Gothmog_Motsham
Posts: 665 |
I found the album rather disappointing indeed because of the written reasons. Also the vocalist didn't do much for me. I honestly kept0 wondering how the album will sound with a black metal vocalist and heavier riffing
Loading...
|
Opethian
Posts: 1758 |
Why not just Luca Turilli?
Loading...
|
Therapy?
Posts: 174
|
12.06.2015 - 18:55Rating: 8
Overall this review doesn't bode well for my expectations except this sentence: "The music itself borrows heavily from Luca Turilli solo projects such as the science fiction-themed Prophet Of The Last Eclipse"
PotLE is truly a great album, one of Turilli's best efforts.
Loading...
|
SoUnDs LiKe PoP
Posts: 1060
|
"but this comes at the cost of the catchy lyrics and sing along parts that made his earlier work so infectious"
This sums it all up perfectly for this project.
----
I lift weights and listen to metal
Loading...
|
chronic-headache
Posts: 249 |
I don't know if I can continue reading this after you saying " Luca Turilli's Rhapsody didn't do that much better with Ascending To Infinity"...seriously? That album was amazing.
Loading...
|
Bad English Tage Westerlund
Posts: 62060 |
This band no metter original or new is same lol sounds same
----
I stand whit Ukraine and Israel. They have right to defend own citizens.
Stormtroopers of Death - "Speak English or Die"
I better die, because I never will learn speek english, so I choose dieing
Loading...
|
Belegûr Arise In Might!
Posts: 365 |
13.06.2015 - 02:26Rating: 7
Written by chronic-headache on 12.06.2015 at 21:18
I don't know if I can continue reading this after you saying " Luca Turilli's Rhapsody didn't do that much better with Ascending To Infinity"...seriously? That album was amazing.
That's the amazing thing about opinions. I'm happy you find Ascending To Infinity amazing, it means you will probably like this one too.
Loading...
|
chronic-headache
Posts: 249 |
Written by Belegûr on 13.06.2015 at 02:26
Written by chronic-headache on 12.06.2015 at 21:18
I don't know if I can continue reading this after you saying " Luca Turilli's Rhapsody didn't do that much better with Ascending To Infinity"...seriously? That album was amazing.
That's the amazing thing about opinions. I'm happy you find Ascending To Infinity amazing, it means you will probably like this one too.
Opinions yes, gotta love em, haha. Your just the first I've come across who wasn't impressed by it. If I remember correctly AtI was hailed as the continuation of the original rhapsody (in spirit) and universally praised.
Loading...
|
Byners
Posts: 215 |
I'm still curious. Rosenkreuz (The Rose And The Cross) is a great song and also is Prometheus. Although the last one really might have some serious lyrics problems... But I can dig that :v
----
"Seize the day or die regretting the time you lost..."
Loading...
|
Lokasenna
Posts: 63
|
Written by Therapy? on 12.06.2015 at 18:55
Overall this review doesn't bode well for my expectations except this sentence: "The music itself borrows heavily from Luca Turilli solo projects such as the science fiction-themed Prophet Of The Last Eclipse"
PotLE is truly a great album, one of Turilli's best efforts.
I'm still pissed off that he seems to have forgotten about that story, since he said at the time there would be a second part. Easily my favorite power-cheese album.
Loading...
|
Belegûr Arise In Might!
Posts: 365 |
13.06.2015 - 11:19Rating: 7
Written by chronic-headache on 13.06.2015 at 04:29
Written by Belegûr on 13.06.2015 at 02:26
Written by chronic-headache on 12.06.2015 at 21:18
I don't know if I can continue reading this after you saying " Luca Turilli's Rhapsody didn't do that much better with Ascending To Infinity"...seriously? That album was amazing.
That's the amazing thing about opinions. I'm happy you find Ascending To Infinity amazing, it means you will probably like this one too.
Opinions yes, gotta love em, haha. Your just the first I've come across who wasn't impressed by it. If I remember correctly AtI was hailed as the continuation of the original rhapsody (in spirit) and universally praised.
