corrupt With a lowercase c AdminPosts: 3536 |
18.10.2008 - 21:56Rating: 8
corruptWith a lowercase cAdminPosts: 3536
Damn, I had already finnished my own review of it and was just working the details. You beat me to it
But I agree with almost every word, although my rating would have been around 8.5. I don't appreciate the song patterns though, it doesn't really fit into the album's context.
Anyway, very well written review, I enjoyed reading this. And it even make me reach for the album once again. Absolutely gorgeous.
----
Loading...
|
=maD.Doc:. Melodeath Master
Posts: 386 |
Demonic Tutor, just saw something that I hook up at, Peter Wickers, if it is the Soilwork guitarist you really mean his name is Peter Wichers (with an H not K). Otherwise, great review! Got me somewhat interested, will check this album out when I have the time!
Loading...
|
METAL!
Posts: 63 |
This is an awesome album. I love the emotions Warrel put into his lyrics.
Loading...
|
Marcel Hubregtse Grumpy Old Fuck ElitePosts: 40071 |
I know I am swimming against the stream here but this was a very disappointing uninspired bland album. Warrel is capable of so much better stuff than what he delivers here. Songwriting is subpar here as well as his vocal delivery. A crying shame. Totally doesn't live up to the hype.
Now if you don't mind I'll get back to the Sanctuary and Nevermore albums instead.
----
Member of the true crusade against European Flower Metal
Yesterday is dead and gone, tomorrow is out of sight
Dawn Crosby (r.i.p.)
05.04.1963 - 15.12.1996
Loading...
|
corrupt With a lowercase c AdminPosts: 3536 |
19.10.2008 - 00:26Rating: 8
corruptWith a lowercase cAdminPosts: 3536
Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 19.10.2008 at 00:20
I know I am swimming against the stream here but this was a very disappointing uninspired bland album. Warrel is capable of so much better stuff than what he delivers here. Songwriting is subpar here as well as his vocal delivery. A crying shame. Totally doesn't live up to the hype.
Now if you don't mind I'll get back to the Sanctuary and Nevermore albums instead.
Boy, you do have a thing with poor Warrel these days. Don't like his album, don't like the Nevermore DVD...
But I can understand what you mean. I was disappointed too at first. But once the image of a Warrel outside the context of Nevermore and Sanctuary settles, it gets to show what it truly is. Give it another try in a few weeks, and mind that he really wanted to do a gothic influenced, soft album. Comparison to his other work doens't do it justice.
----
Loading...
|
HardSide
Posts: 381
|
19.10.2008 - 00:27Rating: 7
Not a fan of nevermore by any means, I think its a crappy band, with that said, this album was a suprise to me, its good, not as great as for me to give a 9, but definately 7-8, and with this album ill try and give nevermore another shot.
Loading...
|
corrupt With a lowercase c AdminPosts: 3536 |
19.10.2008 - 00:29Rating: 8
corruptWith a lowercase cAdminPosts: 3536
Try their first albums then, they are much more emotional than their current work.
----
Loading...
|
Marcel Hubregtse Grumpy Old Fuck ElitePosts: 40071 |
Written by corrupt on 19.10.2008 at 00:26
Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 19.10.2008 at 00:20
I know I am swimming against the stream here but this was a very disappointing uninspired bland album. Warrel is capable of so much better stuff than what he delivers here. Songwriting is subpar here as well as his vocal delivery. A crying shame. Totally doesn't live up to the hype.
Now if you don't mind I'll get back to the Sanctuary and Nevermore albums instead.
Boy, you do have a thing with poor Warrel these days. Don't like his album, don't like the Nevermore DVD...
But I can understand what you mean. I was disappointed too at first. But once the image of a Warrel outside the context of Nevermore and Sanctuary settles, it gets to show what it truly is. Give it another try in a few weeks, and mind that he really wanted to do a gothic influenced, soft album. Comparison to his other work doens't do it justice.
I have given it a gazzilion tries, cause I truly like his voice. But he is not suited for what he's trying to do here. I didn't want to compare it to his other works, but because this is so subpar you automatically (or at least I automatically) start comparing it to stuff he did well.
----
Member of the true crusade against European Flower Metal
Yesterday is dead and gone, tomorrow is out of sight
Dawn Crosby (r.i.p.)
05.04.1963 - 15.12.1996
Loading...
|
corrupt With a lowercase c AdminPosts: 3536 |
19.10.2008 - 00:34Rating: 8
corruptWith a lowercase cAdminPosts: 3536
Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 19.10.2008 at 00:30
I have given it a gazzilion tries, cause I truly like his voice. But he is not suited for what he's trying to do here. I didn't want to compare it to his other works, but because this is so subpar you automatically (or at least I automatically) start comparing it to stuff he did well.
I hate, when people disagree with me
Maybe it's just not for you then. But don't come crawling back whining when you finally find your way into it
----
Loading...
|
Marcel Hubregtse Grumpy Old Fuck ElitePosts: 40071 |
Written by corrupt on 19.10.2008 at 00:34
Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 19.10.2008 at 00:30
I have given it a gazzilion tries, cause I truly like his voice. But he is not suited for what he's trying to do here. I didn't want to compare it to his other works, but because this is so subpar you automatically (or at least I automatically) start comparing it to stuff he did well.
