Written by Troy Killjoy on 25.03.2012 at 16:45

Written by Darkfiber on 25.03.2012 at 07:35
I just don't "get" this album...

Most likely, if you think this is a modern pop album. I hated Crack the Skye and I'm glad they trimmed their progressive influence down for this. It's still one of their weakest overall, but at least they're back to playing a sludgy stoner kind of album.

Mastodon hasn't really been sludge since Call of the Mastodon; Remission to a lesser extent. The Hunter is extremely poppy sounding hard rock. I, on the other hand, am quite sad they moved away from their prog sound, but to each his own.

Written by Darkfiber on 26.03.2012 at 09:47
The Hunter is extremely poppy sounding hard rock.

Poppy sounding hard rock? I'm not going to flame you or anything but I am curious as to how you can make that kind of statement.

Written by Darkfiber on 26.03.2012 at 09:47
The Hunter is extremely poppy sounding hard rock.

Sounds like you just listened to Curl Of The Burl and then checked out some other songs over the top.

Saw them a week or so ago here in Montreal with Opeth on the Heritage Tour. I was expecting most people in the crowd to be Mastodon fans and, while they did get a great response, the night (and the bulk of the fans) belonged to Opeth. Since then, most of what I have been listening to is from those bands.

Written by Darkfiber on 26.03.2012 at 09:47

Written by Troy Killjoy on 25.03.2012 at 16:45

Written by Darkfiber on 25.03.2012 at 07:35
I just don't "get" this album...

Most likely, if you think this is a modern pop album. I hated Crack the Skye and I'm glad they trimmed their progressive influence down for this. It's still one of their weakest overall, but at least they're back to playing a sludgy stoner kind of album.

Mastodon hasn't really been sludge since Call of the Mastodon; Remission to a lesser extent. The Hunter is extremely poppy sounding hard rock. I, on the other hand, am quite sad they moved away from their prog sound, but to each his own.

While I can completely agree they are not as heavy, I am not seeing "poppy sounding hard rock".
They're obviously a band that experiments with their sound, which I greatly enjoy with a band. Bands get boring when they do the same thing over and over.

Written by Sentinel65 on 19.04.2012 at 23:20

They're obviously a band that experiments with their sound, which I greatly enjoy with a band. Bands get boring when they do the same thing over and over.

That's why Mastodon is one hell of a band. None of their albums sound exactly the same, some elements are present from album to album, but every new direction they take adds a lot to their repertoire. At least, that's what I think and feel of them.

Love Mastodon! They've inspired us heavily
http://brahmanda.bandcamp.com/

Written by brahmanda on 24.04.2012 at 02:59

Love Mastodon! They've inspired us heavily
http://brahmanda.bandcamp.com/

Not trying to be a douche, but you should probably post links to your band here
Or just make a new thread here

Written by Darkfiber on 26.03.2012 at 09:47

Written by Troy Killjoy on 25.03.2012 at 16:45

Written by Darkfiber on 25.03.2012 at 07:35
I just don't "get" this album...

Most likely, if you think this is a modern pop album. I hated Crack the Skye and I'm glad they trimmed their progressive influence down for this. It's still one of their weakest overall, but at least they're back to playing a sludgy stoner kind of album.

The Hunter is extremely poppy sounding hard rock.

Did you even listen to Blasteroid?

Weird stuff.

Mastodon definitely went a tad bit away from there prog sound with the hunter, but I wouldn't say they are poppy sounding hard rock. They just decided to "push the envelope" a bit further with the hunter

Written by DIRTYDANIII on 09.06.2012 at 17:29

Mastodon definitely went a tad bit away from there prog sound with the hunter, but I wouldn't say they are poppy sounding hard rock. They just decided to "push the envelope" a bit further with the hunter

Exactly. I dunno what drugs you'd have to be taking in order to classify the material on "The Hunter" as "Poppy sounding hard rock".

Aren't they a prog metal band?

Written by vgmaster9 on 14.06.2012 at 02:37
Aren't they a prog metal band?

They're certainly venturing deeper into prog territory these days, unfortunately.

I liked the Hunter, especially COTB.

DId anyone else think that that the vocals sounded a bit like Ozzy?

Written by Boxcar Willy on 14.06.2012 at 22:28

I liked the Hunter, especially COTB.

DId anyone else think that that the vocals sounded a bit like Ozzy?

you didnt listen to crack the sky, did ya?

there are many ozzy sounding vocals on that album

Written by Unhealer on 10.05.2012 at 21:57

Weird stuff.

That was actually kinda funny.

Great band. It's a shame they've developed a reputation for putting on a live show devoid of stage presence, energy and crowd interaction - all of which was sadly true for when I saw my favourite band at the time

I like some of their heavier songs from their first couple of albums, but they also write some really weird ones that give me a bit of a headache. And I think they have like a 20 minute song where half of it is just silence. I hate when bands do that! Oh well, the guy has great vocals and the drummer rocks the kit on every track!