It wasn't praised on here. I've given this album a higher score than that one received. I never once said it was terrible though, just not particularly good.
Loading...
|
Therapy?
Posts: 174
|
13.06.2015 - 18:00Rating: 8
Written by Lokasenna on 13.06.2015 at 07:18
Written by Therapy? on 12.06.2015 at 18:55
Overall this review doesn't bode well for my expectations except this sentence: "The music itself borrows heavily from Luca Turilli solo projects such as the science fiction-themed Prophet Of The Last Eclipse"
PotLE is truly a great album, one of Turilli's best efforts.
I'm still pissed off that he seems to have forgotten about that story, since he said at the time there would be a second part. Easily my favorite power-cheese album.
I sure hope he will create a second part at some point and in the same style as PotLE. Infinite Wonders of Creation was awful.
Loading...
|
Belegûr Arise In Might!
Posts: 365 |
14.06.2015 - 15:06Rating: 7
Written by Therapy? on 13.06.2015 at 18:00
Written by Lokasenna on 13.06.2015 at 07:18
Written by Therapy? on 12.06.2015 at 18:55
Overall this review doesn't bode well for my expectations except this sentence: "The music itself borrows heavily from Luca Turilli solo projects such as the science fiction-themed Prophet Of The Last Eclipse"
PotLE is truly a great album, one of Turilli's best efforts.
I'm still pissed off that he seems to have forgotten about that story, since he said at the time there would be a second part. Easily my favorite power-cheese album.
I sure hope he will create a second part at some point and in the same style as PotLE. Infinite Wonders of Creation was awful.
Unfortunately I don't think he will. I remember comments he made about why he didn't choose Olaf Hayer as the vocalist for this Rhapsody and it was to do with the diversity of the voice needed for the music he wanted to make. Unfortunately it seems like Luca sees Prophet as a bit too simple for the music he wants to do and that's why we have Prometheus. I agree with you though, Prophet is a great album. I think it's his best solo album and is better than most of the modern Rhapsody albums.
Loading...
|
Netzach Planewalker
Posts: 1761 |
The overly flamboyant and pretentious album and song titles make me wanna vomit all over this page. I will stay the hell away from this, however good it might be.
"Symphonia Ignis Divinus (The Quantum Gate Revealed)"
"Nova Genesis (Ad Splendorem Angeli Triumphantis)"
What the jumping f... Even without the extra parentheses this makes my eyes bleed.
----
My "blackened synth metal" solo project: maladomini.bandcamp.com.
Whenever I write something funny, weird, or pretentious... I learned English by playing Baldur's Gate, okay?
Loading...
|
fandango68
Posts: 194 |
16.06.2015 - 10:08Rating: 8
Written by Belegûr on 13.06.2015 at 11:19 It wasn't praised on here. I've given this album a higher score than that one received. I never once said it was terrible though, just not particularly good.
Overall, I preferred AtI to DWoS, which was OK, but lacked sparkle and sounded a bit like 'Rhapsody by numbers', which, try as I might, I struggled to get enthused by. Both albums lacked a certain, obvious ingredient, although I think AtI contained more originality and was more diverse. I also must confess I like Conti's voice. That said, these tracks don't represent an overall improvement in quality for me, so the jury is still out on the whole project.
----
First gig was Manowar (loincloths 'n' all), Bristol Colston Hall in March 1983, on the 'Hail to England' tour. Tickets were £3.75, 300 in the audience, Mercyful Fate never showed, but my hearing still got seriously trashed..
Loading...
|
Yavanna
Posts: 616 |
Since I do study Latin, I think I might really like this album
----
Carry me to the shoreline
Bury me in the sand
Walk me across the water
And maybe you'll understand
Loading...
|
Belegûr Arise In Might!
