Written by Richard on 16.12.2009 at 05:07

Written by SatyriconChick on 16.12.2009 at 03:18

I honestly can't say. Who knows what might have happened had Dave been allowed to stay in the band? One thing I do know is that they probably wouldn't have put out a good deal of songs we've gotten out of them if Dave were still there and Kirk had never been with them.

Possibly, but then again who knows how the band would've changed? It's not as if Dave is the 'Metal guy' who wouldn't have ever taken a non-Metal direction, because Megadeth haven't exactly been consistent there either! People's attitudes change over time, and also various different scenarios could've happened even if the original line-up had remained, which could've altered the course of the music...

you talk very nice rechard, if you are not a fanboy! may I see your album votes to know if you are a fanboy or not?

anyway really liked your posts about metallica, really rational.

Written by Guest on 16.12.2009 at 18:48

Written by Richard on 16.12.2009 at 05:07

Written by SatyriconChick on 16.12.2009 at 03:18

I honestly can't say. Who knows what might have happened had Dave been allowed to stay in the band? One thing I do know is that they probably wouldn't have put out a good deal of songs we've gotten out of them if Dave were still there and Kirk had never been with them.

Possibly, but then again who knows how the band would've changed? It's not as if Dave is the 'Metal guy' who wouldn't have ever taken a non-Metal direction, because Megadeth haven't exactly been consistent there either! People's attitudes change over time, and also various different scenarios could've happened even if the original line-up had remained, which could've altered the course of the music...

you talk very nice rechard, if you are not a fanboy! may I see your album votes to know if you are a fanboy or not?

anyway really liked your posts about metallica, really rational.

Thanks - I think! My Metallica collection is here:

http://www.metalstorm.ee/users/collection.php?user_id=1722&wishlist=&tradelist=&c_where=bandname&c_what=Metallica

I haven't actually voted on any of those releases, though...

Written by Richard on 17.12.2009 at 01:40

Written by Guest on 16.12.2009 at 18:48

Written by Richard on 16.12.2009 at 05:07

Written by SatyriconChick on 16.12.2009 at 03:18

I honestly can't say. Who knows what might have happened had Dave been allowed to stay in the band? One thing I do know is that they probably wouldn't have put out a good deal of songs we've gotten out of them if Dave were still there and Kirk had never been with them.

Possibly, but then again who knows how the band would've changed? It's not as if Dave is the 'Metal guy' who wouldn't have ever taken a non-Metal direction, because Megadeth haven't exactly been consistent there either! People's attitudes change over time, and also various different scenarios could've happened even if the original line-up had remained, which could've altered the course of the music...

you talk very nice rechard, if you are not a fanboy! may I see your album votes to know if you are a fanboy or not?

anyway really liked your posts about metallica, really rational.

Thanks - I think! My Metallica collection is here:

http://www.metalstorm.ee/users/collection.php?user_id=1722&wishlist=&tradelist=&c_where=bandname&c_what=Metallica

I haven't actually voted on any of those releases, though...

it was a bell for someone who tries to say Im a fanboy cause I have a lot of 10 votes for metallica but to be honest for me ppl how vote 5 6 for black album: you are very metal

I can't say, 'cause IMO, MUstaine's and Kirks styles are different, when it comes to solos, maybe with teh songwriting they would have gone a bit less into personal lyrics and that kinda stuff. Butthat's something I can't imagine, TBH.

Can't say. If Dave was still in the band I guess the lyrics would've been better, but you got to remember that their relationships were/are pretty bad, so I guess it would've damage the music...

I think if dave was with them, jaymz would go to rehab sooner.

Written by Panterica on 26.12.2009 at 12:02

Can't say. If Dave was still in the band I guess the lyrics would've been better, but you got to remember that their relationships were/are pretty bad, so I guess it would've damage the music...

I have nothing against Mustaine's lyrics, but I think Hetfield writes much better ones.

Written by Warman on 26.12.2009 at 19:54

Written by Panterica on 26.12.2009 at 12:02

Can't say. If Dave was still in the band I guess the lyrics would've been better, but you got to remember that their relationships were/are pretty bad, so I guess it would've damage the music...

