Comments on my new list welcome.

Can't really comment on this since I don't even listen to 10 Zeppelin songs on the regular. I think the only tracks I really remember are "Black Dog", "Stairway to Heaven", "Immigrant Song", and "Kashmir". Not sure which of those I even prefer... I suppose "Black Dog" or "Kashmir".

Written by Troy Killjoy on 05.02.2014 at 04:26

Can't really comment on this since I don't even listen to 10 Zeppelin songs on the regular. I think the only tracks I really remember are "Black Dog", "Stairway to Heaven", "Immigrant Song", and "Kashmir". Not sure which of those I even prefer... I suppose "Black Dog" or "Kashmir".

That's alright - you can return to this list when you GET THE LED OUT.

I agree with "No Quarter", "Achilles Last Stand" and "Stairway to Heaven". They're probably my 3 favourite Zep songs.

HOTH and II are too low in the list.
ITTOD - Fool in the Rain is hardly the best song, In the Eveneing, Carouselambra, I'm Gonna Crawl are so much better.
Coda ahead of LZII ?!
LZIII first place?!

oh well, it's all a matter of taste, obvious sentence, sorry.

Written by [user id=17278] on 09.02.2014 at 22:56

HOTH and II are too low in the list.
ITTOD - Fool in the Rain is hardly the best song, In the Eveneing, Carouselambra, I'm Gonna Crawl are so much better.
Coda ahead of LZII ?!
LZIII first place?!

oh well, it's all a matter of taste, obvious sentence, sorry.

The rating order isn't by album but by song on the album. So Coda isn't rated as a better album than LZII, I'm just rating the song "We're Gonna Groove" as better than "Heartbreaker", and those two songs are just my favourites on those two albums.

Quote:


The rating order isn't by album but by song on the album. So Coda isn't rated as a better album than LZII, I'm just rating the song "We're Gonna Groove" as better than "Heartbreaker", and those two songs are just my favourites on those two albums.

my bad then, I have to reconsider my answer

Written by [user id=17278] on 10.02.2014 at 08:17

Quote:


The rating order isn't by album but by song on the album. So Coda isn't rated as a better album than LZII, I'm just rating the song "We're Gonna Groove" as better than "Heartbreaker", and those two songs are just my favourites on those two albums.

my bad then, I have to reconsider my answer

Yep, have a re-think about my list. Fair point about my best song pick for ITTOD but the drum groove on "Fool in the Rain" is just so damn catchy. Not a metal song though.

Quote:

Quote:

Quote:

my bad then, I have to reconsider my answer

Yep, have a re-think about my list. Fair point about my best song pick for ITTOD but the drum groove on "Fool in the Rain" is just so damn catchy. Not a metal song though.

So basically is a song list, not an album list.

Since I've Been Loving You is my personal favorite from LZ.
I agree on your Physical Graffiti choices, nice to see Ten years gone get some appreciation.
No Quarter is one of my favorite as well, especially the live version on The Song remains the Same.
I wouldn't put We're gonna groove ahead of Heartbreaker though.

Good choice of songs.

Written by [user id=17278] on 11.02.2014 at 09:22

So basically is a song list, not an album list.

Since I've Been Loving You is my personal favorite from LZ.
I agree on your Physical Graffiti choices, nice to see Ten years gone get some appreciation.
No Quarter is one of my favorite as well, especially the live version on The Song remains the Same.
I wouldn't put We're gonna groove ahead of Heartbreaker though.

Good choice of songs.

Yep, a song list, but I put the albums in there because I wanted the pics and to confirm it's one song per album (with two from PG). Fair point about Heartbreaker being behind We're Gonna Groove.

A nice list, thumbed it up