Not sure about where to write in your vote? Ask here!
Posts: 95
Visited by: 100 users
Original post
Posted by Milena, 04.02.2012 - 14:46
). Obviously, some albums are pretty ambiguous when it comes to genre, so they can go either way, but if a band was in the nomination circle, you'll get a reply based on where the band was considered to go if it passed. I hope this is clear.Also. Let's say a band was already nominated in category A but you wrote it in category B. Those votes will get deleted. They won't get added up. Why? Because there is no way we can know who cast which vote, so that would give you the opportunity to cheat - vote for a band in the regular category and write it in the other 20. So if you see a band in a genre you don't think it belongs in, don't play genre experts and vote it in that category. We all have different opinions of genre differences and nothing is strictly defined, but the nominees were based on the consensus of the entire staff/elite team. We're not perfect, but we have agreed on some things so that's the way it should go for these Awards.
The questions so far:
Sylosis? Should be in thrash.
Pain Of Salvation? Should be in prog.
Cormorant? The best guess is prog.
Protest The Hero? Prog.
| JD Account deleted |
|
| psykometal A staff guy... Elite Posts: 6101  |
Written by [user id=28526] on 05.02.2012 at 02:19 Doubtful, pretty sure anonymity is a preference on Staff's behalf so they don't have to worry about some of the more immature users attacking one another for "voting stupidly" or whatever. Not even sure Staff can see who voted...
---- ~Zep, Database and Forum Moderation~ 
Loading...
|
| Marcel Hubregtse Grumpy Old Fuck Elite Posts: 40071  |
Written by psykometal on 05.02.2012 at 02:50 Nope, you're right, we can't see who voted. And tbh why would we want to see that?
---- Member of the true crusade against European Flower Metal Yesterday is dead and gone, tomorrow is out of sight Dawn Crosby (r.i.p.) 05.04.1963 - 15.12.1996 
Loading...
|
| psykometal A staff guy... Elite Posts: 6101 |
Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 05.02.2012 at 03:16 Idk. The only reason I could see for Staff needing to see that is so y'all could get onto the trolls or something. 
---- ~Zep, Database and Forum Moderation~
Loading...
|
| Edmund Fogg Posts: 1752  |
Just to be sure, we're taking here about categories for genres and subgenres right? I mean If I write in for best Debut album and Biggest surprise the same album, because I genuinely feel that way will get nuked?
---- You cannot sedate all the things you hate - MM The Observer is the source of reality - Bloom God damn it!! What did Diddy didn't do? - Satan
Loading...
|
| JD Account deleted |
|
| Edmund Fogg Posts: 1752 |
Written by [user id=28526] on 05.02.2012 at 03:29 Me neither, but you never know, sometimes stupid rules are put up to prevent others abusing what would be common sense.
---- You cannot sedate all the things you hate - MM The Observer is the source of reality - Bloom God damn it!! What did Diddy didn't do? - Satan
Loading...
|
| Darkside Momo Retired Elite Posts: 9089  |
No, nothing wrong with that. Best debut, biggest surprise and biggest letdown are different categories altogether. Remember when Nightwish won both 'biggest surprise' and 'biggest disappointment' for Dark Passion Play in 2007...
---- My Author's Blog (in French)  "You must stay drunk on writing so reality cannot destroy you" "I've lost too many years now I'm stealing back my soul I am awake"
Loading...
|
| Edmund Fogg Posts: 1752 |
Haha no I don't. I was not part of the site yet. It was a real letdown then if people were so surprised of how bad it was.
---- You cannot sedate all the things you hate - MM The Observer is the source of reality - Bloom God damn it!! What did Diddy didn't do? - Satan
Loading...
|
| BitterCOld The Ancient One Admin Posts: 15287  |
The only problem with that would be if the album in question were NOT a debut... besides, Debut makes more sense for a Surprise than 90% of the shit people list in that category. fuck, megadeth won it two years ago for releasing an album our users rated marginally better than the prior album.
---- get the fuck off my lawn. Beer Bug Virus Spotify Playlist crafted by Nikarg and I. Feel free to tune in and add some pertinent metal tunes!
Loading...
|
| Edmund Fogg Posts: 1752 |
Figured has much and I guess it's up to the user to make his quick research before writtig in his album instead of trying to remember.
---- You cannot sedate all the things you hate - MM The Observer is the source of reality - Bloom God damn it!! What did Diddy didn't do? - Satan
Loading...
|
| Fredd Account deleted |
Fredd
Account deleted Written by Darkside Momo on 04.02.2012 at 22:43 Sir, I salute you for your excellent choice of avatar. 
Loading...
|
| JD Account deleted |
|
| Milena gloom cookie Staff Posts: 4603  |
Written by [user id=28526] on 05.02.2012 at 13:22 I am sure. It is one of those really genre blending releases, yes. We agreed it would be in thrash... however, if a lot of people vote it in Melodeath, guess there's nothing we can do about it
---- 7.0 means the album is good
Loading...
|
| JD Account deleted |
JD
Account deleted Written by Milena on 05.02.2012 at 13:27 Then I'm gonna vote for them in the Gothenburg Metal, because Sylosis sounds more like metalcore\gothenburg, if we compared them with the NWOTM bands like Havok, Vektor, Warbringer etc..