I have nothing against Mustaine's lyrics, but I think Hetfield writes much better ones.

at least Metallica without Dave has not a music video with Christiana Scabbia. Im very happy.

If they kept Mustaine Metallica would never have had the commerical success they have seen today. Probably keeping within the same leagues of bands like Testament, Exodus etc.... but never breaking out to be an arena rock band.

So Mustaine in Metallica would surely have kept the band from reaching commercial success? Why do so many believe that? Oh sorry, more likely, why do so many KNOW that? Seems that many here are 100 % sure of what would happen, no speculations.

I'm fairly sure of talking of the implications of change of event that happened in 1983/84 would be speculation and not solid knowledge, but just so I don't confuse you as to if I am being clarvoyant or speculating. The above post of mine is what I think might have happened not a 100% certainty.




Glad we cleared that up.

Haha yeah don't worry about it, everyone's got an opinion, fine with me. I was just so tired of users writing stuff like they were absolutely sure about what would happen with Dave in the band. No "I think", "I guess", "maybe", "what if" etc. etc.

Megadeath>Metallica

Written by Bitter Dawn on 29.12.2009 at 02:34

Megadeath>Metallica

Never heard of a band called Megadeath, is that your new band?

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 29.12.2009 at 08:44

Written by Bitter Dawn on 29.12.2009 at 02:34

Megadeath>Metallica

Never heard of a band called Megadeath, is that your new band?

I think it might be a amateur band who cover Megadeth songs!

Real funny smart asses. That whole Metalocalypse/Dethklock thing throws me off from time to time. I honestly don't understand why people even bother with Metallica any more, those guys have sucked for the better part of the last 14 years, Load was some what forgivable, at least compared to St.Anger and so on.

Not to mention, there was a lot better music coming out during the 80's and early 90's, they really should just throw in the towel and stop emberassing themselves.

Written by Bitter Dawn on 29.12.2009 at 18:42

... Load was some what forgivable, at least compared to St.Anger and so on.

I just forgave Mustaine when he made a duet with a bitch. what a big difference metallica sings for poor prostitutes (Turn the Page) then Mustaine makes a Duet with the sexiest female vocalist (take a look at Rolling Stone Magazine) for "A Tout Le Monde".

in the end, read Dave's last funny Letter, he says: "I was praying (piss myself laughing) to be friend with slayer and metallica again!" , ask him why he cares about metallica anymore?

Written by Guest on 30.12.2009 at 02:42

Written by Bitter Dawn on 29.12.2009 at 18:42

... Load was some what forgivable, at least compared to St.Anger and so on.

I just forgave Mustaine when he made a duet with a bitch. what a big difference metallica sings for poor prostitutes (Turn the Page) then Mustaine makes a Duet with the sexiest female vocalist (take a look at Rolling Stone Magazine) for "A Tout Le Monde".

in the end, read Dave's last funny Letter, he says: "I was praying (piss myself laughing) to be friend with slayer and metallica again!" , ask him why he cares about metallica anymore?

Dude, can you stop bashing Megadeth and Mustaine for the mere sake of bashing them. Stop talking shit.

Written by K✞ulu on 31.12.2009 at 08:21

Written by Guest on 30.12.2009 at 02:42

Written by Bitter Dawn on 29.12.2009 at 18:42

... Load was some what forgivable, at least compared to St.Anger and so on.

I just forgave Mustaine when he made a duet with a bitch. what a big difference metallica sings for poor prostitutes (Turn the Page) then Mustaine makes a Duet with the sexiest female vocalist (take a look at Rolling Stone Magazine) for "A Tout Le Monde".

in the end, read Dave's last funny Letter, he says: "I was praying (piss myself laughing) to be friend with slayer and metallica again!" , ask him why he cares about metallica anymore?

Dude, can you stop bashing Megadeth and Mustaine for the mere sake of bashing them. Stop talking shit.

I wont till ppl talking wrong about metallica just for hold mustaine's back. the shit which you are talking about was an answer or you are blind?

secondly you are not supposed to give me advice about my words, as I remember your quotes are always seems advices to me. change the manner or dont quote me.

