Metal Storm logo
Nightwish - Dark Passion Play review



Reviewer:
7.5

1298 users:
7.74
Band: Nightwish
Album: Dark Passion Play
Style: Symphonic power metal
Release date: September 26, 2007
A review by: Baz Anderson


Disc I
01. The Poet And The Pendulum
02. Bye Bye Beautiful
03. Amaranth
04. Cadence Of Her Last Breath
05. Master Passion Greed
06. Eva
07. Sahara
08. Whoever Brings The Night
09. For The Heart I Once Had
10. The Islander
11. Last Of The Wilds
12. 7 Days To The Wolves
13. Meadows Of Heaven
14. Reach [Amaranth demo] [bonus]

Disc II [limited edition]
01. The Poet And The Pendulum [Instrumental]
02. Bye Bye Beautiful [Instrumental]
03. Amaranth [Instrumental]
04. Cadence Of Her Last Breath [Instrumental]
05. Master Passion Greed [Instrumental]
06. Eva [Instrumental]
07. Sahara [Instrumental]
08. Whoever Brings The Night [Instrumental]
09. For The Heart I Once Had [Instrumental]
10. The Islander [Instrumental]
11. Last Of The Wilds [Instrumental]
12. 7 Days To The Wolves [Instrumental]
13. Meadows Of Heaven [Instrumental]

Disc III [Limited 3CD Box Edition]
01. Escapist
02. Meadows Of Heaven [orchestral version]
03. The Poet And The Pendulum [demo]

All eyes have been on Nightwish over the last three years following the huge commercial success of previous album "Once" and of course also the dramatic letting go of previous vocal powerhouse Tarja. Now more than ever Tuomas and company have immense pressure placed upon them to deliver the goods with the sixth full length edition to the Nightwish catalogue.

As bombastic and grand as they have ever sounded, the fourteen minute monster of an opening track "The Poet And The Pendulum" is not just a statement to anyone who may have questioned the future of the band, but is also if you will, the title track with the pendulum on the front cover of the album and is also the epitome of the whole album to come. The band sound as heavy as they have ever been before - full of sound, many layers, the backbone of the music is still the same but of course the slightly different line-up brings with it some slight changes. One of the unique selling points of Nightwish was Tarja and her strong, classical, operatic voice booming over the metallic symphonies, but Anette has more of a rock type of singing that just does not project as Tarja's did, it isn't as powerful and has nothing really unique about it at all, but this still doesn't mean she doesn't have a sweet voice.

"Dark Passion Play" although still very much a Nightwish album is one of the most adventurous outings of the band's history. The album is more diverse than anything we have heard before and must be the bravest as well opening with a near quarter of an hour epic. "Amaranth" sounds very commercial and appealing to the wider audience, "Master Passion Greed" must be the heaviest thing this band have ever put onto CD with furious guitaring, double bass drumming and Marco taking to the lead vocal position, and to another far out tangent of the musical spectrum of the album we even have strong folk elements with "The Islander" and "Last Of The Wilds" that seem to work surprisingly well. The band clearly show with this album that they are not just a typical, simple one-track female fronted symphonic metal band that many people may pass them off for these days.

This is a long album running in at just over seventy-five minutes and so almost inevitably we have some forgetful and morbidly bland tracks, "Eva" being the worst culprit here, I am sure this track must have some deep value in it somewhere but you just can't hear it. It is the slow track of the album that is neither stirring or emotional, nothing special here at all. "Sahara" and "7 Days To The Wolves" also slip way below the radar as well as a couple of other average tracks on the album that unfortunately fail to capture your imagination.

It is difficult to say the least to simultaneously arouse the attention of the two worlds of popular commercial success and the more underground true heavy metal listeners, but this album is one that will please both camps. This still has that Nightwish charm about it, but if you purchase this album hoping it will be just like the others you may be a little let down - not because this is of a lesser quality, but has just adopted a slightly different style which may in fact introduce new fans to the band. "Dark Passion Play" will understandably split the listening audience as most things would after such a change, but this is probably the best album the band could have made given their circumstances and the pressure, and they certainly deserve a thumbs up for the brave effort.





