Talvi
Posts: 825 |
you could rate everyting, not just overall
----
My account on other musical pages:
http://www.last.fm/user/Pozito/
http://rateyourmusic.com/~Talvi
Loading...
|
AnarChrist
Posts: 253
|
08.08.2006 - 01:21Rating: 10
i think it's better to just rate overall like in the old days,for example let's take an occasion where you absolutely love an album and everything about it,but also everyhting done in the album has been done before,you can't give more than 7 points in originality,and that drags the overall score which you want to be perfect,i don't think the new system works that well
----
oh my fucking god, fucking dinosaurs
Loading...
|
Der Meister Account deleted |
Der Meister Account deleted
I would also give the album 10/10. It´s perfect. It´s a beauty. It´s a pearl. It´s immortal. It´s a classic!
Loading...
|
MetalSpider
Posts: 1388 |
08.08.2006 - 07:37Rating: 10
Its an amazing album thats for sure. Every song on there is just excellent. Mors Principium Est is an underrated band imo.
----
Thanks to Corrupt for these banners!
Loading...
|
Nèst
Posts: 10 |
09.08.2006 - 03:19Rating: 10
Superb album
Loading...
|
Raiden Down Under Staff ElitePosts: 8292 |
RaidenDown Under StaffElitePosts: 8292
Written by AnarChrist on 08.08.2006 at 01:21
i think it's better to just rate overall like in the old days,for example let's take an occasion where you absolutely love an album and everything about it,but also everyhting done in the album has been done before,you can't give more than 7 points in originality,and that drags the overall score which you want to be perfect,i don't think the new system works that well
Well I do think the new system works well. People can see the exact breakdown of how good the album is in parts. Some people might be sticklers for originality, so with the new system, they can see the originality rating. With Black Metal albums too, bad production can make the album sound better. So the overall rating is appropriate.
Do you have to rate every album you review with a 10 in every aspect though, Doc?
----
"Scream for me Melbourne!!!!"
- Bruce Dickinson
"I don't see any god up here"
- Yuri Gagarin (while in orbit, 1961)
Loading...
|
Slottet av Take Account deleted |
Slottet av Take Account deleted
Its an OK album....its nothing ground breaking though is it? I would probably give its 7/10 because it has some enjoyable moments and nice songs but still - we've heard it all before...
Of all recent melodic death stuff that's been out only Scar Symmetry has impressed me enough with their technicality and songwriting to rate them more than 8/10 - until such time that we hear something diffferent from MPE im not rating them up there with the best...
Loading...
|
Mindheist No Longer Human
Posts: 618 |
Written by Raiden on 10.08.2006 at 08:21
Written by AnarChrist on 08.08.2006 at 01:21
i think it's better to just rate overall like in the old days,for example let's take an occasion where you absolutely love an album and everything about it,but also everyhting done in the album has been done before,you can't give more than 7 points in originality,and that drags the overall score which you want to be perfect,i don't think the new system works that well
Well I do think the new system works well. People can see the exact breakdown of how good the album is in parts. Some people might be sticklers for originality, so with the new system, they can see the originality rating. With Black Metal albums too, bad production can make the album sound better. So the overall rating is appropriate.
Do you have to rate every album you review with a 10 in every aspect though, Doc?
Well, i just review good albums, i don't see why should i review something bad.
Loading...
|
Raiden Down Under Staff ElitePosts: 8292 |
RaidenDown Under StaffElitePosts: 8292
Written by Mindheist on 19.08.2006 at 20:09
Written by Raiden on 10.08.2006 at 08:21
Written by AnarChrist on 08.08.2006 at 01:21
i think it's better to just rate overall like in the old days,for example let's take an occasion where you absolutely love an album and everything about it,but also everyhting done in the album has been done before,you can't give more than 7 points in originality,and that drags the overall score which you want to be perfect,i don't think the new system works that well
Well I do think the new system works well. People can see the exact breakdown of how good the album is in parts. Some people might be sticklers for originality, so with the new system, they can see the originality rating. With Black Metal albums too, bad production can make the album sound better. So the overall rating is appropriate.
Do you have to rate every album you review with a 10 in every aspect though, Doc?