Written by Guest on 31.12.2009 at 08:39

Written by K✞ulu on 31.12.2009 at 08:21

Written by Guest on 30.12.2009 at 02:42

Written by Bitter Dawn on 29.12.2009 at 18:42

... Load was some what forgivable, at least compared to St.Anger and so on.

I just forgave Mustaine when he made a duet with a bitch. what a big difference metallica sings for poor prostitutes (Turn the Page) then Mustaine makes a Duet with the sexiest female vocalist (take a look at Rolling Stone Magazine) for "A Tout Le Monde".

in the end, read Dave's last funny Letter, he says: "I was praying (piss myself laughing) to be friend with slayer and metallica again!" , ask him why he cares about metallica anymore?

Dude, can you stop bashing Megadeth and Mustaine for the mere sake of bashing them. Stop talking shit.

I wont till ppl talking wrong about metallica just for hold mustaine's back. the shit which you are talking about was an answer or you are blind?

People will continue talking talking shit about Metallica. That doesn't mean you should talk shit about Megadeth as a response to that. That's not the way out (especially for the purpose of defending Metallica).

Written by K✞ulu on 31.12.2009 at 08:49

Written by Guest on 31.12.2009 at 08:39

Written by K✞ulu on 31.12.2009 at 08:21

Written by Guest on 30.12.2009 at 02:42

Written by Bitter Dawn on 29.12.2009 at 18:42

... Load was some what forgivable, at least compared to St.Anger and so on.

I just forgave Mustaine when he made a duet with a bitch. what a big difference metallica sings for poor prostitutes (Turn the Page) then Mustaine makes a Duet with the sexiest female vocalist (take a look at Rolling Stone Magazine) for "A Tout Le Monde".

in the end, read Dave's last funny Letter, he says: "I was praying (piss myself laughing) to be friend with slayer and metallica again!" , ask him why he cares about metallica anymore?

Dude, can you stop bashing Megadeth and Mustaine for the mere sake of bashing them. Stop talking shit.

I wont till ppl talking wrong about metallica just for hold mustaine's back. the shit which you are talking about was an answer or you are blind?

People will continue talking talking shit about Metallica. That doesn't mean you should talk shit about Megadeth as a response to that. That's not the way out (especially for the purpose of defending Metallica).

you think its just a respond? no, I said the truth. if James did such song with Scabbia I would erase Metallica from my favorite bands. I hate ppl who do anything for money! and its Megadeth not Metallica. its what I think, true or false.

Written by Guest on 31.12.2009 at 09:29

if James did such song with Scabbia I would erase Metallica from my favorite bands.

yeah... right...

Written by Guest on 31.12.2009 at 09:29

I hate ppl who do anything for money!

Are you saying Metallica have never done anything for money? One could argue that any music video that any does is for money.

And why are you saying that singing a song with Scabbia is a sell-out move? And what does her sexiness have to do with anything. And don't call her a bitch. wtf?

@ktulu, everyone have an opinion, I call her a bitch cause I didnt like her photos in rolling stones, whats the difference btw her and Britney then?

about metallica and do things for money, yes all ppl do things for money but the way of doing it is very important. you can be a bitch and make money you can do a lot of things. you can say that other bands are sell-out and do what the fuck you want! Im not a Mustaine or megadeth enemy, but just trying to show Megadeth's faults to blinds, I dont have to count metallica's faults over here, I thinkn there are a lot of ppl who are trying to do this with the worst manner. I cant understand who brainwashed them! for example, if megadeth was released Black Album, now ppl were talking about a masterpiece. but now cause Metallica is big as hell, they say its a normal album. piss myself laughing, just ppl who are really DEF can give a rate under 9 to that album.

Ok, don't really know anything about Scabbia, so can't comment on what you said. But as far as the Black Album, Megadeth had their own called Countdown to Extinction. And there are people who hate the two bands for releasing those records and there are others who like them, so your normal/masterpiece argument just doesn't make sense. And as far as rating albums... people have different tastes; live with it.