Written on 28.09.2007 by Member of Staff since 2006


Comments page 4 / 4

Comments: 102   Visited by: 463 users
11.04.2010 - 12:42
Rating: 7
Zhao
The Arkaholic
Exellent review, never like nightwish much, but bought the album after I heard The Islander. I can only agree on every point here.
Loading...
12.07.2010 - 01:19
Rating: 10
Nappo
I really like this album, the best alongside Once and Oceanborn.. but I think it is a little more, coz it's more diverse and obviously Poet and the Pendulum is their best song to date, it's a sort of evolution...
I don't agree at all with those who say now Nightwish is poppish or those who dislike Anette voice coz is poppish..... the first are completely deaf, as Nightwish has never been more "complex" and multilayered, at least since their evolution in style.. and I wonder why a metal singer must be a soprano, it's just a question of trend!! I don't see any tenore metal singer, so why female singers must be classical?? Be open minded!! Nihgtwish were between the first metal bands to have a female singer, and now I foresee they will be the first of many metal bands with a rock singer..
anyway Nightwish rulez!!!
Loading...
15.07.2010 - 02:00
ErnilEnNaur
Account deleted
Written by Thor arise on 23.02.2010 at 12:57

A very good album..probably an 8 rate...bur Anette sounds like a pop girl not like a metal chick...that's what i miss A LOT!!

Why is it, that everything non-Tarja is pop to the ears of Nightwish fans?
Loading...
18.07.2010 - 02:51
deikuzutsu
Written by [user id=105293] on 15.07.2010 at 02:00

Written by Thor arise on 23.02.2010 at 12:57

A very good album..probably an 8 rate...bur Anette sounds like a pop girl not like a metal chick...that's what i miss A LOT!!

Why is it, that everything non-Tarja is pop to the ears of Nightwish fans?

Hit the nail on the head there, buddy.
Loading...
18.07.2010 - 02:54
deikuzutsu
Am I the only one who liked all the songs on here?

It's due to me and not being picky when a band grows on me. Nightwish is one of my favorite bands, so it's become hard for them to sound bad to me.
Loading...
15.03.2011 - 10:45
Rating: 7
Milena
gloom cookie
Staff
The review is awesomely written, it's not too harsh on the album, but it's not a fanboy drooling, it's an objective as it can be, and I actually disagree with some of the points stated, so f you fanboys, leave the guy alone because his opinion doesn't match yours.
----
7.0 means the album is good
Loading...
15.03.2011 - 17:04
Troy Killjoy
perfunctionist
Staff
Written by Milena on 15.03.2011 at 10:45

...so f you fanboys, leave the guy alone because his opinion doesn't match yours.

I don't think Baz lost any sleep over these comments.
----
"Wise men talk because they have something to say; fools because they have to say something."
Loading...
16.03.2011 - 09:28
Rating: 7
Milena
gloom cookie
Staff
Written by Troy Killjoy on 15.03.2011 at 17:04

Written by Milena on 15.03.2011 at 10:45

...so f you fanboys, leave the guy alone because his opinion doesn't match yours.

I don't think Baz lost any sleep over these comments.

Well I did, it annoys me whenever I write something (not only on this forum), I usually see a bunch of posts from people who only see one side of the story, or are just plain subjective, or don't know shit about what they're talking about but decide to go on and play smart anyway. So, yeah, the sight of such comments anywhere, in the so-called online 'life' or the real thing, pretty much flips me off. But I'll learn to laugh at them within a couple of years, I'm too young to be indifferent about everything right now
----
7.0 means the album is good
Loading...
01.12.2011 - 17:07
Cuca Beludo
Account deleted
Tarja was awesome, no one can replace her. Nightwish will never be the same again.
Oh well, this album isn't bad at all.
Loading...
02.12.2011 - 17:28
ErnilEnNaur
Account deleted
Oh how I love this album, despite it's many boring songs. Real emotions, awesome heavy riffs, majestic melodies and the crowning achievement in their career - "The Poet And The Pendulum". I must listen to this album repeatedly to recover from "Imaginaerum".
Loading...
02.12.2011 - 17:45
X-Ray Rod
Skandino
Staff
Written by [user id=105293] on 15.07.2010 at 02:00
Why is it, that everything non-Tarja is pop to the ears of Nightwish fans?

I like to think I'm in a pretty neutral ground here as it has been a long time since I heard Nightwish and all but regardless if I like both vocalist or not, Annette sounds definitely more pop (just talking about the vocals here).
----
Written by BloodTears on 19.08.2011 at 18:29
Like you could kiss my ass

Written by Milena on 20.06.2012 at 10:49
Rod, let me love you.

Loading...
11.04.2020 - 21:38
Rating: 8
BlankFile
Tarja left a big hole to be filled, and altough this record doesn´t have the same quality as previous ones, it´ss a pretty decent effort by the band. It has lots of good moments.
Loading...

Hits total: 26761 | This month: 31