Well, i just review good albums, i don't see why should i review something bad.
Yeah, I suppose. Sometimes it is nice to see some critical analysis though. And not every one of your favourite albums can have a 10/10 rating. Jeff once taught me that 10/10 ratings should really only to the cult albums like Rust In Peace, etc.
----
"Scream for me Melbourne!!!!"
- Bruce Dickinson
"I don't see any god up here"
- Yuri Gagarin (while in orbit, 1961)
Loading...
|
Mindheist No Longer Human
Posts: 618 |
Written by Raiden on 20.08.2006 at 09:33
Written by Mindheist on 19.08.2006 at 20:09
Written by Raiden on 10.08.2006 at 08:21
Written by AnarChrist on 08.08.2006 at 01:21
i think it's better to just rate overall like in the old days,for example let's take an occasion where you absolutely love an album and everything about it,but also everyhting done in the album has been done before,you can't give more than 7 points in originality,and that drags the overall score which you want to be perfect,i don't think the new system works that well
Well I do think the new system works well. People can see the exact breakdown of how good the album is in parts. Some people might be sticklers for originality, so with the new system, they can see the originality rating. With Black Metal albums too, bad production can make the album sound better. So the overall rating is appropriate.
Do you have to rate every album you review with a 10 in every aspect though, Doc?
Well, i just review good albums, i don't see why should i review something bad.
Yeah, I suppose. Sometimes it is nice to see some critical analysis though. And not every one of your favourite albums can have a 10/10 rating. Jeff once taught me that 10/10 ratings should really only to the cult albums like Rust In Peace, etc.
Yeah, but as you can see, we must begin to review our finest albums, how much rating would you give to The Unborn(in case that you own it ofcourse)?.
Loading...
|
Passenger Lost To Apathy
Posts: 1464 |
30.08.2006 - 22:26Rating: 10
Pretty impressive effort. "Pure" is simply unbelievable.
----
You don't make up for your sins in church. You do it in the streets. You do it at home. The rest is bullshit and you know it ~ Mean Streets
Loading...
|
Thryce Retired Staff ElitePosts: 4346 |
ThryceRetired StaffElitePosts: 4346
Great review, but score is a little too high IMO... If it would be my review, I would rate it a 8 in general and a 8.5/9 for the Melo-Death-genre in specific.
I'm listening to "The Unborn" right now, the only album I know from Mors Prinicipium Est. Pretty sweet album indeed! You can easily recognize some In Flames influences in their sound, but still theiy're quite different and like I said also a great and powerful Gothenburg band.
Some songs I that I found really outstanding were "Pure", "Parasite Of Paradise" and "Pressure"
Looking forward to their upcoming album!
----
Your favorite band sucks.
Loading...
|
RazorOfTheLight Account deleted |
RazorOfTheLight Account deleted
Written by [user id=1909] on 11.08.2006 at 01:24
Its an OK album....its nothing ground breaking though is it? I would probably give its 7/10 because it has some enjoyable moments and nice songs but still - we've heard it all before...
Of all recent melodic death stuff that's been out only Scar Symmetry has impressed me enough with their technicality and songwriting to rate them more than 8/10 - until such time that we hear something diffferent from MPE im not rating them up there with the best...
This band puts Scar Symmetry to Shame... I used to think maybe Scar Symmetry was something like this but Scar Symmetry cant touch MPE in any aspect whatsoever. This is music Masterpeice 11/10!
Mors Principium Est Defines good music and all else follows in its wake. I hope the new CD doesnt simplify to gain popularity... Mors Principium Est(Life After Death) Really is divine. After listening to thousands of bands It is extremly rare to find music than can come within the same echelon as MPE... Only the future holds untold musical wonders.
Loading...
|
Slottet av Take Account deleted |
Slottet av Take Account deleted
Written by [user id=2371] on 17.09.2006 at 10:17
Written by [user id=1909] on 11.08.2006 at 01:24
Its an OK album....its nothing ground breaking though is it? I would probably give its 7/10 because it has some enjoyable moments and nice songs but still - we've heard it all before...
