Dark Cornatus Powerslave ElitePosts: 4330 |
It was never about the lyrics, nor was anyone ever making it an official genre. You have the wrong idea i think.
It was used to classify those bands that are not folk, doom, black or power metal, but a mixture of them. When someone asks me what genre Moonsorrow is, i call it viking metal, and people understand.
Who said vikings played the flute? That is folk metal. Viking metal is basically war themed music, using repetitive riff structures.
Loading...
|
Lucas Mr. Noise ElitePosts: 13427 |
LucasMr. NoiseElitePosts: 13427
It wont cease to exist, as there will be bands playing this and people loving this.
Well, perhaps the name 'Viking' will be forgotten (though I doubt it) but at least the combination of Black & Folk will still be played.
----
SLUDGE. DOOM. DEATH. Wait, what?
"The reason I'm running for president is because I can't be Bruce Springsteen." - Barack Obama
Loading...
|
Promonex Cathemeral ElitePosts: 9720 |
The only point of this article is that sub-genres are bound to disappear because they are sub-genres. Nothing more, nothing less. Thus I don't quite understand why this article is about Viking Metal in particular, a genre that actually has its heydey right now, 18 years after it's been created, and which here in Germany has more festivals devoted to than most other specified genres - i.e. Ragnarök Festival and Ultima Ratio Festival for Viking/Pagan Metal opposed to the Doom Shall Rise Festival for Doom Metal and the Thrash Till Death Festival for Thrash Metal. So why not rather write about the demise of Doom or Thrash Metal instead?
----
All life begins with Nu and ends with Nu... This is the truth! This is my belief! ...At least for now.
- The Mystery of Life, Vol. 841 Ch. 26
Loading...
|
TheSlaughter Account deleted |
TheSlaughter Account deleted
Lets see what ANUS says shall we?
"In part as a culmination of the ideology of black metal, which being a Romanticist genre favors naturalism and nationalism alongside a heroic view of death as secondary to achievement of greatness, folkish and Viking black metal crested the mostly Scandinavian wave of original black metal and gave it room for expansion by incorporating Norse and Germanic traditional folk music melodies into the riff-based metal song structure. Contrary to popular belief, not all of these bands have controversial ideologies, although all embrace nationality and ethnic-cultural heritage, but some have become controversial for their traditionalist leanings. Medieval imagery predominates, as does that of the Viking and berserker mythos, while the music incorporates ancient-sounding melodies and a virile spirit of asserting natural and biologically elitist ways of life. This style flourished briefly and then tapered off into soundtrack-like pieces which resemble a collision between a black metal band and the Dead Can Dance tour bus, using keyboards in layers while guitars provide narrative centering, backed by a rasping, rhythmic vocal. While vestiges of this form exist today, most have been incorporated into bands that resemble faster versions of the 1970s neoclassical (Yngwie Malmsteen) shredder heavy metal with black metal vocals."
REAL Viking bands include:
Isenguard, Summoning, Enslaved, Graveland, Heidenreich and Infernum
As much as I love Ensiferum and Tyr, they arent really real Viking metal. Ensiferum is more or less Extreme Power metal with Viking undertones and Tyr is Progressive Heavy Metal with viking undertones.
Loading...
|
Skald Account deleted |
Skald Account deleted
@TheSlaughter: If you think Enslaved is Viking Metal, then you don't know a thing
Download Manegarm's "I Evig Tid" (from their website) and see what it is about. It has typical VM drumming, guitars and vocals.
Loading...
|
Dark Cornatus Powerslave ElitePosts: 4330 |
Isengard is barely Viking either though, more like Black / Thrash.
Loading...
|
Streetcleaner Account deleted |
Streetcleaner Account deleted
Well, I do think Viking Metal concept had been over-used and abused, and certainly that makes people tired... I used to like bands like Helheim, Bathory and Isengard, but now lost totally my interest on the genre... well, I still listen to Enslaved but they're genre-trascending.
Loading...
|
Marcel Hubregtse Grumpy Old Fuck ElitePosts: 40071 |
Written by [user id=809] on 27.09.2006 at 00:07
Lets see what ANUS says shall we?
