One of my favorite albums... Add Reality being the highlight for me, the majestic riffs and great melodies.

Uncreation is, and always been, the highlight for me in a bunch of otherwise virtually perfect songs.

Written by [user id=4365] on 21.08.2010 at 21:15

Uncreation is, and always been, the highlight for me in a bunch of otherwise virtually perfect songs.

Totally.
Stunning album, absolutely stunning start to finish.

When i heard it the first time each songs gave me goosebumps and it still .. this album is magic ,dont know why it is not well known as crimson and crimson II of Edge Of Sanity .. dan swano is probably the best musician ,song writer and sound engineer in the entire world

Excellent album, all of the songs are beautifully composed, especially "Add Reality"...

Lovely piece of prog, but somehow the album as a whole didn't quite "click" for me. I adore it, but I cannot give it a 10 at the moment, maybe it will grow on me. I actually would prefer if the album was instrumental, sorry Dan.

EDIT: As expected, time (and listening to the album repeatedly again and again and...) changed my mind about the vocals. I now think that the harsh vocals accompanying the beautiful, often very uplifting melodies form a wonderful contrast and the album would suffer for the lack of this. This album is very, very close to perfection.

Sun of the Night and Add Reality are both some of the best pieces of music I've ever heard.

Fantastic album. Ultimate prog album in my collection

This man, he's... blah. This is probably one of the most pleasant-sounding prog albums ever, instantly catchy but with ensured longevity. Like all the best traits of Nightingale X 10.

Written by Milena on 16.06.2012 at 21:47

This man, he's... blah. This is probably one of the most pleasant-sounding prog albums ever, instantly catchy but with ensured longevity.

Never thought I'd say this about an album, but I agree with you

Written by [user id=4365] on 16.06.2012 at 22:29

Never thought I'd say this about an album, but I agree with you

Yeah I'm usually too cheesy and sentimental about music.

Proud owner of this disc D

Why isn't this album in the Top 200?

Written by [user id=135634] on 13.05.2013 at 16:12

Why isn't this album in the Top 200?

1) Score is not high enough. 2) Not enough votes.

I agree though, it deserves to be in the top 200, even if I personally don't like it.

Written by Kuroboshi on 14.08.2013 at 15:10

I agree though, it deserves to be in the top 200, even if I personally don't like it.

You may have changed your view of the album since your post but don't you think your vote should reflect what the album deserves?

Surely an album deserving its place amongst the top 200 is worthy of a 9 or 10 regardless of personal sentimental value

Written by LeKiwi on 10.12.2013 at 10:23

Written by Kuroboshi on 14.08.2013 at 15:10

I agree though, it deserves to be in the top 200, even if I personally don't like it.

You may have changed your view of the album since your post but don't you think your vote should reflect what the album deserves?

Surely an album deserving its place amongst the top 200 is worthy of a 9 or 10 regardless of personal sentimental value

I've tried listening to it several times, since I absolutely adore Swano. But, it's just boring, while being incredibly well done, to me (believe, I've tried to wrap my head around my feelings towards this album). Thus, it has a 6.

I think you should vote especially according to your personal sentimental value. All my album votes reflect how much I enjoyed listening to that particular album.

Written by Kuroboshi on 10.12.2013 at 11:31

I think you should vote especially according to your personal sentimental value. All my album votes reflect how much I enjoyed listening to that particular album.

That's exactly how people should vote. I can't fathom why someone would want to do otherwise.

Written by Kuroboshi on 10.12.2013 at 11:31

I've tried listening to it several times, since I absolutely adore Swano. But, it's just boring, while being incredibly well done, to me (believe, I've tried to wrap my head around my feelings towards this album). Thus, it has a 6.

I think you should vote especially according to your personal sentimental value. All my album votes reflect how much I enjoyed listening to that particular album.

Written by [user id=4365] on 10.12.2013 at 14:23

That's exactly how people should vote. I can't fathom why someone would want to do otherwise.

A perfectly reasonable notion, but such ideals limits your capacity to vote fairly. One should vote as a reviewer should rate: by forcing objectivity upon the process. Inaccessible albums are excessively underrated on the basis of personal sentimental value. Merit should always make up a large portion of the vote.

Written by LeKiwi on 10.12.2013 at 16:01

A perfectly reasonable notion, but such ideals limits your capacity to vote fairly. One should vote as a reviewer should rate: by forcing objectivity upon the process. Inaccessible albums are excessively underrated on the basis of personal sentimental value. Merit should always make up a large portion of the vote.

Disagree 100%. Votes should be as personal as one can make them.

I sense a discussion about fundamental differences of perspective.

So just because a band worked their asses off and make a grand album that many love I must rate it high despite me not liking it one bit? Sounds just wrong to say the least.

Written by Troy Killjoy on 10.12.2013 at 16:10

I sense a discussion about fundamental differences of perspective.

Nothing to discuss. People are allowed to vote how they like (within reason; probably worth pointing out that Lekiwi's voting antics got his votes wiped a little while ago.)

Written by [user id=4365] on 10.12.2013 at 16:06

Disagree 100%. Votes should be as personal as one can make them.

Your votes all make sense now

Written by LeKiwi on 10.12.2013 at 16:16

Your votes all make sense now

I would imagine my voting style is pretty indicative of the general populace of MS.

They are, Joe.

In fact, all votes are personal no matter how much you try to dress up the truth.

Written by [user id=4365] on 10.12.2013 at 16:18

I would imagine my voting style is pretty indicative of the general populace of MS.

As you are wont

Written by X-Ray Rod on 10.12.2013 at 16:20

In fact, all votes are personal no matter how much you try to dress up the truth.

If I rated based on my enjoyment of an album, my votes would be substantially lower. There are musical merits to be appreciated beyond that and voting should reflect just that: your level of appreciation.

Written by LeKiwi on 10.12.2013 at 16:26

If I rated based on my enjoyment of an album, my votes would be substantially lower. There are musical merits to be appreciated beyond that and voting should reflect just that: your level of appreciation.

If you ask me you're talking about reviews, not personal votes. Two different methods to approach a rating.

Written by [user id=4365] on 10.12.2013 at 16:28

If you ask me you're talking about reviews, not personal votes. Two different methods to approach a rating.

Wait a minute...you're among the users who perceive melodic death metal to be "overrated" on this website. How can such a notion exist if all votes are personal?

Edit: Overrated as in the album "deserves" a lower rating: your imposing your own level of appreciation there

Can we open an off-topic debate thread?