Andreas
Posts: 334
|
17.01.2015 - 11:07Rating: 10
Interesting review! I'm very much looking forward to this. By the way, on the Blind Guardian forum there's alot fuss about the production being bad (something I don't have an ear for anyway, so I don't care). So it's interesting that you gave this a 10 for production
Loading...
|
Wukk
Posts: 792 |
The review is not what I was expecting based on the single they released. Still makes me want to hear it though.
----
If you're 666 then I'm 777
[URL]http://www.last.fm/user/Joodicator[/URL]
Loading...
|
D.T. Metal StaffPosts: 4193 |
Agree - there are very few albums I like upon first listen but this one got under my skin right away. Great review.
Loading...
|
Zap
Posts: 3577 |
Forgive me if I take this review with a grain of salt, since the single released wasn't very good (even if I don't take into consideration the fact that they didn't release it in stereo)
Loading...
|
Bad English Tage Westerlund
Posts: 62002 |
Gonna judge my self after listening ..booking ticket to ausie and visiting review dude
----
I stand whit Ukraine and Israel. They have right to defend own citizens.
Stormtroopers of Death - "Speak English or Die"
I better die, because I never will learn speek english, so I choose dieing
Loading...
|
John Shock
Posts: 500
|
Nice review!!! Now i have even more curiosity!!!
Loading...
|
Arcesse Eum
Posts: 268 |
17.01.2015 - 19:57Rating: 7
Oh god I'm excited.
----
As above, so below.
Loading...
|
bblitz
Posts: 227
|
Interesting review...Guitars
Loading...
|
Joe Zombie
Posts: 540 |
The single didn't impress me but I'll hold out for the rest of the album.
Loading...
|
AngelofDeth Cyborg Raptor
Posts: 1183 |
18.01.2015 - 00:14Rating: 9
I've always preferred Blind Guardians orchestral tracks over their stripped down heavier tracks, At the Edge of Time is their only album I like in it's entirety so this promises to be a great album to me... Can't wait to get my hands on it!
----
pewpew.. gotcha
Loading...
|
Susan Smeghead ElitePosts: 6941 |
18.01.2015 - 00:52Rating: 8
SusanSmegheadElitePosts: 6941
Interesting review indeed! You more than did your job in getting my interest piqued. I am one of those rare people who think A Twist In The Myth is an absolute gem, and their only newer album that excited me as much as the classics. I love very symphonic music as well so if that is their destination with this record then hopefully it'll become another of the BG greats!!
----
"A life all mine
Is what I choose
At the end of my days"
--The Gathering "A Life All Mine" from Souvenirs
Loading...
|
mikeprado30
Posts: 1284 |
18.01.2015 - 02:09Rating: 10
The hype for this one is growing greatly! I can't await for January 30th!!!!
----
BARDS WE ARE, BARDS WE WILL BE!
Loading...
|
Papa_Ray
Posts: 46
|
I guess I'm one of the weirdos who think A Twist in the Myth is the best album they've released since Nightfall in Middle-Earth. I very much look forward to this one, as a new Guardian album is always cause for celebration.
Loading...
|
OpenMind
Posts: 88
|
18.01.2015 - 13:04Rating: 7
I don't expect nothing else than a masterpiece, like always from these guys..
Loading...
|
R'Vannith ghedengi ElitePosts: 3099 |
19.01.2015 - 03:59Rating: 9
Thanks for the comments all!
Written by Andreas on 17.01.2015 at 11:07
Interesting review! I'm very much looking forward to this. By the way, on the Blind Guardian forum there's alot fuss about the production being bad (something I don't have an ear for anyway, so I don't care). So it's interesting that you gave this a 10 for production
On the production end of things, I think there's an improvement here over the previous two records, certainly over A Twist In The Myth. I suspect that some of the criticism is being levelled at the band again simply because it's (unfortunately) become an expectation that there'll be noticeable production issues on any new record they put out.