Lets first of all FORGET what ANUS has to say about anything shall we?
----
Member of the true crusade against European Flower Metal
Yesterday is dead and gone, tomorrow is out of sight
Dawn Crosby (r.i.p.)
05.04.1963 - 15.12.1996
Loading...
|
TheSlaughter Account deleted |
TheSlaughter Account deleted
Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 28.09.2006 at 16:18
Written by [user id=809] on 27.09.2006 at 00:07
Lets see what ANUS says shall we?
Nah, because they are right.
Lets first of all FORGET what ANUS has to say about anything shall we?
Loading...
|
Mindheist No Longer Human
Posts: 618 |
Written by Promonex on 26.09.2006 at 18:23
The only point of this article is that sub-genres are bound to disappear because they are sub-genres. Nothing more, nothing less. Thus I don't quite understand why this article is about Viking Metal in particular, a genre that actually has its heydey right now, 18 years after it's been created, and which here in Germany has more festivals devoted to than most other specified genres - i.e. Ragnarök Festival and Ultima Ratio Festival for Viking/Pagan Metal opposed to the Doom Shall Rise Festival for Doom Metal and the Thrash Till Death Festival for Thrash Metal. So why not rather write about the demise of Doom or Thrash Metal instead?
Ok, look, you are entirely right. However, i could not speak about all sub-genres, so i choose one particular which is, nowadays, rising and blastin' as, what did the Drone/sludge metal before. And to me, Viking Metal is not like the others sub-genres, it's a beauty, but either way, we must classify its bands as it should even be. Seriously, is it silly to claim that Moonsorrow are Viking Metal? their masterming in an interview with Blabbermouth said Moonsorrow is a pagan heathen metal band. It's just ridiculous...they are black metal, what does these words (pagan, heathen metal) do with that. I really love Moonsorrow, they are perfect, but i have to do it justice. Moonsorrow aren't Viking metal. you get? MS members must know that and every metalhead. Im' not against creating but against forgetting.
And also Thanks for reading my article Promo
Loading...
|
Skald Account deleted |
Skald Account deleted
What the hell? Moonsorrow are one of the best examples of Viking Metal :
And as to them being black metal - that's more than ridiculous. But seeing as people call black metal bands like Moonsorrow, Ensiferum, Children of Bodom or... Red Hot Chili Peppers, it must be the most diverse sub-genre of metal. I'm only waiting until someone labels Britney Spears as such.
And by the way, I absolutely can't stand black metal, while Moonsorrow is one of my favorite bands. Funny how that works.
Loading...
|
Angelique Bitchy Moderator ElitePosts: 3563 |
An interesting article but I don't think Viking Metal is a genre nor subgenre. Genre is something that describes the music, the style and the lyrical themes, term Viking Metal doesn't. It only describes certain atmospehere in the music but it doesn't describe the music like for example power, thrash, death, folk or black metal, as far as it comes to viking metal it can be any style or like usually mix of everything.
If someone tells you that this new band that you haven't heard yet plays viking metal you certainly can imagine the athmosphere of their music right away yet you can't have no idea how they sound musically, it can be anything from folk metal with flutes and harps to black metal with viking themed lyrics.
Terms Pagan/Heathen metal falls into same category with Viking metal and are used for bands that has the very same athmosphere but denies the viking connection (for example Moonsorrow, they're Finns, their influences comes from ancient Finnish history, and as Finns don't have anything to do with vikings that way they don't want to be called viking metal).
I personally use term Viking metal a lot, it's a good way to describe certain type of black/folk/power metal bands that are quite a lot different feeling/sounding from main genre because of their scandinavian culture influences but still, we can't set any clear musical critearias for Viking metal as a genre or even a subgenre so that way it's just a term not a genre.
Back to the article, if your point is that this type of metal is soon to be disappear and forgotten, I really don't think so, we haven't even seen it big yet. In scandinavia the trend is getting old but only now it's ganing international interest in bigger masses, like Promo said there are several festivals for only this type of metal all over the europe.I think it's more like at the moment we are having a kind of quiet period as the first generation of viking metal bands got bored already and are changing into something else and the next generation are still playing in the garages lol
----
I have more faith in my plumber than I do the eternal being. Plumbers do a good job. They keep the shit flowing.
