If I have the interface ready for myself next time we meet, maybe I can show you to get some inspiration :)

To be able to "add" to a rating you already gave, instead of replacing it.

I wonder if that would work on MS as a whole

@ScreamingSteelUS: Yeah I do the same as well. It's quite often an 8 that could later transform into a 7 or a 9. Fortunately I actually mostly go to an album page to rate, only to see I already gave it the rating I have in mind.

And yeah having a chart of my various ratings of an album would be fun. Just have to build the habbit, but I'll give it a try :)

rating with a little caveat to myself that I'll have to go back later and investigate it more thoroughly.

Yeah totally agree as well. And while those factors don't objectively change the quality of the album, they would actually be interesting to factor in my subjective perception of it.