Written by [user id=31891] on 27.06.2008 at 17:58

Written by Hamird on 27.06.2008 at 17:50

Written by Dane Train on 27.06.2008 at 17:42

Written by [user id=31891] on 27.06.2008 at 17:41

if someone asks me: "do u like kirk?" i will answer not. cause i dont like his acts. but no one can close his eyes to his guitar skills. so funny when u compare kirk to mustain.

Ah...what?

Exactly, Dave Mustaine must be compared with someone like Chuck Schuldiner from Death and Hammet must be compared with someone like Munkey from Korn
Guitar skills??? don't you ever heard a name of Jack Owen or Ralph Santolla????

omg jack owen is wearin so unmetal lol with his red fuckin guitar and glasses pffff (kiddin) and he is bald yeah ARGH lol

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 27.06.2008 at 23:12

Although I am a huge fan of Metallica's first three ( and having seen Metallica live 25 times between 1983 and 1992) I never really liked Kirk's playing AT ALL. And I was even GLAD there weren't any solos on St. Anger so then he couldn't fuck them up. Kirk's biggest problem IMO is that he can't keep his foot of those horrible wah-wah pedals.

PLease give my Dave Mustaine's guitar skills over Kirk's any time of the day. IMO even James is a better guitar player than Kirk.

Written by Hamird on 28.06.2008 at 10:39

Oh, I'm sure you joking!!! Do you mean that you believe in such lists??? Come on! Is these lists includes most of powerful Death metal, Doom metal, and other genres of metal? you are talking in Metalstorm! The Only thing that is right in these list that Jimi Hendrix and Eric Clapton are in the first place and 2econd place! And know that personally I just read polls of Rolling Stones and not any other lists! and funny this time in Rolling Stones sucked at sorting list, because it's list had no Slash, Chuck Schuldiner, Rikardo Amorim and Joe Satriani (Kirk's teacher) and then Kurt Cobain is number 12... and also Ed O'brine and Greenwood of Radiohead are in the list and still no Master Jack Owen! Can you believe that??? Kurt Cobain is my idol, my favorite Rockstar of all time, but he has not such a talent to be number 12 at the list!! Give your own reason, these polls are not reliable, just like YAHOO!'s

Written by [user id=31891] on 28.06.2008 at 10:55

if u mean that u just believe in urself its somthin else that we can argu about it! but look man, some of those lists r about rock not metal and some r about all guitarists. the other thing is that its not just 1 list. i think ive put some lists there. and as i know its not a man's opinion its somthin like Consulation. so i think its better to believe it not to cry and about joe satriani, as i remember he was lower than kirk in any lists. think u will remind it.

Written by K✞ulu on 28.06.2008 at 12:07

I was actually waiting for Marcel posting here, but didn't expect he would say James was a better guitar player than Kirk. I mean James probably can't play all those fast solos that Kirk play or can he? It makes sense why he doesn't, but still... i am wondering whether he could play some of them or not.

overall I can't say I find Kirk's solos boring, but I do see some pattern in his leads.

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 28.06.2008 at 13:01

Written by K✞ulu on 28.06.2008 at 12:07

I was actually waiting for Marcel posting here, but didn't expect he would say James was a better guitar player than Kirk. I mean James probably can't play all those fast solos that Kirk play or can he? It makes sense why he doesn't, but still... i am wondering whether he could play some of them or not.

overall I can't say I find Kirk's solos boring, but I do see some pattern in his leads.

James can play those solos but doesn't cause he is also the vocalist. Btw a lot of Metallica's solos were written by James. Why I mentioned James here is because IMO he is one of the most underrated guitarists around.

Coming back to the lists God posted... those lists don't mean a thing usually cause all they look at is very well known bands and guitarists. How else could it be possible that Cobain is mentioned there and not Satriani who is both an extremely talented great guitar player and guitar teacher as well (taught Steve Vai, Kirk Hammett, Larry Lalonde (Primus, ex-Possessed)

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 28.06.2008 at 13:01

Written by K✞ulu on 28.06.2008 at 12:07

I was actually waiting for Marcel posting here, but didn't expect he would say James was a better guitar player than Kirk. I mean James probably can't play all those fast solos that Kirk play or can he? It makes sense why he doesn't, but still... i am wondering whether he could play some of them or not.

overall I can't say I find Kirk's solos boring, but I do see some pattern in his leads.