-C.Bukowski
Loading...
|
Skald Account deleted |
Skald Account deleted
Written by Angelique on 01.10.2006 at 02:37
we can't set any clear musical critearias for Viking metal as a genre or even a subgenre so that way it's just a term not a genre.
We meaning who? I can easily point out musical elements, which are responsible for creation of the epic atmosphere. Mostly thanks to checking out numerous viking metal bands and taking a look at what traditional viking music was supposed to sound like, according to Danish and Icelandic reports and musicians who attempt to play such music today.
Loading...
|
Angelique Bitchy Moderator ElitePosts: 3563 |
Go ahead then, give me the clear musical criterias of Viking Metal, what makes it musically different from other genres such folk metal or black metal? What makes some band Viking metal even their lyrical themes don't involve viking culture and then again does lyrical theme make a black metal band viking metal?
----
I have more faith in my plumber than I do the eternal being. Plumbers do a good job. They keep the shit flowing.
-C.Bukowski
Loading...
|
Skald Account deleted |
Skald Account deleted
Sure thing. But first, one thing I have to point out is that what defines viking metal, or in other words what people commonly see as viking metal is based strongly on our perception of the actual vikings. No matter whether we realise it or not, all history, media and cultural influences that spread through most of Europe during (and after) viking raids, have a strong impact on what we perceive as "viking" elements and when those elements appear in metal music, there's a strong tendency to call it Viking Metal. Like in case of Moonsorrow, who are called like that, despite not having viking themes. But here are the elements:
Firstly vocals - The most characteristic style, also rarely found in other forms of metal, is the deep (and often very prolonged) form achieved by neglecting nose while singing. Another form of music that uses this vocal are the working songs. First mention about them comes from Icelandic sagas, today it is performed mostly by the sailors. Modern working song (sea shanty) can be found here. It should well describe what kind of vocal I have in mind. Because working songs were used by workers to add entertaining value to their munduane jobs, as well coordinate their tasks, this style includes many choirs, which often overlap or create background for the lead vocal. Another commonly used form is lead vocalist beginning part of a song, while the choir ends it, or accompanies in the ending part. The best example of this can be found in Ásmegin music. And while I'm at it, chants were also commonly used by the vikings, mostly while performing rituals.
Another vocal style used in viking metal is common among other genres. That would be growls. Sure, it doesn't seperate it from other genres, but it's also important in viking metal. Maybe because vikings also used growl vocals. I know it may sound silly, but it was actually recorded by foreigners who simply hated viking songs. This is my favorite quote (from Arab who visited Denmark in 10th century: " Never before I have heard uglier songs than those of the Vikings in Slesvig. The growling sound coming from their throats reminds me of dogs howling, only more untamed." I suppose this also means their growls were more chant-like than those we hear today, which means there's still place for development within viking metal.
Clean singing other than the one I mentioned is very rare in viking metal. I've heard some bands which used power metal vocals and this may be my subjective opinion, but although I like power metal, together it sounded awful.
Good examples of viking metal singing:
Moonsorrow - "Raunioilla"
Ásmegin - "Til Rondefolkets Herskab"
Ensiferum - "Dragonheads"
Månegarm - "I Evig Tid"
Nomans Land - "Lord of The Seas"
Secondly, drums. This aspect was spread even by TV. In movies about vikings you'll see viking ship, where one person is hitting drums to coordinate rowing. So it's not really surprising that specific drumming makes us think of the vikings. In viking metal this takes a form of a mid-tempo rhytmical drumming. It'll be quite repetetive for the most part, but once in a while you'll hear a more complex interlude. Although more of melodeath, lately Amon Amarth uses some viking metal influences, and this can be found in drumming. If you'll watch "The Pursuit of Vikings" video, the drummer there shows how it looks like.
