sous terre"
Loading...
|
Ethan1994
Posts: 52  |
23.10.2013 - 01:44Rating: 10
Written by Spell on 11.06.2013 at 10:59
Vibeke was Tristania, Tristania started going downhill after world of glass imo and totally fucked up when they picked this new chick instead of seeking a proper replacement to Vibeke. now they sound like just another chick band.
That's your opinion, but to be honest, I think Vibeke is overrated (By that, I mean she's good, but not so much "amazing" or "unique"). I also think every other "chick band" sounds like Tristania's early work, not this album.
I also think getting someone like Mary to take Vibeke's place was a great idea, seeing as how Anders and Einar clearly wanted to take the band's music in a new direction, and getting a singer with a different style has enabled them to do so much more easily.
Loading...
|