Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 23.07.2010 at 03:33

Written by whatsacow on 23.07.2010 at 03:20

Thergothon, Skepticism and finntroll are missing...

And Unholy and Tyranny and Pofetus and and and and

And shape of despair and... ... ... ... ... ... there are just way too many to list.

Written by whatsacow on 23.07.2010 at 03:35

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 23.07.2010 at 03:33

Written by whatsacow on 23.07.2010 at 03:20

Thergothon, Skepticism and finntroll are missing...

And Unholy and Tyranny and Pofetus and and and and

And shape of despair and... ... ... ... ... ... there are just way too many to list.

Exactly

The list here is just mainstream metal. No black metal bands are on it either. Damn, no Clandestine Blaze,a lso no funeral doom master Stabat Mater etc etc

As expected, a battle between CoB and NW (if you exclude the almighty Other),

Insomnium, Swallow the Sun, Kalmah, Mors Principium Est, Rapture. There's just so many OTHERS...

Where is Thergoton? :'(

Kalmah is my favorite band. I really like their music and IMO they are one of the best Melodeath bands in the world.

I suggest reneming the thread to "the best shit band from Finland", because some of the bands in the poll are just that - shit. EToS, Nightwish, CoB - they should have no place in a "best of " poll about Finland, or any poll for that matter. Most of the time they play pop that's somehow metallized, not real metal. The only good bands on that list are Moonsorrow, Sentenced (old) and Amorphis (old).
Otheris my choice then, and even then I'd be torn between Skepticism and Shape of Despair. And that's doom only. There are also lots of great black metal bands, Satanic Warmaster springs to mind immediately.

Written by Daniell on 17.09.2010 at 14:51

I suggest reneming the thread to "the best shit band from Finland", because some of the bands in the poll are just that - shit. EToS, Nightwish, CoB - they should have no place in a "best of " poll about Finland, or any poll for that matter. Most of the time they play pop that's somehow metallized, not real metal. The only good bands on that list are Moonsorrow, Sentenced (old) and Amorphis (old).
Otheris my choice then, and even then I'd be torn between Skepticism and Shape of Despair. And that's doom only. There are also lots of great black metal bands, Satanic Warmaster springs to mind immediately.

Sounds like elitism to me. Or whinging. Probably both.

Now that was some epic hypocrisy from a guy who hates elitism.

I dismissed 3 bands as shit, and mentioned 6 as good. Among those 6 good ones 3 are very well known, some even mainstream (Sentenced and Amorphis). Where's elitism here?

EDIT:
Hey Vezzydude, I at least listened to the crap I call crap...

Written by Daniell on 17.09.2010 at 17:32

Hey Vezzydude, I at least listened to the crap I call crap...

So did I.

I love Turisas and Ensiferum from Finland , because of it i voted other

Its funny i used to really love the finnish metal scene. There are some amazing bands out of Finland, but also a lot of rubbish too. But i suppose thats the same everywhere any you can blame people for having a go. Finland has been a birth place of some outstanding metal my vote in this instance is pretty tough to place because none of my real favorites come from there. Basically all of the acts mentioned here are good bands. I voted other, because I thought Turisas are a band that could be a great band in the next few years

Written by ToMegaTherion on 19.09.2010 at 15:38

Its funny i used to really love the finnish metal scene. There are some amazing bands out of Finland, but also a lot of rubbish too. But i suppose thats the same everywhere any you can blame people for having a go. Finland has been a birth place of some outstanding metal my vote in this instance is pretty tough to place because none of my real favorites come from there. Basically all of the acts mentioned here are good bands. I voted other, because I thought Turisas are a band that could be a great band in the next few years

interesting post, but if you give us examples what is outstanding bands and what is rubish from Fin

Nightwish. Holopainen is the best melody maker out there, even if he does only bother with half the songs on every album. If I had to choose the greatest metal song ever written, it would be The Poet and the Pendulum, nothing else even comes close. It is worth more to me than some other band's entire discography.

Hey why ensiferum and turisas and wintersun r not here! shit!!! they're just what I would to vote

Voted Nightwish because they were first Fin band I ever heard and I still love all their Tarja era material. Otherwise, Wintersun or Swallow the Sun would've gotten it.

I didnt remember for which band i voted in the past (i suspect Nightwish ) but nowadays it would be Moonsorrow by a thousand miles

Written by Daniell on 17.09.2010 at 14:51

I suggest reneming the thread to "the best shit band from Finland", because some of the bands in the poll are just that - shit. EToS, Nightwish, CoB - they should have no place in a "best of " poll about Finland, or any poll for that matter. Most of the time they play pop that's somehow metallized, not real metal.

Surprised that bands under big labels release catchy singles? Were you born the day after tomorrow?

I'm not surprised, I'm merely stating facts.

Written by Daniell on 24.09.2010 at 23:06

I'm not surprised, I'm merely stating facts.

The only fact is, that you can't tell the difference between pop and metal. And apparently you think the word "pop" is an insult. Moron.

And have Cradle Of Filth among favorite bands...

Written by Ellrohir on 24.09.2010 at 23:40

And have Cradle Of Filth among favorite bands...

Not to mention Opeth.

You say Opeth is a "pop" band?

Written by [user id=105293] on 25.09.2010 at 00:03

Written by Ellrohir on 24.09.2010 at 23:40

And have Cradle Of Filth among favorite bands...

Not to mention Opeth.

Opeth is swedish , I think 99.999999999% people knows it

I think the only band from Finland I'm listening to is Catamenia (until Location:Cold).

And most of the bands on the list are mainstream and barely metal, indeed, from my point of view.

Written by Daniell on 17.09.2010 at 14:51

I suggest reneming the thread to "the best shit band from Finland", because some of the bands in the poll are just that - shit. EToS, Nightwish, CoB - they should have no place in a "best of " poll about Finland, or any poll for that matter. Most of the time they play pop that's somehow metallized, not real metal. The only good bands on that list are Moonsorrow, Sentenced (old) and Amorphis (old).
Otheris my choice then, and even then I'd be torn between Skepticism and Shape of Despair. And that's doom only. There are also lots of great black metal bands, Satanic Warmaster springs to mind immediately.

See, we are all elitists in our own way. We all dismiss things as crap and label some things as pop.
The only difference is some of us are more purists, so there is more stuff we dislike and we have different visions of what is metal and what is not, so some things that are considered as metal for one person can be considered as pop by someone else.

Written by Bad English on 25.09.2010 at 02:15

Written by [user id=105293] on 25.09.2010 at 00:03

Written by Ellrohir on 24.09.2010 at 23:40

And have Cradle Of Filth among favorite bands...

Not to mention Opeth.

Opeth is swedish , I think 99.999999999% people knows it

and?

Written by Bad English on 25.09.2010 at 02:15

Opeth is swedish , I think 99.999999999% people knows it

That's why I said NOT TO MENTION OPETH.

Written by RavenKing on 25.09.2010 at 03:39

I think the only band from Finland I'm listening to is Catamenia (until Location:Cold).

And most of the bands on the list are mainstream and barely metal, indeed, from my point of view.

Mainstream metal is still metal. Genres have nothing to do with popularity and everything to do with music. If Cannibal Corpse sold a hundred times more that wouldn't make them pop. Because pop is in fact a genre of it's own with (great) bands such as R.E.M., The Cure, Poets of the Fall etc.