Posts: 13287  |
Posts: 13287 
I don't understand how the first two albums have a better reputation than this one. This is just magic.
Loading...
|
Posts: 507  |
Posts: 507 
Their worst album for me, the only songs that save it are Gravenimage and The Ruins of My Life.
----
If this grand panorama before me is what you call God
Then God is not dead.
Loading...
|
Posts: 13287  |
Posts: 13287 
Written by Zuzuz0r on 20.12.2009 at 05:07
Their worst album for me, the only songs that save it are Gravenimage and The Ruins of My Life.
Worst? You mean you prefer "Unia"?
Just goes to show how tastes differ... "The Cage" and such are just some of the best in the genre in my opinion.
Loading...
|
Posts: 8700  |
Posts: 8700 
I somehow only remember "The Cage" from listening to this album...my bad? maybe...
----
My rest seems now calm and deep
Finally I got my dead man sleep
Loading...
|
Posts: 507  |
Posts: 507 
@Baz Anderson: Yeah, I prefer Unia over WHG, I've never really liked that album, even when Sonata Arctica was my favorite band ever, I felt dissapointed when I listened to it after Silence, and I got bored instantly when listening to it.
----
If this grand panorama before me is what you call God
Then God is not dead.
Loading...
|
Posts: 13287  |
Posts: 13287 
Try it again?
Loading...
|
Posts: 9720  |
20.12.2009 - 23:25Rating: 9
Posts: 9720 
Written by Zuzuz0r on 20.12.2009 at 05:07
Their worst album for me, the only songs that save it are Gravenimage and The Ruins of My Life.
Those clearly are the best songs on the album and in my opinion two of their - if not even THEIR - best songs ever. "APBE" is also great and so is "The Cage." The rest is your usual Sonata Arctica filler stuff, but due to those four aforementioned songs I agree with Barry and rate Winterheart's Guild as Sonata's best album to date.
----
All life begins with Nu and ends with Nu... This is the truth! This is my belief! ...At least for now.
- The Mystery of Life, Vol. 841 Ch. 26
Loading...
|
Posts: 9125  |
Posts: 9125 
I really think this is Sonata's finest moment. It has fillers like any Sonata album, but The Cage, Gravenimage, and Broken are really some of their best songs imo.
----
My Author's Blog (in French)

"You must stay drunk on writing so reality cannot destroy you"
"I've lost too many years now
I'm stealing back my soul
I am awake"
Loading...
|
Posts: 4862  |
Posts: 4862 
I'm not a fan of this band, or generally into happy power metal - but I own a couple of Sonata's CD's, and ultimately 'The Cage' seems to be their ultimate anthem IMO. It's still kind of cheesy, but the melodies and everything just work so well - if only they had other songs that worked so well.
----
Loading...
|
Posts: 2955  |
Posts: 2955 
Victoria´s Secret is just beautiful. Along with a bunch of other songs. How can anyone prefer Unia?
I like St. Anger
----

----
member of the true crusade against old school heavy metal, early 80s thrash, NWOBHM, traditional doom, first and second wave black metal, old school death metal, US power metal, 70s prog rock and atmospheric doomsludgestoner. o/
Loading...
|
Posts: 1361  |
25.09.2010 - 17:07Rating: 10
Posts: 1361 
Of course this is SA's best album! The Misery is an amazing ballad. Victoria's Secret is so beautiful and the middle part is a modern day concerto. Gravenimage is beautiful as well, beautiful piano intro...Champagne Bath, Broken, The Cage are all great songs...
Loading...
|
Posts: 111  |
22.12.2010 - 13:26Rating: 10
Posts: 111 
Ecliptice and silence are great, but this one is really amazing, their best album. And one of the best power metal albums of all time for me.
Loading...
|
Cal Wolvington
Account deleted
|
Cal Wolvington
Account deleted
I am another who prefers the debut over this one, they just don't so fresh and inspired on this album anymore, which makes sense. In a way, the debut is always going to sound more youthful, it is unavoidable. Still like this album a lot though, The Ruins Of My Life is a killer track and one of the best they have ever done. Oddly enough I actually think they sounded more inspired on the follow-up "Reckoning Night" as well.
Loading...
|
Posts: 4603  |
14.06.2012 - 22:44Rating: 9
Posts: 4603 
Written by Baz Anderson on 20.12.2009 at 03:06
I don't understand how the first two albums have a better reputation than this one. This is just magic.
Agreed.
----
7.0 means the album is good
Loading...
|
LordHypnos
Account deleted
|
LordHypnos
Account deleted
Their last good album imo. My favorites are Gravenimage, Victoria's Secret and Broken.
Loading...
|
Posts: 328  |
14.01.2014 - 08:42Rating: 9
Posts: 328 
Gravenimage all the way. Although Draw Me really sticks out to me as well. This is one underrated album in my opinion.
Loading...
|
Posts: 1375  |
08.04.2020 - 16:38Rating: 9
Posts: 1375 
Like they say in Finland: there's no two without a third one. Winterheart's Guild is more or less the same as the previous ones, but considering how great the first two Sonata's albums were, it's no wonder this also kicks some serious ass. It's all downfall from here, Reckoning Night is still really damn good, but after that it's mostly mediocre to bad.
----
You've got a lot of guts. Let's see what they look like!
Loading...
|
Posts: 35  |
16.02.2024 - 22:20Rating: 10
Posts: 35 
Amazing album, magical, fun, surprisingly good.
Loading...
|