Good examples of viking metal drumming:
Thyrfing - "The Voyager"
Bathory - "Vinland"
Månegarm - "I Evig Tid"
Moonsorrow - "Raunioilla"
Falkenbach - "Vanadis"
Guitar riffs are usually simple and repetetive, while the melody tends to be epic, melancholic, or seafaring-sounding. Anything goes, as long as it deals with aspects of viking life. This is probably the only element which isn't reflected by traditional form of music (but then again I've heard supposed Skaldic music that actually sounded like that).
Good examples of viking metal guitars:
Ensiferum - "Dragonheads"
Månegarm - "I Evig Tid"
Nomans Land - "Lord of The Seas"
Moonsorrow - "Jumalten Kaupunki"
Greigh - "Ut på Tokt"
Other details. I'll point out several elements here. First of all - non-standard metal instruments. This is usually modern form of what vikings used for playing music (or just making sounds). This includes violins, horns and to some extend flutes. Acoustic guitar is especially common instrument within viking metal. Additionally to make it even more viking-sounding, bands will use warcries, sound of clashing swords and anything that could be heard around 10th century. After all, as long as it makes sound, it can be turned into music. In the end, atmosphere is very important in defining viking metal. And if someone doesn't count atmosphere as something that can define a genre, then he/she can go ahead and scratch out folk metal from the accepted metal genres. Because unlike viking metal, folk metal has absolutely no musical elements that unites all the bands. How do we define folk metal? Metal with elements taken from folk music. How do we define folk music?
[n] the traditional and typically anonymous music that is an expression of the life of people in a community
We can find other definitions, but none will point out any musical elements (and no, using folk instruments alone doesn't make something folk music).
Also to answer questions:
What differs Viking Metal from Black Metal?
Viking Metal is melodic, it has clean sound, uses BM growls only in Black/Viking cross-overs (like Nachtfalke), has slower and rhytmical drumming, uses completely different melodies and deep vocal style that rarely appears in Black Metal.
What differs Viking Metal from Folk Metal?
Viking Metal has epic atmosphere, while Folk Metal expresses life of ordinary people (hence folk, coming from German 'volk'). It's more agressive, usually slower (especially as far as drumming goes), more often uses death growls. It uses deep vocal style, which rarely appears in Folk Metal. It doesn't use 'folk' instruments as richly and the music isn't meant to be 'colourful' and happy.
...I think I wrote too much :\
Loading...
|
Angelique Bitchy Moderator ElitePosts: 3563 |
Yes, you describe good what Viking Metal can be about but still I can't see it as a whole own genre, it's just too messy.. for example Ensiferum, Windir and Falkenbach in the same genre? It doesn't make any sense music vise. All in all, no matter I think it's a real genre or not I don't believe this kind of music would be dying, as long as there are people there is a need to get closer to their ancestors, explore old cultures and especially as long as there are people that loves heavier music there will be Viking/heathen/folk metal.
----
I have more faith in my plumber than I do the eternal being. Plumbers do a good job. They keep the shit flowing.
-C.Bukowski
Loading...
|
Skald Account deleted |
Skald Account deleted
Written by Angelique on 01.10.2006 at 23:11
Yes, you describe good what Viking Metal can be about but still I can't see it as a whole own genre, it's just too messy.. for example Ensiferum, Windir and Falkenbach in the same genre? It doesn't make any sense music vise.
Well Windir is a Black/Viking cross over, Falkenbach Viking/Folk with tint of Black Metal, while Ensiferum Viking/Folk with tint of Power Metal, so they may be different. But in the end, it doesn't matter. Children of Bodom and Rhapsody (if I had $1 for every time I compared those two ) are much different, but both are power metal.
But I think bands that represent VM best are Manegarm, Thyrfing, Nomans Land, Moonsorrow and alike bands. But that again depends on region.
I noticed there's something I'd call "German Viking Metal", because bands from there are similar to each other in a way that they're usually blackened and symphonic version of VM. I mean bands like Wolfchant, Falkenbach, Nachtfalke, Fjoergyn or Equilibrium.
Loading...
|
Promonex Cathemeral ElitePosts: 9720 |
Written by [user id=1868] on 01.10.2006 at 23:45
I noticed there's something I'd call "German Viking Metal", because bands from there are similar to each other in a way that they're usually blackened and symphonic version of VM. I mean bands like Wolfchant, Falkenbach, Nachtfalke, Fjoergyn or Equilibrium.