Written by K✞ulu on 31.12.2009 at 16:05

Ok, don't really know anything about Scabbia, so can't comment on what you said. But as far as the Black Album, Megadeth had their own called Countdown to Extinction. And there are people who hate the two bands for releasing those records and there are others who like them, so your normal/masterpiece argument just doesn't make sense. And as far as rating albums... people have different tastes; live with it.

take a look at my album votes, "Cryptic Writings" got 10 IMO. I really dont hate Megadeth, but the problem is that MEgadeth's fans cant take metallica always. but we are not like them. But when they dont calm down and cant talk rational, then its time to show them the truth. when a fan of megadeth says why ppl care about metallica, then he should know that Mustaine wrote a letter and its very clear that how he cares about metallica that was all which I wanted to say.

Wow, what a heavy discussion...Who wants ice-cream?

Written by Richard on 17.12.2009 at 01:40

Written by Guest on 16.12.2009 at 18:48

Written by Richard on 16.12.2009 at 05:07

Written by SatyriconChick on 16.12.2009 at 03:18

I honestly can't say. Who knows what might have happened had Dave been allowed to stay in the band? One thing I do know is that they probably wouldn't have put out a good deal of songs we've gotten out of them if Dave were still there and Kirk had never been with them.

Possibly, but then again who knows how the band would've changed? It's not as if Dave is the 'Metal guy' who wouldn't have ever taken a non-Metal direction, because Megadeth haven't exactly been consistent there either! People's attitudes change over time, and also various different scenarios could've happened even if the original line-up had remained, which could've altered the course of the music...

you talk very nice rechard, if you are not a fanboy! may I see your album votes to know if you are a fanboy or not?

anyway really liked your posts about metallica, really rational.

Thanks - I think! My Metallica collection is here:

http://www.metalstorm.ee/users/collection.php?user_id=1722&wishlist=&tradelist=&c_where=bandname&c_what=Metallica

I haven't actually voted on any of those releases, though...

it seems that you erased your votes about metallica recently.

Written by Guest on 05.01.2010 at 07:53

Written by Richard on 17.12.2009 at 01:40

Written by Guest on 16.12.2009 at 18:48

Written by Richard on 16.12.2009 at 05:07

Written by SatyriconChick on 16.12.2009 at 03:18

I honestly can't say. Who knows what might have happened had Dave been allowed to stay in the band? One thing I do know is that they probably wouldn't have put out a good deal of songs we've gotten out of them if Dave were still there and Kirk had never been with them.

Possibly, but then again who knows how the band would've changed? It's not as if Dave is the 'Metal guy' who wouldn't have ever taken a non-Metal direction, because Megadeth haven't exactly been consistent there either! People's attitudes change over time, and also various different scenarios could've happened even if the original line-up had remained, which could've altered the course of the music...

you talk very nice rechard, if you are not a fanboy! may I see your album votes to know if you are a fanboy or not?

anyway really liked your posts about metallica, really rational.

Thanks - I think! My Metallica collection is here:

http://www.metalstorm.ee/users/collection.php?user_id=1722&wishlist=&tradelist=&c_where=bandname&c_what=Metallica

I haven't actually voted on any of those releases, though...

it seems that you erased your votes about metallica recently.

Nope, as I said, I haven't voted on any of the Metallica releases, I haven't recently changed anything in that respect...

Written by Panterica on 04.01.2010 at 18:08

Wow, what a heavy discussion...Who wants ice-cream?

I do.

Written by K✞ulu on 31.12.2009 at 08:21

Written by Guest on 30.12.2009 at 02:42

Written by Bitter Dawn on 29.12.2009 at 18:42

... Load was some what forgivable, at least compared to St.Anger and so on.

I just forgave Mustaine when he made a duet with a bitch. what a big difference metallica sings for poor prostitutes (Turn the Page) then Mustaine makes a Duet with the sexiest female vocalist (take a look at Rolling Stone Magazine) for "A Tout Le Monde".

in the end, read Dave's last funny Letter, he says: "I was praying (piss myself laughing) to be friend with slayer and metallica again!" , ask him why he cares about metallica anymore?

Dude, can you stop bashing Megadeth and Mustaine for the mere sake of bashing them. Stop talking shit.

An interesting hypothesis.