For its purposes in blending the orchestral aspect with Blind Guardian's sound, this album is excellently produced, I have to say.
Loading...
|
R'Vannith ghedengi ElitePosts: 3099 |
19.01.2015 - 04:00Rating: 9
Written by Wukk on 17.01.2015 at 12:19
The review is not what I was expecting based on the single they released. Still makes me want to hear it though.
I'd say that the single isn't particularly representative of the album overall.
Loading...
|
R'Vannith ghedengi ElitePosts: 3099 |
19.01.2015 - 04:03Rating: 9
Written by Zap on 17.01.2015 at 17:32
Forgive me if I take this review with a grain of salt, since the single released wasn't very good (even if I don't take into consideration the fact that they didn't release it in stereo)
If it's any consolation, I found it to be the least remarkable track on the record. Still very much an enjoyable and listenable one though.
edit: and as some others have mentioned below you, it's a typical BG track, which I agree with as it's the most typical number on here.
Loading...
|
R'Vannith ghedengi ElitePosts: 3099 |
19.01.2015 - 04:08Rating: 9
Written by deadone on 17.01.2015 at 23:40
Interesting review. The single seemed like more of the same.
More symphonic components + longer songs actually seems like a bad thing to me.
My biggest issue with the last couple of albums is the songs aren't a memorable as in the past. Night at the Opera had a lot of goods one but started the downward trend in interesting and memorable songwriting.
Is this new one any better on song writing?
As they've taken a different approach to the song writing here, with a heavy focus on blending their style with those orchestral elements throughout the record (something which you may have issues with, judging from what you've said) I'd say it's more memorable than A Twist In The Myth overall, and on a par with the previous. It certainly stands out on its own terms in their discog.
Loading...
|
R'Vannith ghedengi ElitePosts: 3099 |
19.01.2015 - 04:10Rating: 9
Written by AngelofDeth on 18.01.2015 at 00:14
I've always preferred Blind Guardians orchestral tracks over their stripped down heavier tracks, At the Edge of Time is their only album I like in it's entirety so this promises to be a great album to me... Can't wait to get my hands on it!
I think you'll be pleasantly surprised by this one
Loading...
|
R'Vannith ghedengi ElitePosts: 3099 |
19.01.2015 - 04:13Rating: 9
Written by Susan on 18.01.2015 at 00:52
Interesting review indeed! You more than did your job in getting my interest piqued. I am one of those rare people who think A Twist In The Myth is an absolute gem, and their only newer album that excited me as much as the classics. I love very symphonic music as well so if that is their destination with this record then hopefully it'll become another of the BG greats!!
Thanks Susan! While I can understand the appeal in A Twist In The Myth, I don't think it meets the BG standard in terms of performance, song writing and production, though I do like the rather "folksier" approach to it (for want of a better word) and it stands out in their discography in that sense, so I'd give it higher points in originality over its defects.
Loading...
|
R'Vannith ghedengi ElitePosts: 3099 |
19.01.2015 - 04:16Rating: 9
Written by Papa_Ray on 18.01.2015 at 08:57
I guess I'm one of the weirdos who think A Twist in the Myth is the best album they've released since Nightfall in Middle-Earth. I very much look forward to this one, as a new Guardian album is always cause for celebration.
There's nothing weird about having our preferred BG albums, no matter which one it happens to be. They have a ridiculously consistent standard as far as records go, after all, and an output well above what's being released in the genre these days. As you say, it's always cause for celebration!
Loading...
|
Susan Smeghead ElitePosts: 6941 |
19.01.2015 - 04:35Rating: 8
SusanSmegheadElitePosts: 6941
Written by Papa_Ray on 18.01.2015 at 08:57
I guess I'm one of the weirdos who think A Twist in the Myth is the best album they've released since Nightfall in Middle-Earth. I very much look forward to this one, as a new Guardian album is always cause for celebration.
I thought I was the only one. Yes. Those are easily the two best BG albums for me, though I accept that we're in the minority.