While I agree that the German Viking and Pagan Metal scene has a specific sound, I don't quite understand how Nachtfalke fit into there. I don't see much symphonic aspects in their music and they are more Black Metal with Viking Metal elements than Viking Metal with Black Metal elements. Also I wouldn't call their music epic at all, unlike Falkenbach and Fjoergyn.
----
All life begins with Nu and ends with Nu... This is the truth! This is my belief! ...At least for now.
- The Mystery of Life, Vol. 841 Ch. 26
Loading...
|
Skald Account deleted |
Skald Account deleted
Did you listen to their "As The Wolves Died" album? Blood And Iron is a very good example of German Viking Metal. But I'd agree that the rest of their albums don't have as much Viking elements.
Loading...
|
Promonex Cathemeral ElitePosts: 9720 |
I must confess, it's been a while since I listened to them. I've listened to "As the Wolves Died" just now and I gotta agree that it does have some thick synthie layers; I still think it's Viking/Pagan Black Metal (Bombensturm, Bergthron) rather than Blackened Viking/Pagan Metal (Falkenbach, Fjoergyn) though. But in the end it just boils down to the question where exactly to draw the border between Viking/Pagan and Black Metal. As long as we agree that Viking/Pagan Metal does have a certain sound and feeling to it, everything's fine. And as long as we agree that Viking Metal will not cease to be, everything's even better
----
All life begins with Nu and ends with Nu... This is the truth! This is my belief! ...At least for now.
- The Mystery of Life, Vol. 841 Ch. 26
Loading...
|
TOUGHEST MEMBER
Posts: 3626 |
Windir is black/viking metal, I wonder wut part is main, Viking metal or black metal in Windir's music. I believe Catamenia is black/viking metal. Epic black metal has structure similarly to black/ viking metal. And, I experience that Black/viking, viking/folk, epic black are same of including of clean vocal, harsh vocal, and melodious
Loading...
|
Judas The Amputator
Posts: 2043 |
JudasThe AmputatorPosts: 2043
Draklar/Skald, you've said pretty much everything that I wanted to say. I'll summarise it somewhat, by saying that VM, while perhaps not being a full-fledged genre in it's own right, still deserves credit as an independent, recognisably different sub-genre. IMO If you listen to one of the 'pure' Viking bands like Nomans Land, Thyrfing, Asmegin or [Viking era] Bathory, then to one of the VM + ?M bands, you can hear a clear difference in musical structure. A band can be Viking without being Black. Sure, the Folk parts will always be there, but it's the type of Folk that sets it apart. And as long as there are bands playing in the style as described by Skald, Viking Metal will exist.
Incidentally, wasn't there a rather exhaustive topic created on this subject in the old forum?
----
"Once the game is over, the king and the pawn both go back into the same box."
Loading...
|
Revenant Account deleted |
Revenant Account deleted
Thyrfing - folk metal
Tyr - heavy metal
Enslaved - progressive black metal
Amon Amarth - mellodic death metal
Thorr's Hammer - doom metal
It's a lyrical theme, not a genre. Most 'viking' bands are either black metal or folk metal
Loading...
|
Doom Raven Account deleted |
Doom Raven Account deleted
How many arguments can possibly annoy the hell out of Doom Raven? Apparently many. Viking metal was actually a lyrical theme first as "Blood Fire Death" is still stylistically black metal. Obviously some bands such as Einherjer and Ensiferum have molded a musical style around this idea which is obscenely cool, but that doesn't herald an exclusivity clause against cross-genre bands. The concept is simple; Amon Amarth play Viking death-metal, Grand Magus are Viking-doom, Enslaved are prog-Viking black-metal, Thorr's Hammer is Viking doom-death, Rebellion are Viking power-metal, Falkenbach is Viking folk-metal amd so on and so forth. Disagree all you want, but my definition quells all debate. And anyone who says we don't need labels for certain styles can go get screwed, sub-genres and their subsequent monikers have been a valuable tool for dialog between fans since the underground began. Many a band has gained a fan because someone heard that so-and-so is a great doom band or a killer thrash band or Viking band for that matter. I welcome your comments as long as you tell them to someone else, i.e. not me. Thanks, your genuflection will be noted. Now kneel!