James can play those solos but doesn't cause he is also the vocalist. Btw a lot of Metallica's solos were written by James. Why I mentioned James here is because IMO he is one of the most underrated guitarists around.

Coming back to the lists God posted... those lists don't mean a thing usually cause all they look at is very well known bands and guitarists. How else could it be possible that Cobain is mentioned there and not Satriani who is both an extremely talented great guitar player and guitar teacher as well (taught Steve Vai, Kirk Hammett, Larry Lalonde (Primus, ex-Possessed)

Written by K✞ulu on 28.06.2008 at 13:19

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 28.06.2008 at 13:01

Written by K✞ulu on 28.06.2008 at 12:07

I was actually waiting for Marcel posting here, but didn't expect he would say James was a better guitar player than Kirk. I mean James probably can't play all those fast solos that Kirk play or can he? It makes sense why he doesn't, but still... i am wondering whether he could play some of them or not.

overall I can't say I find Kirk's solos boring, but I do see some pattern in his leads.

James can play those solos but doesn't cause he is also the vocalist. Btw a lot of Metallica's solos were written by James. Why I mentioned James here is because IMO he is one of the most underrated guitarists around.

Coming back to the lists God posted... those lists don't mean a thing usually cause all they look at is very well known bands and guitarists. How else could it be possible that Cobain is mentioned there and not Satriani who is both an extremely talented great guitar player and guitar teacher as well (taught Steve Vai, Kirk Hammett, Larry Lalonde (Primus, ex-Possessed)

yeah. i got it. I also think he doesn't play them because he sings. They probably agreed to have it that way. But Dave actually both sings and plays the solos.

I don't know about the objectivity of the charts, but some of them are just based on user voting. I actually wish there was a poll between the best guitarists of the world to decide who it the best between them.

Written by [user id=31891] on 28.06.2008 at 15:14

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 28.06.2008 at 13:01

Written by K✞ulu on 28.06.2008 at 12:07

I was actually waiting for Marcel posting here, but didn't expect he would say James was a better guitar player than Kirk. I mean James probably can't play all those fast solos that Kirk play or can he? It makes sense why he doesn't, but still... i am wondering whether he could play some of them or not.

overall I can't say I find Kirk's solos boring, but I do see some pattern in his leads.

James can play those solos but doesn't cause he is also the vocalist. Btw a lot of Metallica's solos were written by James. Why I mentioned James here is because IMO he is one of the most underrated guitarists around.

Coming back to the lists God posted... those lists don't mean a thing usually cause all they look at is very well known bands and guitarists. How else could it be possible that Cobain is mentioned there and not Satriani who is both an extremely talented great guitar player and guitar teacher as well (taught Steve Vai, Kirk Hammett, Larry Lalonde (Primus, ex-Possessed)

Marcel do u think that Kirk gave money to all who chose him in all that magazines and sites? but dave didn ? or satriani? and about satriani i can say that he has just on or two songs that they r masterpiece. a lot of works doesnt mean Quality does?
do we have to believe somthin more than ourselves or not? everyone here was tryin to say that "IMO", but i took here lists, and those list has choosed by a lot of groups and "Guitar Experts" not by friends or enemis of kirk and dave or any others.

Written by Hamird on 28.06.2008 at 15:37

Written by [user id=31891] on 28.06.2008 at 15:14

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 28.06.2008 at 13:01

Written by K✞ulu on 28.06.2008 at 12:07

I was actually waiting for Marcel posting here, but didn't expect he would say James was a better guitar player than Kirk. I mean James probably can't play all those fast solos that Kirk play or can he? It makes sense why he doesn't, but still... i am wondering whether he could play some of them or not.

overall I can't say I find Kirk's solos boring, but I do see some pattern in his leads.

James can play those solos but doesn't cause he is also the vocalist. Btw a lot of Metallica's solos were written by James. Why I mentioned James here is because IMO he is one of the most underrated guitarists around.