Of all recent melodic death stuff that's been out only Scar Symmetry has impressed me enough with their technicality and songwriting to rate them more than 8/10 - until such time that we hear something diffferent from MPE im not rating them up there with the best...
Well thats just your opinion...i think they are kinda bland
This band puts Scar Symmetry to Shame... I used to think maybe Scar Symmetry was something like this but Scar Symmetry cant touch MPE in any aspect whatsoever. This is music Masterpeice 11/10!
Mors Principium Est Defines good music and all else follows in its wake. I hope the new CD doesnt simplify to gain popularity... Mors Principium Est(Life After Death) Really is divine. After listening to thousands of bands It is extremly rare to find music than can come within the same echelon as MPE... Only the future holds untold musical wonders.
Loading...
|
Acid_ Account deleted |
Acid_ Account deleted
I Agree, but 10 is not much for this album, i'd give 11..
Loading...
|
Keoren Account deleted |
Keoren Account deleted
I just got the album and it's plain awesome. I'd give it 9.5/10
Loading...
|
DeadEternity Account deleted |
DeadEternity Account deleted
Truly GREAT album. I'm at a losfer words. Can't say anything more than that.
Loading...
|
Lucas Mr. Noise ElitePosts: 13427 |
LucasMr. NoiseElitePosts: 13427
I get sick of reading 9.9/10 or 10/10 reviews. Hurray for the (almost) objective reviewers!
----
SLUDGE. DOOM. DEATH. Wait, what?
"The reason I'm running for president is because I can't be Bruce Springsteen." - Barack Obama
Loading...
|
Mindheist No Longer Human
Posts: 618 |
Written by Lucas on 02.02.2007 at 22:21
I get sick of reading 9.9/10 or 10/10 reviews. Hurray for the (almost) objective reviewers!
I agree with you, This rating is a little higher than it should be. Don't worry, there's another one coming, Great but not perfect...Check it on Feb, 11. thanks
Loading...
|
Opium Magnet Account deleted |
Opium Magnet Account deleted
Their debut was much more impressive IMO, this was just an average melodeath album overall, almost all the songs sounded very similar. I'd give this album a 7/10 for the effort in trying to live up to their debut album.
Loading...
|
mutha
Posts: 7
|
Written by [user id=6205] on 08.08.2006 at 01:27
I would also give the album 10/10. It´s perfect. It´s a beauty. It´s a pearl. It´s immortal. It´s a classic!
absolutely right !!!
Loading...
|
K✞ulu Seeker of Truth
Posts: 2573 |
05.06.2008 - 15:11Rating: 6
K✞uluSeeker of TruthPosts: 2573
Nothing special about this album just like the previous one. Very generic: most of the leads, drums, and riffs. Plus, man, who called this album the best melodeth release of 2005? This is just ridiculous...
----
Savor what you feel and what you see
Things that may not seem important now
But may be tomorrow
R.I.P. Chuck Schuldiner
Satan was a Backstreet Boy
Loading...
|
jdsony
Posts: 12
|
Well I'd have to say it's one of my favorite albums. It's obviously a matter of taste but I find while they aren't bringing a whole lot of originality to the genre they seem to pull it off a lot better than many others. The first album for me was a bit generic and while I liked it at the time I find it doesn't hold up all that well for me anymore. The latest album is really good but not quite the masterpiece that the Unborn is.
Loading...
|
Deadmeat Necrobutcher
Posts: 2437 |
16.04.2010 - 19:52Rating: 9
What i like the most in this review is that we have exactly the same fav songs from this album. Altered State Consciousness is really MAGNIFICENT.
----
Υou've sold your human essence to the cold world of dead and empty things... You're SOLD!
Loading...
|
Spanishkiller
Posts: 80 |
24.06.2011 - 01:53Rating: 9
Written by [user id=6205] on 08.08.2006 at 01:27
I would also give the album 10/10. It´s perfect. It´s a beauty. It´s a pearl. It´s immortal. It´s a classic!
TU is such a good album, but it doesn't deserve a 10, even thought it is completely different from everything I've ever listened to. Somehow progressive, very technical, and also melodic. It is a great mixture, but it is far away from perfection. IMO it deserves a 8.5-9
Loading...
|