I hate, when people disagree with me
Maybe it's just not for you then. But don't come crawling back whining when you finally find your way into it
I doubt I will ever find my way into it since I have truly listened to it at least 50 times.
----
Member of the true crusade against European Flower Metal
Yesterday is dead and gone, tomorrow is out of sight
Dawn Crosby (r.i.p.)
05.04.1963 - 15.12.1996
Loading...
|
Dream Taster The Enemy Within StaffPosts: 1337 |
19.10.2008 - 05:29Rating: 10
Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 19.10.2008 at 00:36
Written by corrupt on 19.10.2008 at 00:34
Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 19.10.2008 at 00:30
I have given it a gazzilion tries, cause I truly like his voice. But he is not suited for what he's trying to do here. I didn't want to compare it to his other works, but because this is so subpar you automatically (or at least I automatically) start comparing it to stuff he did well.
I hate, when people disagree with me
Maybe it's just not for you then. But don't come crawling back whining when you finally find your way into it
I doubt I will ever find my way into it since I have truly listened to it at least 50 times.
Marcel, you are even more messed up than I thought then. Your loss.
Loading...
|
Southern Wind Account deleted |
Southern Wind Account deleted
Great album. I had never dedicated much time to Nevermore, so I won't make the obvious comparisons, but I enjoyed Warrel Dane A LOT.
Loading...
|
Carrion Misery
Posts: 424 |
Written by HardSide on 19.10.2008 at 00:27
Not a fan of nevermore by any means, I think its a crappy band, with that said, this album was a suprise to me, its good, not as great as for me to give a 9, but definately 7-8, and with this album ill try and give nevermore another shot.
Well, Nevermore is a very sophisticated band (musically and lyrically), so its very easy for one who doesn't listen to well constructed music to say they are a crappy band. Its an acquired taste I suppose.
Nevermore aside, I did enjoy Praises to the War Machine and I felt it was a great feat for Warrel Dane. It isn't going to be for someone who is bound to the rageful, aggression emotions, or only wants crazy breakdowns and bust your face open riffs. It is a great piece to appreciate if you're into studying music, vocals and lyrics rather than one trying to be tough with it in their car. Nothing wrong with feeling tough in your car listening to metal at all, but there's no need to criticise great music someone put their heart into. Thats how it goes though. Good review.
----
? Carrion Misery
[url]www.mournspire.com[/url] | Two-Man Death Doom Project
Full album streaming
Loading...
|
TOUGHEST MEMBER
Posts: 3618 |
More rock than goth except track 4, Lucretia My Reflection, his voice clearly is not so much goth. I can enjoy the music but because it has progressive and power element influence.
Loading...
|
ponderer
Posts: 153 |
There shouldn't be any obvious comparisons to make if your brain functions normally. This isn't Nevermore, it was never intended to be Nevermore. Solo projects are a reflection of what the person is feeling, and their work outside of the main band. I'm glad this doesn't sound like Nevermore, and I'm pleased to see Warrel doing his own thing. This is an epic offering. 10.
Loading...
|
Dark Blood The Avenger
Posts: 1435 |
19.10.2008 - 17:40Rating: 8
Warrel is a great musician. He already proved it in the past, but now it's time for his own project and I think it couldn't have been more perfect than this for the first album. Very good review Olivier, I must agree with it in almost every point (including the rating). Thanks man.
----
It is humanity who must pay homage to the greatness of the Universe... not the Universe to the human narcissism.
Loading...
|
sevendeadlysins Account deleted |
sevendeadlysins Account deleted
I think that it's just bad album.
I was expecting more.
Loading...
|
misanthroman Account deleted |
misanthroman Account deleted
This album is clearly a nine+,How can anyone consider themselves a metal fan and not at least like some of this stuff or Nevermore,time to get those ears flushed out and when you brush your toung make sure you brush that food residue off,good reveiw!!!
Loading...
|
Landry
Posts: 8 |
28.10.2008 - 20:31Rating: 10
This album is really awesome! I love the songs August - it's so beautiful - and Your Chosen Misery - even though it's slow, it's filled with emotion. Lucretia My Reflection was a surprise but a good one. The vocals on it is different to what he usually does but it's still part of his brilliance!
Loading...
|
Arcesse Eum
Posts: 268 |
Needs moar Nevermoar - No more solo projects please!
----
As above, so below.
Loading...
|
Justice
Posts: 109 |
31.12.2009 - 15:45Rating: 10
For me this is the best solo project that i've seen till now
Loading...
|
Throne
Posts: 17 |
My personal oppinion, which I am entitled to, is that Dane sounds way better on here than any Nevermore album. And trust me, I have every Nevermore album, and to me it is a frusterating band, I think that he can be overwhelmingly bland sometimes, and then others way too over the top. I don't doubt that he has an amazing voice, I know he has an insane range, but for me, he tries to be all evil sounding in Nevermore, and fails. I know a lot of you love Nevermore, but to me, his note choice is way better on this album.
Loading...
|
Night Sight
Posts: 260 |
I dont like this album
warrel dane voice is better in nevermore
it is very bad
----
Alone in birth
Alone in the darkness
Alone in death
Alone in the daylight
Loading...
|
DarkWingedSoul
Posts: 1380 |
Heh, reading all the comments i think this album should have a warning note sticker to it saying if u like nevermore or sanctuary u need to forget about that first and than listen to the album
Loading...
|