Coming back to the lists God posted... those lists don't mean a thing usually cause all they look at is very well known bands and guitarists. How else could it be possible that Cobain is mentioned there and not Satriani who is both an extremely talented great guitar player and guitar teacher as well (taught Steve Vai, Kirk Hammett, Larry Lalonde (Primus, ex-Possessed)

Marcel do u think that Kirk gave money to all who chose him in all that magazines and sites? but dave didn ? or satriani? and about satriani i can say that he has just on or two songs that they r masterpiece. a lot of works doesnt mean Quality does?
do we have to believe somthin more than ourselves or not? everyone here was tryin to say that "IMO", but i took here lists, and those list has choosed by a lot of groups and "Guitar Experts" not by friends or enemis of kirk and dave or any others.

Satriani just has two songs which are masterpiece. ...so in your way St. Anger is all masterpiece!!!!??? I bet, you are joking!
And as I said, your lists suck but Rolling Stones, (which sucks on this); Mercel and others got the point, but still you don't!
In your word can be felt that you don't care about our opinions, so you can go and discuss with those Experts!!

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 28.06.2008 at 15:39

Talking about experts. I would dare to say I am more of an expert concerning metal guitarists than any single person writing for Rolling Stone magazine

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 28.06.2008 at 15:39

Written by Hamird on 28.06.2008 at 15:37

Written by [user id=31891] on 28.06.2008 at 15:14

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 28.06.2008 at 13:01

Written by K✞ulu on 28.06.2008 at 12:07

I was actually waiting for Marcel posting here, but didn't expect he would say James was a better guitar player than Kirk. I mean James probably can't play all those fast solos that Kirk play or can he? It makes sense why he doesn't, but still... i am wondering whether he could play some of them or not.

overall I can't say I find Kirk's solos boring, but I do see some pattern in his leads.

James can play those solos but doesn't cause he is also the vocalist. Btw a lot of Metallica's solos were written by James. Why I mentioned James here is because IMO he is one of the most underrated guitarists around.

Coming back to the lists God posted... those lists don't mean a thing usually cause all they look at is very well known bands and guitarists. How else could it be possible that Cobain is mentioned there and not Satriani who is both an extremely talented great guitar player and guitar teacher as well (taught Steve Vai, Kirk Hammett, Larry Lalonde (Primus, ex-Possessed)

Marcel do u think that Kirk gave money to all who chose him in all that magazines and sites? but dave didn ? or satriani? and about satriani i can say that he has just on or two songs that they r masterpiece. a lot of works doesnt mean Quality does?
do we have to believe somthin more than ourselves or not? everyone here was tryin to say that "IMO", but i took here lists, and those list has choosed by a lot of groups and "Guitar Experts" not by friends or enemis of kirk and dave or any others.

Satriani just has two songs which are masterpiece. ...so in your way St. Anger is all masterpiece!!!!??? I bet, you are joking!
And as I said, your lists suck but Rolling Stones, (which sucks on this); Mercel and others got the point, but still you don't!
In your word can be felt that you don't care about our opinions, so you can go and discuss with those Experts!!

Talking about experts. I would dare to say I am more of an expert concerning metal guitarists than any single person writing for Rolling Stone magazine

Written by Hamird on 28.06.2008 at 15:37

Written by [user id=31891] on 28.06.2008 at 15:14

Marcel do u think that Kirk gave money to all who chose him in all that magazines and sites? but dave didn ? or satriani? and about satriani i can say that he has just on or two songs that they r masterpiece. a lot of works doesnt mean Quality does?
do we have to believe somthin more than ourselves or not? everyone here was tryin to say that "IMO", but i took here lists, and those list has choosed by a lot of groups and "Guitar Experts" not by friends or enemis of kirk and dave or any others.

Satriani just has two songs which are masterpiece. ...so in your way St. Anger is all masterpiece!!!!??? I bet, you are joking!
And as I said, your lists suck but Rolling Stones, (which sucks on this); Mercel and others got the point, but still you don't!
In your word can be felt that you don't care about our opinions, so you can go and discuss with those Experts!!

