Monolithic ♠♠♠
Posts: 669 |
Well you should filter out some people because their outer nature is like a prison nowadays. lol
good review.
Loading...
|
Fritillaria Account deleted |
Fritillaria Account deleted
Written by Monolithic on 27.03.2013 at 12:16
Well you should filter out some people because their outer nature is like a prison nowadays. lol
good review.
I personally think that I COULD have written it better, but I am not allowed to write song by song reviews due MS laws on writing reviews,so I missed some points. But thanks anyhow for reading it.
Loading...
|
Monolithic ♠♠♠
Posts: 669 |
Well if you read my reviews, you can see how unsatisfied I seem when it comes to song-by-song reviews. Personally, I believe it kills all the fun and sucks the joy out of each song if you dissect it. For me, giving an overall impression of the work is much more appealing.
Loading...
|
Fritillaria Account deleted |
Fritillaria Account deleted
Written by Monolithic on 27.03.2013 at 12:35 giving an overall impression of the work is much more appealing.
I agree
Loading...
|
SSM Massacred
Posts: 236 |
27.03.2013 - 15:18Rating: 8
SSMMassacredPosts: 236
Great review, great album. Keep on writing.
Loading...
|
Fritillaria Account deleted |
Fritillaria Account deleted
Written by SSM on 27.03.2013 at 15:18
Great review, great album. Keep on writing.
thank you
Loading...
|
Kheille
Posts: 2
|
27.03.2013 - 20:44Rating: 9
Just listened to the album on youtube, and holy shit is all I can say! How the hell can this mess of different styles and odd noises work so unbelievably well!?
I really hope this can last multiple listenings without getting just annoying.
Thanks for the review.
Loading...
|
Erik M.
Posts: 3104 |
Good review. I didn't hear this (yet?), but isn't an 8 for originality low for this? I know this seems like nitpicking, but it seems from what I've read in your review and heard about this album when it got released that it's incredibly original. Though I could be wrong, since I didn't actually hear it.
Loading...
|
Fritillaria Account deleted |
Fritillaria Account deleted
Written by Kheille on 27.03.2013 at 20:44
Just listened to the album on youtube, and holy shit is all I can say! How the hell can this mess of different styles and odd noises work so unbelievably well!?
I really hope this can last multiple listenings without getting just annoying.
Thanks for the review.
haha that was exactly what I felt in the first time I heard it : HOLY SHIT ! For me it could last perfectly I even find more with listening more. I thank you for reading it
Loading...
|
Fritillaria Account deleted |
Fritillaria Account deleted
Written by Erik M. on 27.03.2013 at 22:47
Good review. I didn't hear this (yet?), but isn't an 8 for originality low for this? I know this seems like nitpicking, but it seems from what I've read in your review and heard about this album when it got released that it's incredibly original. Though I could be wrong, since I didn't actually hear it.
Thank you well I don't think it's really low, only 2 less than 10, is it low ? Well I consider originality in songwriting ,and I don't dare to say that I have heard the most innovative for example guitar melodies or rhythms or pianos but the whole different sounds and noises were mixed so artfully that all of them together sound something very chaotic and beautiful but separately no. Actually one of the points I missed to mention on this review is that I SHOULD have said that the strength of this album is that how they managed to mix and master all these various and different lines together this perfectly.AWH I wish I could explain it better.
Loading...
|
Erik M.
Posts: 3104 |
Written by [user id=130727] on 27.03.2013 at 23:15
Thank you well I don't think it's really low, only 2 less than 10, is it low ? Well I consider originality in songwriting ,and I don't dare to say that I have heard the most innovative for example guitar melodies or rhythms or pianos but the whole different sounds and noises were mixed so artfully that all of them together sound something very chaotic and beautiful but separately no. Actually one of the points I missed to mention on this review is that I SHOULD have said that the strength of this album is that how they managed to mix and master all these various and different lines together this perfectly.AWH I wish I could explain it better.
I think I understand what you mean pretty well. Thanks for clearing that up. And an 8 is definitely not low, but I just noticed the other three points are all 9's, so hence why I was a bit surprised, haha.
Loading...
|
Fritillaria Account deleted |
Fritillaria Account deleted
Loading...
|
Unhealer Eclecticist
Posts: 2311 |
28.03.2013 - 16:08Rating: 9
Quote: I remember from a documentary on musical notes production and history
Do you happen to remember the name of that documentary? I'm pretty interested in that stuff.
Loading...
|
Fritillaria Account deleted |
Fritillaria Account deleted
Written by Unhealer on 28.03.2013 at 16:08
Quote: I remember from a documentary on musical notes production and history
Do you happen to remember the name of that documentary? I'm pretty interested in that stuff.
Unfortunately nope ! and I myself really loved to find the title of that documentary too but I can't remember at all.
