Circus Maximus - Nine - guest review
Circus Maximus - Nine - guest review
Tracklist
01. Forging02. Architect Of Fortune
03. Namaste
04. Game Of Life
05. Reach Within
06. I Am
07. Used
08. The One
09. Burn After Reading
10. Last Goodbye
Guest review by
RhaegarTargaryen December 30, 2012
That said, it's important to notice that the reviews on the net and magazines were not so great as for the previous two albums. I must say I clearly disagree with that. Although they did soften their sound in a way, making room for some more melodic metal and hard rock influences, I only see it as a way to sweeten up the already proven formula. This kind of clean melodic progressive metal, for me, is a trademark of the genre. Mats Haugen's guitar skills are pure epicness, and I firmly stand behind my words when I say that Michael Eriksen is one of the best vocals in the world today. Architecture of songs is something I always valued about this band. Every instrument, every note has its purpose, carving a monumental sound out of small pieces. I love that they are able to make some simple, even popish melody, quickly and fluidly turn into some epic progressive monumental part. The songs vary from longer, more progressive ones, building on their epic foundations. And then there are shorter ones, which tend to lean more towards melodic aspects.
It may be true that this one is maybe less pompous and epic than the previous two, but it makes up for it with atmosphere and melody. What makes this band and album so good for me is the way they know how to mix technical aspects of progressive metal, highly skilled musicianship and technique with atmosphere and melodies. Unlike many progressive works, Nine doesn't sound sterile and cold. You get the emotional component as well, not just a CD that is there to show instrument playing skills. A trait which many in the genre seems to forgot in recent years.
For me it seems that high expectations after a five year hiatus are something that drags this album down much more than the music. Five years have made us impatient, and the expectations maybe got unrealistically high. It is also a work that demands attention, you can't just go through this once and have a clear picture, this album requires you to go through it a few times to really get the full picture.
Rating breakdown
| Performance: | 10 |
| Songwriting: | 8 |
| Originality: | 8 |
| Production: | 9 |
Written by RhaegarTargaryen | December 30, 2012
Guest review disclaimer:
This is a guest review, which means it does not necessarily represent the point of view of the MS Staff.
This is a guest review, which means it does not necessarily represent the point of view of the MS Staff.
Comments
Comments:
4
Visited by
54 users
|
Posts: 141  |
Posts: 141
Nailed it. The expectations were high and were met, but not how most anticipated. Can we say that "wankery" has been put in the background but skill and emotion in the ear of listeners?
---- No time like the present
Loading...
|
|
Posts: 10 |
|
|
Posts: 426  |
Posts: 426
I still consider the album excellent. At first I was very turned off, but over the last year I've found myself coming back time and time again. I absolutely love it.
Loading...
|
| Luneth
Account deleted |
Hits total: 4553 | This month: 9