Milena gloom cookie StaffPosts: 4603 |
12.03.2012 - 10:52Rating: 8
Milenagloom cookieStaffPosts: 4603
Doc, y u no drool over Pharaoh like the rest of us?
I guess we have an insatiable lust for high energy trad metal
----
7.0 means the album is good
Loading...
|
R'Vannith ghedengi ElitePosts: 3099 |
12.03.2012 - 13:38Rating: 10
Severe lack of flavour? Blasphemy! This is like downing a bag full of toffees. One of the rare power metal bands these days with any flavour.
Or maybe your right and I just like toffee too much.
Loading...
|
K✞ulu Seeker of Truth
Posts: 2574 |
K✞uluSeeker of TruthPosts: 2574
Ok, so it's legal not to worship this album. Interesting view of this album. I have not listened to it yet, but I will keep in mind the details you mentioned when listening to this one.
----
Savor what you feel and what you see
Things that may not seem important now
But may be tomorrow
R.I.P. Chuck Schuldiner
Satan was a Backstreet Boy
Loading...
|
strade
Posts: 677 |
12.03.2012 - 14:47Rating: 9
Written by Milena on 12.03.2012 at 10:52
Doc, y u no drool over Pharaoh like the rest of us?
I guess we have an insatiable lust for high energy trad metal
I too, of course, greatly disagree with the review. To each his own, I guess.
----
My lo-fi synth project: http://luciddreamer.bandcamp.com
Loading...
|
scaesura
Posts: 174
|
12.03.2012 - 17:27Rating: 9
I give it an 8. Thought it was damn good, but not fantastic. Some of Doc's points are valid.
Personally though I think the album would be better with a better singer. A more melodic one, I suppose. too much Iced Earth in the vocals for me.
Loading...
|
Hammer34
Posts: 14
|
Written by scaesura on 12.03.2012 at 17:27
I give it an 8. Thought it was damn good, but not fantastic. Some of Doc's points are valid.
Personally though I think the album would be better with a better singer. A more melodic one, I suppose. too much Iced Earth in the vocals for me.
Glad to hear someone else say it. Like this band a lot, and certainly think Tim Aymar has chops, but I think his vocals are the thing that holds this band back. They have such a signature, pretty unique guitar sound, but Aymar just has that screechy, often grating, old school metal/hard rock delivery that keeps these guys squarely in that retro camp. Not a Euro-power yodeler, but just somebody with a warmer delivery I think would take their sound and a lot of these songs to the next level. They have a pretty innovative take on melodic metal which I think would shine through more with a vocalist who doesn't scream (literally) old school quite so much (reminds me of Graham Bonnett, Kevin Dubrow, and I just think that kind of vocal style doesn't do justice to this music).
Loading...
|
Lit. Account deleted |
Lit. Account deleted
Why do I have a foreboding feeling this will be come this year's Septicflesh?
Loading...
|
scaesura
Posts: 174
|
12.03.2012 - 21:47Rating: 9
Written by Hammer34 on 12.03.2012 at 18:43 Glad to hear someone else say it. Like this band a lot, and certainly think Tim Aymar has chops, but I think his vocals are the thing that holds this band back. They have such a signature, pretty unique guitar sound, but Aymar just has that screechy, often grating, old school metal/hard rock delivery that keeps these guys squarely in that retro camp. Not a Euro-power yodeler, but just somebody with a warmer delivery I think would take their sound and a lot of these songs to the next level. They have a pretty innovative take on melodic metal which I think would shine through more with a vocalist who doesn't scream (literally) old school quite so much (reminds me of Graham Bonnett, Kevin Dubrow, and I just think that kind of vocal style doesn't do justice to this music).
Aye. Hell, I actually think Pharaoh would be fantastic with a guy like Fevre/Hansen at the vocal helm, or someone like that.
Loading...
|
Hammer34
Posts: 14
|
Quote: Aye. Hell, I actually think Pharaoh would be fantastic with a guy like Fevre/Hansen at the vocal helm, or someone like that.