Loading...
|
| Milena gloom cookie Staff Posts: 4603 |
Written by [user id=28526] on 05.02.2012 at 13:35 It comes down to your choice in the end now really, it would be smarter to vote it in thrash but I don't think votes for those cangoeitherway-type of releases will get nuked just because a number of people disagrees with us. If a genre is nicely defined, with influences from other genres but not 50%=50% between some two, yes, we'd like you to vote it in the genres we decided they would be, but if it were up to me I wouldn't mind seeing Sylosis in melodeath. Ask Craig about it. So basically, you can. However, there's plenty of awesome stuff in melodeath this year, maybe you should check some of the releases you haven't, if you haven't 
---- 7.0 means the album is good
Loading...
|
| Darkside Momo Retired Elite Posts: 9089 |
Written by [user id=114127] on 05.02.2012 at 06:08 Thanks! I almost never changed it since 2004. Just because this album is so perfect
---- My Author's Blog (in French) "You must stay drunk on writing so reality cannot destroy you" "I've lost too many years now I'm stealing back my soul I am awake"
Loading...
|
| ?apleee Mouthcrab Posts: 260  |
Is Mastodon Sludge, Progressive, or alternative?
---- "Without judgement, perception would increase a million times."~Chuck Schuldiner Less coherent than Anal Cunt. Eric Brecht once liked my Facebook comment. Therefore, by the translative property, Chuck Schuldiner like my comment.
Loading...
|
| JD Account deleted |
|
| Marcel Hubregtse Grumpy Old Fuck Elite Posts: 40071 |
Written by [user id=28526] on 05.02.2012 at 17:51 They are nominated there, so I don't understand the wquestion the guy asked.
---- Member of the true crusade against European Flower Metal Yesterday is dead and gone, tomorrow is out of sight Dawn Crosby (r.i.p.) 05.04.1963 - 15.12.1996
Loading...
|
| JD Account deleted |
|
| psykometal A staff guy... Elite Posts: 6101 |
Really, Mastodon is in Sludge? Don't get me wrong, I'm not in to them (or Sludge) so I don't care but I've heard so many people here on MS and on other sites and outside of the internet calling them progressive and saying things like "Hunter was the best prog metal release of 2011" and stuff so just I'm surprised they aren't listed in the Prog category. Even the band consider themselves a prog metal band (just watched an interview with Brent Hinds and Brann Dailor on Metal Evolution last night) and even Craig said in his review of Hunter, "The band continues with the direction taken in CTS, which is to say less with the sludged-up noisecore or whatever, and more with the 70's prog loving alternative rock/metal approach." Once again I'm not complaining, just expressing my surprise is all.
---- ~Zep, Database and Forum Moderation~
Loading...
|
| Milena gloom cookie Staff Posts: 4603 |
Written by psykometal on 05.02.2012 at 18:49 Mmmmm, don't listen to Mastodon, but I wouldn't be surprised if the prog-spice in their music is in fact just spice... we'll have to ask Mastodon lovers, but MS has never been hesitant about nominating bands in a different genre than usual if the band changed, so I don't see why would that practice be started now
---- 7.0 means the album is good
Loading...
|
| psykometal A staff guy... Elite Posts: 6101 |
Written by Milena on 05.02.2012 at 19:06 Yea I know, I was just commenting my surprise is all. I got Leviathan when that came out and didn't care for it, I've also checked out some of their singles as they've released their other albums and I just never could get into them at all so I have no clue how to "properly" categorize them, I just know what I've heard from fans (and what I saw of the band last night on ME).
---- ~Zep, Database and Forum Moderation~
Loading...
|
| Cynic Metalhead Ambrish Saxena Posts: 7562  |
Written by psykometal on 05.02.2012 at 19:26 pretty strange(again?!) to see Mastodon getting labels of Prog. even further going labeling nasty Djent, metalcore or what not. Shit. i love Mastodon but what i feel is they're a crossover Djent stuff who alters their genre from album to album...but fuck no! they never sounded like prog.!!. Peace. Serious Peace.
Loading...
|
| Fredd Account deleted |
Fredd
Account deleted Written by Milena on 05.02.2012 at 13:42 I dont get it. Say a hundred users voted for ambiguous album X in a certain category and another hundred voted in another category, would half of the votes get nuked?
Loading...
|
| Milena gloom cookie Staff Posts: 4603 |
Written by [user id=114127] on 05.02.2012 at 20:04 I'm the new kid so I'm not SO sure, but I think they would. Because that means someone might have wrote in the same release in two categories, doubling the amount of votes that release would get.
---- 7.0 means the album is good
Loading...
|
| Darkside Momo Retired Elite Posts: 9089 |
Written by [user id=114127] on 05.02.2012 at 20:04 yup. because people could have voted for the same album in both
---- My Author's Blog (in French) "You must stay drunk on writing so reality cannot destroy you" "I've lost too many years now I'm stealing back my soul I am awake"
Loading...
|
| Fredd Account deleted |
|
| psykometal A staff guy... Elite Posts: 6101 |
Written by Cynic Metalhead on 05.02.2012 at 19:40 Well like I said, I don't listen to them but I see people all over the place calling them progressive metal and I heard both Brent Hinds (Mastodon's guitarist) and Brann Dailor (Mastodon's drummer) call themselves a prog band on Metal Evolution (episode 11, season finale, Progressive Metal) last night; and both of them said they're biggest influences for The Hunter were 70's british prog rock bands. So when I see more people calling them a prog band than not, and I see/hear half of the band calling themselves a prog band, then as far as I'm concerned they're a prog band.
---- ~Zep, Database and Forum Moderation~
Loading...
|