Doc G. Full Grown Hoser StaffPosts: 9718 |
13.12.2006 - 08:45Rating: 7
Doc G.Full Grown HoserStaffPosts: 9718
ok, the review makes its seem flawless, then you give it a 7? wtf? this album deserves at least an 8. This is Overkills best work imo. Your forgetting the amazing track 'damned'. So if you give this album such a low rating I wish you would elaborate on that. Otherwise your review is useless.
----
"I got a lot of really good ideas, problem is, most of them suck."
- George Carlin
Loading...
|
Marcel Hubregtse Grumpy Old Fuck ElitePosts: 40071 |
Written by Doc G. on 13.12.2006 at 08:45
ok, the review makes its seem flawless, then you give it a 7? wtf? this album deserves at least an 8. This is Overkills best work imo. Your forgetting the amazing track 'damned'. So if you give this album such a low rating I wish you would elaborate on that. Otherwise your review is useless.
7 is NOT a low rrating, it means it is above average but nothing special as everything has been heard and done before. everything under a 6 is low because that would mean below average.
And come on people Overkill is musically quite an average and at times a little above average band. They have a couple of memorable killer songs, but those are all off their first three albums. I never understood why Overkill are lauded so much nowadays, back when they started they were seen as second-tier thrash, and rightly so IMO.
----
Member of the true crusade against European Flower Metal
Yesterday is dead and gone, tomorrow is out of sight
Dawn Crosby (r.i.p.)
05.04.1963 - 15.12.1996
Loading...
|
Samuel550 Account deleted |
Samuel550 Account deleted
Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 13.12.2006 at 15:24 And come on people Overkill is musically quite an average and at times a little above average band. They have a couple of memorable killer songs, but those are all off their first three albums. I never understood why Overkill are lauded so much nowadays, back when they started they were seen as second-tier thrash, and rightly so IMO.
Come on man, at this point Overkill have more right being a thrash band then Faketallica...erm I mean Metallica. The fact that most of they're music isn't very original is highly irrelevant and can easily apply to the musical logic of bands like Iron Maiden: more of the same=good. So why should Overkill have to change for anyone?
New big 4 of Thash Metal: Overkill, Slayer, Megadeth and Lamb of God(Slayer and Megadeth retain they're positions for obviouse reasons).
Loading...
|
Doc G. Full Grown Hoser StaffPosts: 9718 |
23.07.2008 - 19:32Rating: 7
Doc G.Full Grown HoserStaffPosts: 9718
Written by [user id=26806] on 23.07.2008 at 15:41
Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 13.12.2006 at 15:24 And come on people Overkill is musically quite an average and at times a little above average band. They have a couple of memorable killer songs, but those are all off their first three albums. I never understood why Overkill are lauded so much nowadays, back when they started they were seen as second-tier thrash, and rightly so IMO.
Come on man, at this point Overkill have more right being a thrash band then Faketallica...erm I mean Metallica. The fact that most of they're music isn't very original is highly irrelevant and can easily apply to the musical logic of bands like Iron Maiden: more of the same=good. So why should Overkill have to change for anyone?
New big 4 of Thash Metal: Overkill, Slayer, Megadeth and Lamb of God(Slayer and Megadeth retain they're positions for obviouse reasons).
What criteria are you basing this "new big 4 of thrash" off of?
----
"I got a lot of really good ideas, problem is, most of them suck."
- George Carlin
Loading...
|
Samuel550 Account deleted |
Samuel550 Account deleted
Written by Doc G. on 23.07.2008 at 19:32
Written by [user id=26806] on 23.07.2008 at 15:41
Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 13.12.2006 at 15:24 And come on people Overkill is musically quite an average and at times a little above average band. They have a couple of memorable killer songs, but those are all off their first three albums. I never understood why Overkill are lauded so much nowadays, back when they started they were seen as second-tier thrash, and rightly so IMO.
Come on man, at this point Overkill have more right being a thrash band then Faketallica...erm I mean Metallica. The fact that most of they're music isn't very original is highly irrelevant and can easily apply to the musical logic of bands like Iron Maiden: more of the same=good. So why should Overkill have to change for anyone?
New big 4 of Thash Metal: Overkill, Slayer, Megadeth and Lamb of God(Slayer and Megadeth retain they're positions for obviouse reasons).
What criteria are you basing this "new big 4 of thrash" off of?
The sorry state of todays metal and music in general.
Loading...
|
Doc G. Full Grown Hoser StaffPosts: 9718 |
23.07.2008 - 22:42Rating: 7
Doc G.Full Grown HoserStaffPosts: 9718
Written by [user id=26806] on 23.07.2008 at 22:05
Written by Doc G. on 23.07.2008 at 19:32
Written by [user id=26806] on 23.07.2008 at 15:41
Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 13.12.2006 at 15:24 And come on people Overkill is musically quite an average and at times a little above average band. They have a couple of memorable killer songs, but those are all off their first three albums. I never understood why Overkill are lauded so much nowadays, back when they started they were seen as second-tier thrash, and rightly so IMO.