Me, I think a voice like Andy B. Franck's would be a great fit . . . strong, smooth mid range, but can get up there when he needs to . . . .
Or a guy like Antony Parviainen I think would be another good choice.
Loading...
|
Milena gloom cookie StaffPosts: 4603 |
12.03.2012 - 22:26Rating: 8
Milenagloom cookieStaffPosts: 4603
Written by Hammer34 on 12.03.2012 at 18:43
Written by scaesura on 12.03.2012 at 17:27
I give it an 8. Thought it was damn good, but not fantastic. Some of Doc's points are valid.
Personally though I think the album would be better with a better singer. A more melodic one, I suppose. too much Iced Earth in the vocals for me.
Glad to hear someone else say it. Like this band a lot, and certainly think Tim Aymar has chops, but I think his vocals are the thing that holds this band back. They have such a signature, pretty unique guitar sound, but Aymar just has that screechy, often grating, old school metal/hard rock delivery that keeps these guys squarely in that retro camp. Not a Euro-power yodeler, but just somebody with a warmer delivery I think would take their sound and a lot of these songs to the next level. They have a pretty innovative take on melodic metal which I think would shine through more with a vocalist who doesn't scream (literally) old school quite so much (reminds me of Graham Bonnett, Kevin Dubrow, and I just think that kind of vocal style doesn't do justice to this music).
Interesting, one of the reasons why I liked this so much IS Tim Aymar. I find his vocal style to be a better fit for this music than for Control Denied.
----
7.0 means the album is good
Loading...
|
TrollandDie
Posts: 274 |
Written by Hammer34 on 12.03.2012 at 18:43
Written by scaesura on 12.03.2012 at 17:27
I give it an 8. Thought it was damn good, but not fantastic. Some of Doc's points are valid.
Personally though I think the album would be better with a better singer. A more melodic one, I suppose. too much Iced Earth in the vocals for me.
Glad to hear someone else say it. Like this band a lot, and certainly think Tim Aymar has chops, but I think his vocals are the thing that holds this band back. They have such a signature, pretty unique guitar sound, but Aymar just has that screechy, often grating, old school metal/hard rock delivery that keeps these guys squarely in that retro camp. Not a Euro-power yodeler, but just somebody with a warmer delivery I think would take their sound and a lot of these songs to the next level. They have a pretty innovative take on melodic metal which I think would shine through more with a vocalist who doesn't scream (literally) old school quite so much (reminds me of Graham Bonnett, Kevin Dubrow, and I just think that kind of vocal style doesn't do justice to this music).
Genuinely I feel that these vocals are a great fit for the band. They have a certain abrasive strain to which it feels Tim places a lot of actual effort from his part. A lot of power metal vocalists use a monotonish and often really synthetic sound that makes the music feel bland and dull to say the least.
This band has the power metal elements so I'd see where more melodic/harmonic vocalists would be a bigger asset. Yet, they also play with a thrashy and personalised sound which makes the music, with a lack of a better word on-hand, seem more ''real''. I think Tim allows for some dynamic changes as well and I can't really seem to think of another vocalist out there (maybe Barlow) that could have enhanced this listening experience.
----
Hello, my name is Mr......Snrub and I think it would be a capital idea to invest the money back in the nuclear plant.
Loading...
|
strade
Posts: 677 |
13.03.2012 - 03:05Rating: 9
Written by [user id=101272] on 12.03.2012 at 20:53
Why do I have a foreboding feeling this will be come this year's Septicflesh?
HAHAHA no. Not even close. This band has no where near the amount of fans or rabid support and will mostly go ignored by those not strictly into the genre or in the know. US power metal is no where near as revered as the Euro variety anyway, which is complete and utter bullshit.
----
My lo-fi synth project: http://luciddreamer.bandcamp.com
Loading...
|
Fredd Account deleted |
Fredd Account deleted
I couldnt have put it better myself
Loading...
|