Oh boy how do I disagree with the top spot.

Written by Guib on 16.08.2023 at 22:41

Oh boy how do I disagree with the top spot.

me, too.

Ohhhhhh shock!!! 😯😯 Didn't see people disagreeing with my top spot coming at all haha. I'm just not cool enough to have the opinion that Arise or Beneath The Remains is number one 😭😭. To be fair, I couldn't understand if I picked Root's or a post Max C album but I don't understand people still trying to act like Chaos A.D. isn't easily up there with their best 🤷.

Oh BTW the top 2 probably rotate depending on what mood I'm in ☺️. But I just always go back to Chaos A.D. Personal preference, guys. I'm sure we all have favourites that aren't the general favourite amongst fans.

Written by Oldy86 on 17.08.2023 at 15:09

I just always go back to Chaos A.D. Personal preference, guys. I'm sure we all have favourites that aren't the general favourite amongst fans.

No problem, just disagreeing, that's all. I think I have a few odd favorites as well.

Written by Oldy86 on 17.08.2023 at 15:09

Ohhhhhh shock!!! 😯😯 Didn't see people disagreeing with my top spot coming at all haha. I'm just not cool enough to have the opinion that Arise or Beneath The Remains is number one 😭😭. To be fair, I couldn't understand if I picked Root's or a post Max C album but I don't understand people still trying to act like Chaos A.D. isn't easily up there with their best 🤷.

Oh BTW the top 2 probably rotate depending on what mood I'm in ☺️. But I just always go back to Chaos A.D. Personal preference, guys. I'm sure we all have favourites that aren't the general favourite amongst fans.

Never said it was a bad album or that it doesn't deserve to make the top 5, I actually think it does and rated it quite high. I just don't agree its the top spot. Also, we definitely do have favourites that aren't the general consensus.

My reply was all in jest, mate. I expected a lot to disagree with me. But like I say, I'm always torn on Chaos and Arise. I actually thought people would say Roots or the last two albums were too high. I actually think the last 2 albums have gave Sepultura new life. I loved them. Or I thought people might say MV was too low but I think it's very overrated due to it being the first. Cavaleras just massively improved that.

Written by Oldy86 on 17.08.2023 at 16:28

My reply was all in jest, mate. I expected a lot to disagree with me. But like I say, I'm always torn on Chaos and Arise. I actually thought people would say Roots or the last two albums were too high. I actually think the last 2 albums have gave Sepultura new life. I loved them. Or I thought people might say MV was too low but I think it's very overrated due to it being the first. Cavaleras just massively improved that.

Gotcha, I think MV is rated properly and unlike a lot of folks Im not one of those who hate Roots. It think its a decent album.

Chaos A.D. >>>>> Anything else by Sepultura

Written by A Real Mönkey on 17.08.2023 at 22:45

Chaos A.D. >>>>> Anything else by Sepultura

Stop being edgy.

Written by A Real Mönkey on 17.08.2023 at 22:45

Chaos A.D. >>>>> Anything else by Sepultura

Most people rejected his message. They hated Monkey because he told them the truth.

Written by A Real Mönkey on 18.08.2023 at 00:30

Most people rejected his message. They hated Monkey because he told them the truth.

Written by F3ynman on 18.08.2023 at 01:03

Written by A Real Mönkey on 18.08.2023 at 00:30

Most people rejected his message. They hated Monkey because he told them the truth.

Wise folks.

Really delighted to see Quadra and Machine Messiah so high up, especially the former. The more I listen to them, the more I appreciate the composition and the general vibe behind those records. Both contain an absolutely killer instrumental and some great clean vocal parts, both are diverse and well paced. Kinda hurts me to see how easily people can discard them without actually giving them a chance.

Also I've found myself enjoying Schizophrenia more and more lately, it would crack my top-5

The first three are the same for me

Written by tludmetal on 18.08.2023 at 12:57

The first three are the same for me

What do you mean the "same"? Same quality, same sound? Either way I disagree. The second album was an improvement on the debut, in song-writing that is. Same for the third one, huge improvement on their previous work. Their peak IMO. Only Arise comes close.

Written by John doe on 18.08.2023 at 13:09

Written by tludmetal on 18.08.2023 at 12:57

The first three are the same for me

What do you mean the "same"? Same quality, same sound? Either way I disagree. The second album was an improvement on the debut, in song-writing that is. Same for the third one, huge improvement on their previous work. Their peak IMO. Only Arise comes close.

I think he means my top 3 he'd rank the same as mine. At least that's what I assumed when reading it.

Also, although Arise may not be my number one on this list, I'd still objectively say it's easily their best and indeed where they peaked. Obviously I absolutely adore BTR, and objectively speaking is probably their 2nd best album. But I feel like the people that like their death metal sound more kinda overrate it a tad. I think their top 3 are all at least a 9, but Arise is simply their magnum opus.

No no, what you meant to do was...

1. Beneath The Remains
2. Arise
3. Chaos AD
4.Morbid Visions
5. Schizophrenia
6. Roots
7 - 17. Everything Else In Some Random Order

Written by Auntie Sahar on 26.08.2023 at 19:10

No no, what you meant to do was...

1. Beneath The Remains
2. Arise
3. Chaos AD
4.Morbid Visions
5. Schizophrenia
6. Roots
7 - 17. Everything Else In Some Random Order

Close enough, just switch Schizophrenia and Morbid Visions place. Good attempt though

Written by Guib on 26.08.2023 at 19:39

Close enough, just switch Schizophrenia and Morbid Visions place. Good attempt though

Yeah, hard to say which is the better album. Morbid Visions is rawer and definitely not as refined as Schizophrenia, but sometimes I prefer it for that exact reason. Nice and ugly

Why would anyone mean this? Lol Arise is absolutely better than BTR that's for sure. Unless You mean the new Cavalera version of Morbid then you've just overrated the hell out of that album. We get it, it's the first, so you feel obliged to put it high, but there's a few post Cavalera that's better. People that shit on post Cavalera, I just assume haven't listened to the album's. Or they maybe listened to one or 2 and decided to shit on them regardless for the rest of their existence lol. Seriously, if you haven't heard the last 2 albums then go do so, because they're more than deserving of being this high.

Written by Oldy86 on 26.08.2023 at 19:47

Why would anyone mean this? Lol Arise is absolutely better than BTR that's for sure. Unless You mean the new Cavalera version of Morbid then you've just overrated the hell out of that album. We get it, it's the first, so you feel obliged to put it high, but there's a few post Cavalera that's better. People that shit on post Cavalera, I just assume haven't listened to the album's. Or they maybe listened to one or 2 and decided to shit on them regardless for the rest of their existence lol. Seriously, if you haven't heard the last 2 albums then go do so, because they're more than deserving of being this high.

Who shat on any album?