Metal Storm logo
Cradle Of Filth - Hammer Of The Witches review



Reviewer:
9.0

341 users:
8.22
Band: Cradle Of Filth
Album: Hammer Of The Witches
Style: Extreme gothic metal, Symphonic metal
Release date: July 10, 2015
Guest review by: X-FrEaK


01. Walpurgis Eve
02. Yours Immortally...
03. Enshrined In Crematoria
04. Deflowering The Maidenhead, Displeasuring The Goddess
05. Blackest Magick In Practice
06. The Monstrous Sabbat (Summoning The Coven)
07. Hammer Of The Witches
08. Right Wing Of The Garden Triptych
09. The Vampyre At My Side
10. Onward Christian Soldiers
11. Blooding The Hounds Of Hell
12. King Of The Woods [bonus]
13. Misericord [bonus]

There are two ways that metal bands tend to choose to (not) stay relevant throughout their careers: The Opethian Way or the Amon Amarthian Way. The former consists of changing your musical direction aggressively, which is a lot riskier and can sometimes alienate a lot of old school fans (ex: Opeth or In Flames), but on the other hand it can provide a much-needed second wind (ex: Paradise Lost or Machine Head). The latter consists of staying true to your winning formula and changing nothing or very little from album to album, which may or may not keep your old school fans interested. For me, Amon Amarth are the band that best represents this formula, and I have lost interest in their most recent albums, as it's just more of the same.

Cradle Of Filth belong somewhere in the middle, since no one can say that the last four albums before Hammer Of The Witches are at all similar, but at the same time they are not as different as, say, Opeth's Heritage. Nevertheless, they are not masterpieces, not by a longshot, and some Cradle fans, myself included, have lost some hope of seeing Dani Filth returning his band to the spotlight once again. After Thornography, there was a sort of comeback with Godspeed On The Devil's Thunder, but it still wasn't the old Cradle. The two albums that followed, although not terrible, were completely forgettable.

So it is with great pleasure that I witness one of the best comebacks in metal's recent history (akin to Machine Head's The Blackening). Although it gave every impression of failure since Paul Allender was leaving, it seems that his creative input was one of the main things holding this band back. The two replacement guitarists, Marek ?merda and Richard Shaw, pulled out something that Paul Allender lost a long time ago: memorable riffs and catchy songs! Remember how Darkly, Darkly, Venus Aversa seemed like a really long song instead of an actual album with structured and diverse songs? Hammer of the Witches is the opposite (maybe not reaching the heights of Midian, but very close) providing a lot of memorable songs, from which I would have to highlight "Deflowering The Maidenhead, Displeasuring The Goddess"; it is a really great song with a lot of varied sections, and there has not been a song like this in a Cradle record for a very, very long time.

One of the things that impressed me the most was Dani Filth's voices. At some point in time it seemed his voice was almost gone and he was unable to pull out his signature shrieks, but he sounds impressive here. Kudos to you, Mr. Filth!

Martin continues his great work behind the drum kit (he has been the member in the highest form in their latest releases) and Lindsay Schoolcraft gives a solid backing vocal performance; thankfully it appears more often here, althought it still doesn't reach the quality of Sarah Jezebel Deva.

In the end Hammer of the Witches is a comeback in every sense of the word and stands as one of the best albums in Cradle Of Filth's history. Let's hope they can keep raising or maintaining the bar next time!


Rating breakdown
Performance: 10
Songwriting: 9
Originality: 9
Production: 10

Written by X-FrEaK | 17.09.2015




Guest review disclaimer:
This is a guest review, which means it does not necessarily represent the point of view of the MS Staff.

Staff review by
Windrider
Rating:
6.0
It must be tough to be Dani Filth right now. The voice of your early career has left you and the one thing you can still properly sing is some gentle gothic metal as last seen on the Godspeed On The Devil's Thunder album. However, for this kind of music your chief songwriter has just left you. The departure of Paul Allender was both sad and promising. He is a great guitarist, yet most fans can agree that the band was in bloom at the times he wasn't around. That is why I personally had some hopes. But as it often turns out in the end, he should not have left.

Read more ››
published 26.06.2015 | Comments (54)


Comments

Comments: 6   Visited by: 147 users
17.09.2015 - 11:49
TheMAGAmvm
Soycrusher
Nice review. I think this one compliments the album in the best way possible. Too bad few people realized that this album would be a great comeback. This is nothing like the first 3 albums, and like you said, not as good as Midian, but definitely close.
Loading...
17.09.2015 - 17:10
Andresopeth
Haven't heard this record yet, I tottaly agree with the line:

"here was a sort of comeback with Godspeed On The Devil's Thunder, but it still wasn't the old Cradle. The two albums that followed, although not terrible, were completely forgettable"

I like Godspeed On The Devil's Thunder much more than Nymphetamine and Damnation And A Day, regarding the other s two albums i really can remember any song from them, even when i played at least 20 times on their respective releases.
Will check this out expecting to find something memorable.

Thanks for the review
Loading...
17.09.2015 - 18:28
Rating: 8
Warman
Erotic Stains
Good review, especially the first passages. It's certainly not a total comeback to the old sound, but here and there Cradle reminds you of their classic sound. Most importantly, it's a damn good album.
----
Loading...
17.09.2015 - 23:36
Rating: 9
X-FrEaK
Written by Andresopeth on 17.09.2015 at 17:10

Haven't heard this record yet, I tottaly agree with the line:

"here was a sort of comeback with Godspeed On The Devil's Thunder, but it still wasn't the old Cradle. The two albums that followed, although not terrible, were completely forgettable"

I like Godspeed On The Devil's Thunder much more than Nymphetamine and Damnation And A Day, regarding the other s two albums i really can remember any song from them, even when i played at least 20 times on their respective releases.
Will check this out expecting to find something memorable.

Thanks for the review

No problem mate! Nevertheless I really like the two albums you mentioned. For me, after Nymphetamine, was when Cradle started to lose my interest
----
Loading...
18.09.2015 - 02:29
Rating: 8
Good review.

I wouldn't call this a comeback though, unless they continue producing good music in next releases. Like you said, Godspeed was sort of a comeback, but what came after proved wrong.
Loading...
11.02.2016 - 14:35
Rating: 8
s_t_s
Took me some time to get into this one, but now I really love it tho I won't call it black nor brutal music (Godspeed was nastier on that topic !).. Yet it sounds very good and inspired with lots of breakdowns where Manticore gave me the uneasing impression that I didn't remember any part of it after several full spins...

Anyway I've followed Cradle of Filth since Cruelty and The Beast and I will go on as long as they bring me what I expect from metal : thrills and mesmerizing melodies. I don't give a shit about people who complain about CoF not redoing Midian for the 10th time. Keep going guys !
Loading...

Hits total: 3358 | This month: 11