I have a great feeling about this one. I did already and then this review confirmed it as much as is possible without hearing the actual music. Hopefully it'll make a trio of favorite albums for me!
----
"A life all mine
Is what I choose
At the end of my days"
--The Gathering "A Life All Mine" from Souvenirs
Loading...
|
Zap
Posts: 3577 |
Written by R'Vannith on 19.01.2015 at 04:03
If it's any consolation, I found it to be the least remarkable track on the record. Still very much an enjoyable and listenable one though.
edit: and as some others have mentioned below you, it's a typical BG track, which I agree with as it's the most typical number on here.
Well, that's good then. Your review does make it seem like it's a continuation of the symphonic elements hinted at in the previous album, which is what I liked most about that album in the first place, so this album definitely has a lot of potential to appeal to me.
Loading...
|
GordOfThunder
Posts: 8 |
Looking Forward to hearing this album, liked Twilight of the Gods track, but it sounds like the rest is going to be more symphonic sound, I was wondering if you think they will be able to do it Live on stage ? Will it blend in with the previous album songs or do you think it will have to be done in it's entirety. Which tracks from previous albums do you think they can mix into a concert with the new songs ?
It was said they were using 3 different Orchestra's on the album, can you distinguish any different sounds from each one?
Loading...
|
BlankFile
Posts: 705
|
07.02.2015 - 16:28Rating: 9
Altough it doesn´t reach the quality of it´s predecessor, i think this one is a really excellent álbum. It reminds me a lot of ANATO in various moments. I think we have another BG gem here.
Loading...
|
R'Vannith ghedengi ElitePosts: 3099 |
07.03.2015 - 12:59Rating: 9
Written by Irritable Ted on 06.03.2015 at 19:10
10 for production? You must have an amazing sound system. What ever I have listened to it on it sounds like a muddy mess. There is too much going on and it merges into noise. Nothing is clear, the songs don't stand out. It is like they got Yngwie Malmsteen on production duties.
Yes, I have a good pair of headphones, these. Nothing more amazing than that. There is a lot going on, which is exactly the point. This isn't the recording of a simple four-piece guitar, bass, drums and vocal combo. This is the recording of a band that already uses significant overdubbing, and further mixes within this context multiple orchestras and choirs. To allot adequate space for each of this album's components and give them their audibility is a challenging undertaking, which has been achieved remarkably well here. The instrumentation and vocals are all audible, which is a considerable feat given the complexity of the album's arrangement. To my ears, the production carries the involved content well and clearly.
Loading...
|
mikeprado30
Posts: 1284 |
14.04.2015 - 05:33Rating: 10
Written by deadone on 10.03.2015 at 01:29
Blind Guardian production has been going down the toilet since A Night At The Opera and this new album just takes the cake. Throw in really average unmemorable song writing and voilà: Blind Guardian have released their first shit burger.
It's a matter of tastes. I found specially very amazing At The Edge of Time, The Throne and Sacred Mind, and I love the other songs from the album.
But I agree with you, the production was bad for this one (not so for ATEOT album and the 2014 boxset, at least IMHO)
----
BARDS WE ARE, BARDS WE WILL BE!
Loading...
|
Belegûr Arise In Might!
Posts: 365 |
After listening to this about 6 times, I just still can't get into it. I can't even explain what it is I don't like. I can barely remember anything after every listen and it just seems so forgettable to me. Production is a bit weird and I have a very good sound system, even the layered vocals just seem unimpressive. A shame .
Loading...
|
BlankFile
Posts: 705
|
27.11.2018 - 00:03Rating: 9
I think it´s still a very rewarding and very good CD, with lots of great moments. Off course the good old Blind Guardian days are long gone, but they still kickass. I would put "The Ninth Wave", "Twlight of the Gods", "At The Edge of Time", "Sacred Mind" and "The Grand Parade" as the highlights on this one.
Loading...
|