Written by [user id=31891] on 28.06.2008 at 18:24

do u know what i meant by Masterpiece ? evey guitarist can have just 2 or 3 masterpiece solo's i think!! as kirk too. but satriani has his own band, and he have a lot of solos, so he has too have more masterpiece's than kirk for sure. but IMO he hasnt cause i can number just 2 or 3 songs of him as a masterpiece(masterpiece is different from good or very good). thats all. but i like those 2 songs as hell. forgotten part 1 and 2. and flying in a blue dream ) i love them

Written by Hamird on 28.06.2008 at 18:42

Written by [user id=31891] on 28.06.2008 at 18:24

do u know what i meant by Masterpiece ? evey guitarist can have just 2 or 3 masterpiece solo's i think!! as kirk too. but satriani has his own band, and he have a lot of solos, so he has too have more masterpiece's than kirk for sure. but IMO he hasnt cause i can number just 2 or 3 songs of him as a masterpiece(masterpiece is different from good or very good). thats all. but i like those 2 songs as hell. forgotten part 1 and 2. and flying in a blue dream ) i love them

My problem is that you say Hammet is better than Satriani, with accepting these lists!

Written by [user id=31891] on 28.06.2008 at 18:48

Written by Hamird on 28.06.2008 at 18:42

Written by [user id=31891] on 28.06.2008 at 18:24

do u know what i meant by Masterpiece ? evey guitarist can have just 2 or 3 masterpiece solo's i think!! as kirk too. but satriani has his own band, and he have a lot of solos, so he has too have more masterpiece's than kirk for sure. but IMO he hasnt cause i can number just 2 or 3 songs of him as a masterpiece(masterpiece is different from good or very good). thats all. but i like those 2 songs as hell. forgotten part 1 and 2. and flying in a blue dream ) i love them

My problem is that you say Hammet is better than Satriani, with accepting these lists!

have u ever seen satriani above hammet in any list?

Written by [user id=32012] on 29.06.2008 at 02:09

Oh yeah those lists are bullshit, is just who is more popular and famous bajjjj who cares.... is good to know that James wrote many of the solos for Metallica. And I do think Metallica has nice melodic solos (continuing with the topic's poster idea), but Dave Mustaine for me is a step ahead, may be more.

Did James also wrote the solos for Kill em all and other songs where Mustaine was still part of Metallica???

Written by Hamird on 28.06.2008 at 19:51

Written by [user id=31891] on 28.06.2008 at 18:48

Written by Hamird on 28.06.2008 at 18:42

Written by [user id=31891] on 28.06.2008 at 18:24

do u know what i meant by Masterpiece ? evey guitarist can have just 2 or 3 masterpiece solo's i think!! as kirk too. but satriani has his own band, and he have a lot of solos, so he has too have more masterpiece's than kirk for sure. but IMO he hasnt cause i can number just 2 or 3 songs of him as a masterpiece(masterpiece is different from good or very good). thats all. but i like those 2 songs as hell. forgotten part 1 and 2. and flying in a blue dream ) i love them

My problem is that you say Hammet is better than Satriani, with accepting these lists!

have u ever seen satriani above hammet in any list?

Oh Goddd.. I say I don't care about these lists then you say "have you ever seen Satriani above Hammet in any lists"????? I don't believe in these lists exactly because Hammet is above Satriani and many other guitarists who are better than him!

Written by BloodTears on 28.06.2008 at 21:02

Whats wrong with Satriani? I love him. And I don't know if you actually know but Satriani was Hammet's teacher.

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 27.06.2008 at 23:12

Kirk's biggest problem IMO is that he can't keep his foot of those horrible wah-wah pedals.

Written by K✞ulu on 29.06.2008 at 16:16

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 27.06.2008 at 23:12

Kirk's biggest problem IMO is that he can't keep his foot of those horrible wah-wah pedals.

Can you give any song examples 'cause you know what, that's interesting to know.

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 29.06.2008 at 16:17

Written by K✞ulu on 29.06.2008 at 16:16

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 27.06.2008 at 23:12

Kirk's biggest problem IMO is that he can't keep his foot of those horrible wah-wah pedals.

Can you give any song examples 'cause you know what, that's interesting to know.

He uses that wah-wah pedal in almost every single song. I know it is personal, but if there is one effect for the guitar I can't stand it is the wah-wah pedal.