Posts: 365 |
17.06.2015 - 23:22Rating: 7
Written by Yavanna on 17.06.2015 at 23:11
Since I do study Latin, I think I might really like this album
haha
Then you can come back and tell me what it all means
Loading...
|
Yavanna
Posts: 616 |
----
Carry me to the shoreline
Bury me in the sand
Walk me across the water
And maybe you'll understand
Loading...
|
CoFVe
Posts: 4
|
21.06.2015 - 17:55Rating: 10
I dont agree on certain points of this review, mainly the 6 points of originality, because i think that there is nothing out there that could be similar to something like this album, even his previous album was a little bit different, and to the reference to the lyrics, i would give fewer points, because it seems like was writen by a 15 year old child.
Loading...
|
Belegûr Arise In Might!
Posts: 365 |
21.06.2015 - 20:00Rating: 7
Written by CoFVe on 21.06.2015 at 17:55
I dont agree on certain points of this review, mainly the 6 points of originality, because i think that there is nothing out there that could be similar to something like this album, even his previous album was a little bit different, and to the reference to the lyrics, i would give fewer points, because it seems like was writen by a 15 year old child.
I gave it an above average score for originality. 6 isn't bad, but I certainly wouldn't give this album a higher score for originality personally. Luca Turilli has ran out of tricks and none of it was surprising.
Loading...
|
jtowne1968 Account deleted |
jtowne1968 Account deleted
I love "Prometheus Symphonia Ignis Divinus" from an orchestration perspective (always a hallmark of this band and Rhapsody of Fire) but I have to agree that there is a lack of catchy songwriting. I don't believe that we have seen a truly great album from Rhapsody, Rhapsody of Fire or any of the various Luca Turilli projects since 2002's "Power of the Dragonflame" album. That said, this album is really well put together and extremely well played.
Loading...
|
Belegûr Arise In Might!
Posts: 365 |
30.06.2015 - 15:58Rating: 7
Written by [user id=156071] on 28.06.2015 at 01:44
I love "Prometheus Symphonia Ignis Divinus" from an orchestration perspective (always a hallmark of this band and Rhapsody of Fire) but I have to agree that there is a lack of catchy songwriting. I don't believe that we have seen a truly great album from Rhapsody, Rhapsody of Fire or any of the various Luca Turilli projects since 2002's "Power of the Dragonflame" album. That said, this album is really well put together and extremely well played.
I do agree. Hopefully my review didn't come across as "too negative". A lot of people online see a score of 7 as being bad, though to me a 7 means "good", just not great, excellent of perfect etc etc. The album is good, it's just not anything better than that in my opinion. I did give Production and Performance 9 out of 10 as I do think like you say "this album is really well put together and extremely well played."
Obviously I would never expect Rhapsody (either one) to just keep doing what they have always done, but a part of me does miss the catchy albums from Legendary Tales to Power of the Dragonflame. One thing I will say, if I give this album a 7.2, I would have to give the Rhapsody of Fire album "Dark Wings of Steel" a 5 or something...
Loading...
|
jtowne1968 Account deleted |
jtowne1968 Account deleted
I agree totally! A review of anything over 6 is good. 8"s and 9's should be for really special albums. 10's should only be used for stuff like "Legendary Tales", "Keeper of the Seven Keys", "Stained Class" and "Number of the Beast"!
I'm actually listening to "Prometheus Symphonia Ignis Divinus" right now. Your review was fair and accurate.
Loading...
|
Creativinity
Posts: 79 |
22.11.2015 - 11:23Rating: 9
I like this album. I also happen to like cinematic metal. Oh....
Loading...
|
Belegûr Arise In Might!
Posts: 365 |
22.11.2015 - 18:28Rating: 7
Written by Creativinity on 22.11.2015 at 11:23
I like this album. I also happen to like cinematic metal. Oh....
It's a made up genre really though isn't it? haha. Didn't Rhapsody say they were "Hollywood Metal" at some point. This is just symphonic power metal really isn't it?
Loading...
|
NahuelBenvenuto
Posts: 7
|
I had an old comment here somewhere, but anyway here it goes again: This album is a work of art, nothing more, nothing less.
Loading...
|