This is my top albums (only with those where I gave 8 or more). I will update the list now and then.
Keep in mind that I've only been seriously listening to metal for a few years, and that it's not because an album is recent that it deserves to be on the list any less than a classic of the genre, that doesn't matter to me, an album makes the list when I like it, that's the only criterion that counts.
Bands that appeared more than once:
9: Opeth
6: Finsterforst, Moonsorrow
5: Dream Theater, Megadeth
4: Agalloch, Black Sabbath, Bolt Thrower, Children Of Bodom, Iron Maiden, Leprous, Metallica, Septicflesh, Shadow Of Intent
3: Be'lakor, Blind Guardian, Born Of Osiris, Cradle Of Filth, Death, Haken, Immortal, Judas Priest, Mgła, My Dying Bride, Nightwish, Pantera, Paysage D'Hiver, Porcupine Tree, Slipknot, W.A.S.P.
There’s a few picks I can’t wrap my head around but I’m sure some folks would say the same about my favorites great mix of genres, and I like seeing a good mix of old and new as well. Thumbs up for Kivenkantanja at number one!