Written by [user id=138012] on 23.01.2013 at 02:39

I like some of their heavier songs from their first couple of albums, but they also write some really weird ones that give me a bit of a headache. And I think they have like a 20 minute song where half of it is just silence. I hate when bands do that! Oh well, the guy has great vocals and the drummer rocks the kit on every track!

Agree that Brann Dailor rocks the kit. He's very busy with his hands but in later releases has been developing some more laid back grooves that sound good too. He's got a distinctive style to his drumming and it's good to be a bit different from the pack. I reckon he's got a really good voice as well when he does lead vocals. I hope he does some more of that on the next Mastodon album.

Written by [user id=138012] on 23.01.2013 at 02:39

I like some of their heavier songs from their first couple of albums, but they also write some really weird ones that give me a bit of a headache. And I think they have like a 20 minute song where half of it is just silence. I hate when bands do that! Oh well, the guy has great vocals and the drummer rocks the kit on every track!

Which vocalist do you mean? The bass player and guitarist share the vocals and the drummer sings on some songs as well (a very unique aspect of the band imo!)

Written by Darkfiber on 26.03.2012 at 09:47

Written by Troy Killjoy on 25.03.2012 at 16:45

Written by Darkfiber on 25.03.2012 at 07:35
I just don't "get" this album...

Most likely, if you think this is a modern pop album. I hated Crack the Skye and I'm glad they trimmed their progressive influence down for this. It's still one of their weakest overall, but at least they're back to playing a sludgy stoner kind of album.

Mastodon hasn't really been sludge since Call of the Mastodon; Remission to a lesser extent. The Hunter is extremely poppy sounding hard rock. I, on the other hand, am quite sad they moved away from their prog sound, but to each his own.

Tell me how is this poppy sounding and don't you find some prog influence in there



C'mon.. go ahead, tell me I've just destroyed both of your statements Do it !!

Written by Zombie94 on 23.01.2013 at 23:44

Which vocalist do you mean?

I don't actually know, for all I know it could be all of them! I just remember listening to some of their songs and thinking to myself how annoying the vocals can be, especially the album with the white whale on the front. It's just the sort of higher pitched groaning, I don't even know how to describe it.

Written by [user id=138012] on 24.01.2013 at 03:14

I don't actually know, for all I know it could be all of them! I just remember listening to some of their songs and thinking to myself how annoying the vocals can be, especially the album with the white whale on the front. It's just the sort of higher pitched groaning, I don't even know how to describe it.

That's probably Brent Hinds, the guitarist, you're talking about. He has a whiny kind of voice. If you listen to Leviathan you can hear the difference between Troy's voice on Blood And Thunder and Brent's on Naked Burn.

Written by Zombie94 on 23.01.2013 at 23:44


Which vocalist do you mean? The bass player and guitarist share the vocals and the drummer sings on some songs as well (a very unique aspect of the band imo!)

Not as unique as it seems. Kiss in their heydays had all four bandmembers doing vocals.

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 24.01.2013 at 14:16

Not as unique as it seems. Kiss in their heydays had all four bandmembers doing vocals.

If you contemplate metal bands only, it's not really that common. Maybe rare is the word, not unique.

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 24.01.2013 at 14:16


Not as unique as it seems. Kiss in their heydays had all four bandmembers doing vocals.

Well not unique in the sense of them being the ONLY band that has 3 or 4 members singing. But as Unhealer said, you have to admit it is rare in metal to see that many people sharing vocals, especially the drummer! The only other band that I can remember seeing a drummer do vocals in is Bloodshot Dawn. But I reckon you'll be able to name 10 more off the top of you head

Written by Zombie94 on 24.01.2013 at 16:14

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 24.01.2013 at 14:16


Not as unique as it seems. Kiss in their heydays had all four bandmembers doing vocals.

Well not unique in the sense of them being the ONLY band that has 3 or 4 members singing. But as Unhealer said, you have to admit it is rare in metal to see that many people sharing vocals, especially the drummer! The only other band that I can remember seeing a drummer do vocals in is Bloodshot Dawn. But I reckon you'll be able to name 10 more off the top of you head

drummers singing happens quite a bit.
First two bands that spring to mind Exciter and Autopsy

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 24.01.2013 at 16:16

Written by Zombie94 on 24.01.2013 at 16:14

Written by Marcel Hubregtse on 24.01.2013 at 14:16


Not as unique as it seems. Kiss in their heydays had all four bandmembers doing vocals.

Well not unique in the sense of them being the ONLY band that has 3 or 4 members singing. But as Unhealer said, you have to admit it is rare in metal to see that many people sharing vocals, especially the drummer! The only other band that I can remember seeing a drummer do vocals in is Bloodshot Dawn. But I reckon you'll be able to name 10 more off the top of you head

drummers singing happens quite a bit.
First two bands that spring to mind Exciter and Autopsy

Morbid Angel's original drummer,Mike Browning was also the vocalist before he left the band.

Written by Monolithic on 26.01.2013 at 14:03


Morbid Angel's original drummer,Mike Browning was also the vocalist before he left the band.

and he still sang in the band he started afterwards, Nocturnus.
But indee he is another singing drummer