Metal Storm logo
Swallow The Sun - Shining review



Reviewer:
8.5

154 users:
7.17
Band: Swallow The Sun
Album: Shining
Style: Melodic death metal, Melodic doom metal
Release date: October 18, 2024
A review by: omne metallum


01. Innocence Was Long Forgotten
02. What I Have Become
03. MelancHoly
04. Under The Moon And The Sun
05. Kold
06. November Dust
07. Velvet Chains
08. Tonight Pain Believes
09. Charcoal Sky
10. Shining

Is the sun shining after I swallow it?  

Finnish doom crew Swallow The Sun have long dredged the human experience for its darkest moments and feelings for inspiration, and used their music as a mirror for listeners to reflect upon. The band's ninth effort, Shining, continues this theme, but this time reminds us that it is possible to find joy amongst the pain. 

Swallow The Sun have long walked a separate path from other doom bands; whereas many groups go for a dark and abrasive sound, Swallow The Sun have opted for a more polished and vibrant sound, establishing for themselves an identity that allows them to stand out from the crowd. Shining has the band's most vibrant production to date, one that retains the doom ethos and heaviness, but gives Shining a unique sound in the doomscape that enhances the listening experience. 

It is clear the band's ambitions are greater than merely releasing another good album, with the mix of songwriting and production suggesting they are aiming to break out of the mould and niche. Shining thankfully matches ambition with quality, making for a highly enjoyable experience that ranks one of the best of the year. 

The sun is bright on tracks like "MelancHoly", a surprisingly poppy-sounding track that nails the balance between pop and hard-hitting, while "Under The Moon And The Sun" has a Katatonia style that slowly crescendos into an epic conclusion that spams the dopamine centre in your brain like a video game player spamming the special move button. When Shining peaks, its heights are some of the highest of the band's career to date. 

The band don't completely cut themselves off from their history, with tracks like "Kold" and "November Dust" bridging the gap and giving old school fans their fix. Indeed, it is the guitar work of Raivio and Räihä that makes the latter another bright spot on an album that shines bright... like a sun. Next to the regular highlight of Swallow The Sun's career in Kotamäki's vocals (which again, remain one of the band's strengths) is the drum work of Raatikainen, easily morphing between the role of bombastic rhythm on tracks like "Charcoal Sky", and subdued on "Velvet Chains". 

There will be some that may find Shining a step too far for the group, breaking the sonic boundaries that have long defined their domain, rather than merely pushing against those boundaries. It is a risk the band are taking, though like many before them that have done similar, I would hazard a guess that this album is the one that nails the sweet spot between new and old sound, before they later lose this equilibrium. 

Swallow The Sun, at minimum, produce one of the strongest doom albums of the year; at best, Shining is one of the strongest albums of their career and will remain a highlight in an already solid and extensive discography.


Rating breakdown
Performance: 8
Songwriting: 8
Originality: 6
Production: 8





Written on 14.10.2024 by Just because I don't care doesn't mean I'm not listening.


Comments

Comments: 12   Visited by: 203 users
15.10.2024 - 08:19
Rating: 8
Interesting review. The 3 singles were a little underwhelming to me. not bad, but they were short and simple. Reading the review, Under the Moon and Sun, Kold and November Dust would be songs I'm most curious about
Loading...
15.10.2024 - 14:16
Archie 666
Only 6 for originality? 😕
Loading...
15.10.2024 - 19:20
DarkWingedSoul
Hehe, yeah i also checked the ratings 2x after reading the closing sentence but if anyone can deliver a great album without being great its them
Loading...
17.10.2024 - 07:31
Dinruth
I've always had a soft spot for them, even after having become as pop-y as they are now.
Loading...
18.10.2024 - 08:28
Rating: 8
Written by Archie 666 on 15.10.2024 at 14:16

Only 6 for originality? 😕

Now that I've heard the whole album, I agree with the review a lot. I'd add Shining as one of the highlight tracks though.

About the originality score... ah, don't want to start another fight here, but yeah I guess MS has a definition for it that I don't quite understand yet.

I love everything they've put out since Songs of the North. It's always recognizably Swallow the Sun from start to end, yet each album has a different style traversing the whole spectrum of Doom metal... very original in my books.
Loading...
18.10.2024 - 09:13
Cynic Metalhead
Ambrish Saxena
Written by The Melting Snow on 18.10.2024 at 08:28

Written by Archie 666 on 15.10.2024 at 14:16

Only 6 for originality? 😕

About the originality score... ah, don't want to start another fight here, but yeah I guess MS has a definition for it that I don't quite understand yet.

From what I assess listening to STS and doom metal in general, STS is often highly rated because of their ability to mix doom's emotional depth with melody and accessible elements, appealing easily to a commerical audience, not to fans who gravitate towards more extreme or experimental sides of doom. While other doom acts push boundaries with more innovative structures or extreme atmospheres, STS tends to rely on tried-and-true melodic and melancholic formulas, which lacks the originality at forefront.
Loading...
18.10.2024 - 16:33
Rating: 6
musclassia
Staff
Written by The Melting Snow on 18.10.2024 at 08:28

Written by Archie 666 on 15.10.2024 at 14:16

Only 6 for originality? 😕

About the originality score... ah, don't want to start another fight here, but yeah I guess MS has a definition for it that I don't quite understand yet.

For what it's worth, as the person you've argued about it over for previous reviews, I would give this album a higher originality score than a 6; this is what I was talking about when responding to you for the Endtime Signals review of what I'd expect a long-running band to do to remain original (take a novel route that distinguishes a release from the albums that preceded it)
Loading...
18.10.2024 - 23:08
Tuonelan
I think I understand where you are coming from when you describe the production on this, especially with the comparison to Katatonia, and I, too, am a fan of Kotamäki as a vocalist. Yet I often find myself feeling dissatisfied with how the production serves Mikko's vocals this time around. I think the layers of processing and pitch correction are covering up a lot of the things he adds to his performances to connect with the emotion of the song. Yes, the production gives the album as a whole more of that warm, pop feel, but it also feels a bit less genuine, and StS has always felt very genuine in the past - sometimes painfully so.

So I'm okay with them being more accessible, and more pop sounding overall (like Katatonia, or Leprous) but I wish it could have been done in a way that left more Kotamäki in the vocals and didn't smooth out the things about his singing that make him so distinctive and interesting as a vocalist. I'd have preferred a lighter touch with the plugins.
----
For ages we have wandered
Under the wings of deception
Too long have we been waiting
For the long winter to end
Loading...
20.10.2024 - 19:39
Rating: 6
metalbrat
Yet to listen but now confused the rating here and by others...🙄🙄🙄
----
In the beginning I was made of clay. Then I bit the apple and they changed me to metal 🤘
Loading...
25.10.2024 - 15:06
Bad English
Tage Westerlund
9th album, maybe they should do 10th and let it rest after?
----
I stand whit Ukraine and Israel. They have right to defend own citizens.

Stormtroopers of Death - "Speak English or Die"

I better die, because I never will learn speek english, so I choose dieing
Loading...
05.11.2024 - 20:42
Rating: 6
nephilim80
Enjoyed the first 2 tracks and Charcoal Sky, the rest were kinda dull. Coming from 2 bangers this was a semi-letdown.
Loading...
07.11.2024 - 09:05
TOUGHEST MEMBER
MY GREATEST BAND OF MELLOW DOOOOOOM
Loading...

Hits total: 3044 | This month: 503