Metal Storm logo
Ad Infinitum - Chapter II: Legacy review

Bandcamp music player

54 users:
Band: Ad Infinitum
Album: Chapter II: Legacy
Style: Symphonic metal
Release date: October 2021

01. Reinvented
02. Unstoppable
03. Inferno
04. Your Enemy
05. Afterlife [feat. Nils Molin]
06. Breathe
07. Animals
08. Into The Night
09. Son Of Wallachia
10. My Justice, Your Pain
11. Haunted
12. Lullaby

I hear a lot of promise in Ad Infinitum, but Chapter II: Legacy isn’t the sound of them realizing that promise.

With many of the bigger names in symphonic metal either going on divisive musical journeys (Nightwish, Within Temptation) or undergoing line-up turmoil (Delain), there’s plenty of room in the genre for emerging bands to make their name. Two such bands that earned nominations in last year’s awards were Seven Spires and Ad Infinitum; although the former was more heralded across the online metal community, it was the latter’s debut record, Chapter I: Monarchy, that stood out to me as the sound of an up-and-coming band with real promise. The heavy Kamelot influence probably played a part in that, but beyond symphonic power metal, there was a more grounded heavy metal approach delivered with a sense of grandeur in many songs, as well as some effective poppier sensibilities. With the sophomore album coming shortly afterwards, I was looking forward to an opportunity to shine a light on a promising artist in one of our less-covered genres, but unfortunately Chapter II: Legacy has left me somewhat underwhelmed.

Ad Infinitum was founded by Melissa Bonny, with the project initially crowdfunded by Bonny. Therefore, the band is unsurprisingly her vehicle, and once again she gives a strong performance throughout. In addition to a powerful singing voice and good ear for vocal melodies, she has expanded her harsh vocal range on Chapter II: Legacy, with regular use of screams/growls, particularly on songs such as “Your Enemy”. This time around, however, Bonny isn’t the only vocalist; there’s a guest feature on “Afterlife” for Amaranthe clean vocalist Nils Molin, and this guest appearance may have indirectly helped me work out why this album isn’t clicking with me in the same way.

As I mentioned above, what I liked about Chapter I: Monarchy was the mixture of Kamelot-esque power metal, grandiose vibes when marching forwards at slower tempos, and successful pop inclinations in some of the vocal melodies. Well, with the sole exception of “Haunted”, there’s no real power metal here, and there’s not much grandeur to a lot of the songs, outside of the symphonic backdrop. Instead, the poppiness comes into sharper focus, specifically in a form not too dissimilar to Amaranthe; even without Molin’s appearance here, I imagine my mind would have gone to Amaranthe anyway when hearing tracks such as “My Enemy” and “Inferno”. Now, as I mentioned when reviewing Manifest last year[/url], I don’t hate Amaranthe; I’ve found some of their earlier stuff to be worryingly addictive. Still, I don’t really see the benefits of venturing in this direction and abandoning the sense of purpose that made the likes of “Infected Monarchy”, “Marching On Versailles” and “I Am The Storm” leave such a good impression on the debut record.

It’s not all bad by any means; I’ve given Chapter II: Legacy a few playthroughs, and find it an easy enough listen that I mildly enjoy. If you are more inclined towards a pop metal sound, I think the quality for that style is pretty high here, with the likes of “Animals” and “Into The Night” having that polished catchiness one might expect from such a record. There’s also a few songs here that I do actually enjoy myself; in addition to the remaining hints of Kamelot on “Haunted”, some of that purpose from the debut record can still be found in the opening song “Reinvented”, and there’s quite a lot of heart in the ballad-esque “Son Of Wallachia”.

Ultimately, though, it’s an album that I only gave more than a cursory glance to because of the debut, and when placed alongside Chapter I: Monarchy, Chapter II: Legacy does feel a bit lightweight and throwaway. I do hope that Ad Infinitum manage to find a good balance between the strengths of that debut record and where they seemingly are wanting to go at present, because Melissa Bonny is a great vocalist and there’s enough evidence in the music they’ve released so far to suggest that they could go some way to filling the void slowly being left in female-fronted symphonic metal by some of the veteran names.

Rating breakdown
Performance: 7
Songwriting: 6
Originality: 6
Production: 8

Written on 28.10.2021 by Hey chief let's talk why not


Comments: 6   Visited by: 100 users
28.10.2021 - 22:32
I'm only on music 05 afterlife and really don't understand the score of the review.

I'm on 8 and starting to totally disagree with the review.
30.10.2021 - 00:51
Bad English
Tage Westerlund
I did not like other albums from them, I did not like album singles either
I stand whit Ukraine and Israel. They have right to defend own citizens.

Stormtroopers of Death - "Speak English or Die"

I better die, because I never will learn speek english, so I choose dieing
30.10.2021 - 23:42
Rating: 7
I agree with the sentiment. The front half of the album, minus Reinvented, feels less energetic than the back half. Their debut had songs I liked dispersed throughout, but here I felt like I was slogging my way through to the good bits. Maybe that's where my disconnect to this album comes from.
31.10.2021 - 00:10
Rating: 7
Written by LifelikeAdvisor on 30.10.2021 at 23:42

I agree with the sentiment. The front half of the album, minus Reinvented, feels less energetic than the back half. Their debut had songs I liked dispersed throughout, but here I felt like I was slogging my way through to the good bits. Maybe that's where my disconnect to this album comes from.

I don't think I'd recognized a front/back half split in quality when listening to it, but looking at the songs I mentioned as highlights, 4/5 are from the second half, so seems like I agreed with your perspective of it
31.10.2021 - 13:53
Fair review, fair score. "Haunted" indeed stands out.
31.10.2021 - 17:29
I'm a sucker for Melissa Bonny since I heard her in Rage Of Light for the first time. It was exactly the same when I discovered Alissa in The Agonist many years back. So for me Melissa can do no wrong so I really enjoy this album. It's melodic and catchy and her voice is gorgeous. Sure you don't have a Marching On Versailles here but it's still a very good album imo. Either way, fair review. Great as always Matt. Cheers!

Hits total: 2412 | This month: 22