Come on man, at this point Overkill have more right being a thrash band then Faketallica...erm I mean Metallica. The fact that most of they're music isn't very original is highly irrelevant and can easily apply to the musical logic of bands like Iron Maiden: more of the same=good. So why should Overkill have to change for anyone?
New big 4 of Thash Metal: Overkill, Slayer, Megadeth and Lamb of God(Slayer and Megadeth retain they're positions for obviouse reasons).
What criteria are you basing this "new big 4 of thrash" off of?
The sorry state of todays metal and music in general.
Yeah, it has to be a pretty sorry state if Lamb Of God is considered 1 of the big 4. But on a serious note, I have to disagree completely, I think music is more alive than it ever was, theres more bands coming out now than there ever was, unfortunately that means more shit bands, but at the same time it still means theres more and more great bands than ever.
----
"I got a lot of really good ideas, problem is, most of them suck."
- George Carlin
Loading...
|
Samuel550 Account deleted |
Samuel550 Account deleted
Written by Doc G. on 23.07.2008 at 22:42
Written by [user id=26806] on 23.07.2008 at 22:05
Written by Doc G. on 23.07.2008 at 19:32
Written by [user id=26806] on 23.07.2008 at 15:41
Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 13.12.2006 at 15:24 And come on people Overkill is musically quite an average and at times a little above average band. They have a couple of memorable killer songs, but those are all off their first three albums. I never understood why Overkill are lauded so much nowadays, back when they started they were seen as second-tier thrash, and rightly so IMO.
Come on man, at this point Overkill have more right being a thrash band then Faketallica...erm I mean Metallica. The fact that most of they're music isn't very original is highly irrelevant and can easily apply to the musical logic of bands like Iron Maiden: more of the same=good. So why should Overkill have to change for anyone?
New big 4 of Thash Metal: Overkill, Slayer, Megadeth and Lamb of God(Slayer and Megadeth retain they're positions for obviouse reasons).
What criteria are you basing this "new big 4 of thrash" off of?
The sorry state of todays metal and music in general.
Yeah, it has to be a pretty sorry state if Lamb Of God is considered 1 of the big 4. But on a serious note, I have to disagree completely, I think music is more alive than it ever was, theres more bands coming out now than there ever was, unfortunately that means more shit bands, but at the same time it still means theres more and more great bands than ever.
I have a feeling you just contradicted yourself there, but no there aren't that many great good bands coming out nowadays. If bands like Good Charlot and Tokyo Hotel are concidered good bands these days then people may as well shoot themselfs.
Loading...
|
Doc G. Full Grown Hoser StaffPosts: 9718 |
24.07.2008 - 23:36Rating: 7
Doc G.Full Grown HoserStaffPosts: 9718
Written by [user id=26806] on 24.07.2008 at 07:24
Written by Doc G. on 23.07.2008 at 22:42
Written by [user id=26806] on 23.07.2008 at 22:05
Written by Doc G. on 23.07.2008 at 19:32
Written by [user id=26806] on 23.07.2008 at 15:41
Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 13.12.2006 at 15:24 And come on people Overkill is musically quite an average and at times a little above average band. They have a couple of memorable killer songs, but those are all off their first three albums. I never understood why Overkill are lauded so much nowadays, back when they started they were seen as second-tier thrash, and rightly so IMO.
Come on man, at this point Overkill have more right being a thrash band then Faketallica...erm I mean Metallica. The fact that most of they're music isn't very original is highly irrelevant and can easily apply to the musical logic of bands like Iron Maiden: more of the same=good. So why should Overkill have to change for anyone?
New big 4 of Thash Metal: Overkill, Slayer, Megadeth and Lamb of God(Slayer and Megadeth retain they're positions for obviouse reasons).
What criteria are you basing this "new big 4 of thrash" off of?
The sorry state of todays metal and music in general.
Yeah, it has to be a pretty sorry state if Lamb Of God is considered 1 of the big 4. But on a serious note, I have to disagree completely, I think music is more alive than it ever was, theres more bands coming out now than there ever was, unfortunately that means more shit bands, but at the same time it still means theres more and more great bands than ever.
I have a feeling you just contradicted yourself there, but no there aren't that many great good bands coming out nowadays. If bands like Good Charlot and Tokyo Hotel are concidered good bands these days then people may as well shoot themselfs.
Well your talking in a mainstream sense, which sometimes there are good bands still coming out. But frankly I dont pay attention to tv music so I have no idea what Tokyo Hotel is....
About contradicting myself; the first line was a joke, everything except the part about LoG being shit, but yes, there are more great bands coming out than ever, thanks to the internet they are quite easily findable.
----
"I got a lot of really good ideas, problem is, most of them suck."
- George Carlin
Loading...
|
Murder
Posts: 255 |
Overkill is amazing... a thrash fucking legend and a fucking monster , they stay to the roots and keep making an excellent thrash IMO.
One of my fav bands, and well, their last albums has great songs too, I mean, not only the first albums has amazing tracks... their music could be repetitive sometimes... but come on, their sound is fucking amazing
Loading...
|
Dominus The Shooter
Posts: 375 |
15.03.2009 - 21:39Rating: 8
Is a good album.I believe that never they could surpass to horroscope as far as musical quality.
Loading...
|