Loading...
|
Skald Account deleted |
Skald Account deleted
Accidentally I came across this bit on wikipedia when searching for some information on folk music
" Grand, bombastic rhythms with hymns and chants glorifying and celebrating medieval Scandinavian culture and mythology, Viking metal is generally more epic and darker than folk metal. The two styles emerged parallel to one another but remained distinct till the second half of the 1990s when a number of bands began to blend the two approaches, combining the folk melodies and instrumentation of folk metal with the rhythm and lyrics of Viking metal. Not surprisingly, the overlap between Viking metal and folk metal is strongest in Scandinavia with bands such as Moonsorrow and Ensiferum serving as examples. There are still many bands today that pursue Viking metal without bringing in any folk elements and conversely, many folk metal bands that do not entertain any Viking lyrics or imagery. Nonetheless, the overlap has meant that fans of one genre tend to be fans of the other as well, with many websites and communities over the internet devoted to both music styles, as evident by the external links below. A hard rock variation of Viking metal can be found in such Finnish folk rock as Tarujen Saari and Kivimetsän Druidi."
Loading...
|
Doc G. Full Grown Hoser StaffPosts: 9718 |
Doc G.Full Grown HoserStaffPosts: 9718
This in no way explains the title of the article, you put simply as saying "subgenres fade out, viking metal is a subgenre, therefore viking metal will fade out" uhmmmmmmmm ok, well there are so many places to go with it so it will actually get bigger and bigger, for example; I heard Amon Amarth, very viking and I thought that was viking metal period. then i heard Finntroll, using accordian sounding keyboards, i thought id heard everything, then I heard Moonsorrow, using far more epic & large sounding synth, at that point I thought id heard everything, then I heard Turisas, using actual accordians, actual violins, some real flutes, just showing that just because you doubt the ability to create a new sound within this genre doesnt mean it will cease to be.
----
"I got a lot of really good ideas, problem is, most of them suck."
- George Carlin
Loading...
|
Paganblood The Aryaputra
Posts: 1194 |
Viking metal is the thing that aroused interest towards Norse mythology/religion in me.
Good article anyway!
----
that which shines without names and forms...
Loading...
|
Opium Magnet Account deleted |
Opium Magnet Account deleted
Written by Paganblood on 16.01.2007 at 09:09
Viking metal is the thing that aroused interest towards Norse mythology/religion in me.
Good article anyway!
Religion?
Please elaborate on that... I can't think of anything in relation to Norse religion.
Loading...
|
Judas The Amputator
Posts: 2043 |
JudasThe AmputatorPosts: 2043
Written by [user id=12867] on 18.01.2007 at 11:39
Written by Paganblood on 16.01.2007 at 09:09
Viking metal is the thing that aroused interest towards Norse mythology/religion in me.
Good article anyway!
Religion?
Please elaborate on that... I can't think of anything in relation to Norse religion.
Well, think of the common Viking Metal bands (bearing in mind that some of them aren't really Viking Metal at all). Most people, who don't have an actual knowledge of the genre, would have a list somewhat similar to this:
Amon Amarth (not VM), Bathory, Ensiferum (not really VM), Enslaved (not VM), Falkenbach (not pure VM), Moonsorrow, Thyrfing, Tyr.
If you look at these bands' lyrics, there is often a focus on the Norse pantheon or the Icelandic sagas, instead of what many think are the standard 'pagan roar battle kill' themes.
----
"Once the game is over, the king and the pawn both go back into the same box."
Loading...
|
Skald Account deleted |
Skald Account deleted
Tyr aren't really VM either. More of progressive metal (with tint of viking and folk).
And I'd put Ensiferum under "not pure VM".
Songs such as Little Dreamer, Lost in Despair, Dragonheads, or Whitestorm are pretty damn VM
Though Jari certainly pushed them towards power metal
Loading...
|