Loading...
|
4look4rd The Sasquatch
Posts: 841 |
Too much happening at the same time, and it feels too disjointed. Its a more structured version of Unexpect. It sounds as if my dial-up internet from the 90s was mixed with a bunch of radio stations that don't have anything in common with eachother.
Not my cup of tea.
Loading...
|
Fritillaria Account deleted |
Fritillaria Account deleted
Written by 4look4rd on 30.03.2013 at 19:38
Too much happening at the same time, and it feels too disjointed
that's why I call it chaotic
Loading...
|
4look4rd The Sasquatch
Posts: 841 |
Written by [user id=130727] on 30.03.2013 at 21:34
Written by 4look4rd on 30.03.2013 at 19:38
Too much happening at the same time, and it feels too disjointed
that's why I call it chaotic
See I wouldn't go as far as calling it chaotic because that would imply a lack of structure. I think its disjointed because for the most part you can hear distinct coherent melodies -- but its as if my left ear was listening to classical while my right ear was listening to metal.
I think this is what distinguishes them from Unexpect. This is a bunch of different melodies on top of each with the random factor coming from which melody is going to be in the foreground vs the background, however the melodies themselves are pretty structured for the most part.
Unexpect is the opposite of this. Its generally just one melody that changes unpredictably.
Loading...
|
Fritillaria Account deleted |
Fritillaria Account deleted
Written by 4look4rd on 31.03.2013 at 00:41
Written by [user id=130727] on 30.03.2013 at 21:34
Written by 4look4rd on 30.03.2013 at 19:38
Too much happening at the same time, and it feels too disjointed
that's why I call it chaotic
See I wouldn't go as far as calling it chaotic because that would imply a lack of structure. I think its disjointed because for the most part you can hear distinct coherent melodies -- but its as if my left ear was listening to classical while my right ear was listening to metal.
I think this is what distinguishes them from Unexpect. This is a bunch of different melodies on top of each with the random factor coming from which melody is going to be in the foreground vs the background, however the melodies themselves are pretty structured for the most part.
Unexpect is the opposite of this. Its generally just one melody that changes unpredictably.
well what you said is exactly opposite of what I think about this album.Although I call this album chaotic I would say this is completely an artful organized chaos. They exactly knew where to put which melody or rhythm and or any noise and sound,or any of those different styles of vocals and music genres. I have never tried Unexpected but I may pay close attention to them by what you said. And totally I think this album is not what you like and it's matter of having different taste I guess.
Loading...
|
!J.O.O.E.! Account deleted |
!J.O.O.E.! Account deleted
Nice review ^^ Glad you got around to submitting this.
For what it's worth I always found Unexpect to be pretty boring, but I don't really see them as an especially worthy point of comparison with this band either, because, as you say, their genre synthesis is relatively minimal. Naturally the term "disjointed" is a term that will be eternally bandied around with bands like Igorrr but that disjointedness is not automatically a negative aspect. There are many bands that try to mish-mash different styles together with varying successes, but I found Igorrr to be one of the most seamless in its execution of controlled chaos in that "disjointed" nature. Even when diametrically opposed elements are flung together there is an underlying sense of unity and organised dissonance. Experimental music is thus; the arrangement of abnormal sounds, styles, structures and tones in a way that challenges the listener. Suggesting that the more conventional band, like Unexpect, is more successful because its more conventional and simplistic should never be a valid critique, imo.
Quote: but its as if my left ear was listening to classical while my right ear was listening to metal.
And why is this a bad thing? I love both, and hearing the two in unity is a joy to my ears
Loading...
|
Fritillaria Account deleted |
Fritillaria Account deleted
Written by [user id=4365] on 01.04.2013 at 13:01
Nice review ^^ Glad you got around to submitting this.
Thanks ^ ^ I'm glad that you checked it out.
Quote: There are many bands that try to mish-mash different styles together with varying successes, but I found Igorrr to be one of the most seamless in its execution of controlled chaos in that "disjointed" nature. Even when diametrically opposed elements are flung together there is an underlying sense of unity and organised dissonance. Experimental music is thus; the arrangement of abnormal sounds, styles, structures and tones in a way that challenges the listener.
really well said.
Loading...
|
tea[m]ster Au Pays Natal ContributorPosts: 5266 |
Nice first review. I clicked on it as soon as I saw YOU wrote it
I can't stand this kind of music tho Just npt my thing...
Loading...
|
Fritillaria Account deleted |
Fritillaria Account deleted
Loading...
|
LeKiwi High Fist Prog
Posts: 4115 |
28.07.2013 - 04:07Rating: 9
LeKiwiHigh Fist ProgPosts: 4115
Anyone know who does which vocals?
Loading...
|
Bad English Tage Westerlund
Posts: 62280 |
Written by SSM on 27.03.2013 at 15:18
Keep on writing.
she should, I like her reviews
----
I stand whit Ukraine and Israel. They have right to defend own citizens.
Stormtroopers of Death - "Speak English or Die"
I better die, because I never will learn speek english, so I choose dieing
Loading...
|